Garbarsardar for Philosophers Robe Medal

[Belisarius]

Proposer - Belisarius
Nominated Citizen - Garbarsardar

Philosophers Robe

Members of any rank are awarded this medal by means of a Consilium de Civitates vote and simple majority for outstanding contributions to the common community. The member must be nominated and a case brought forward in the Prothalamos like any other proposal.

Citizens of the community and fellow CdC members, I would like to bring forward the nomination of Citizen Garbarsardar for the honorary award of Philosophers Robe. The case I bring forward is a simple one; one need only go through the posts of Garbarsardar to note the outstanding contributions he has made to the Common community throughout his time within the community.

I trust my fellow citizens will join me in supporting this proposal.

Belisarius.

[Tom Paine]

Aaand as with Sibsy, there's surely no doubt on this one, anywhere, right? For those who don't know him: [user]Garbarsardar[/user]

[the Black Prince]

i'm puzzled

the text quoted clearly indicates a Consilium de Civitate vote, but them nentions the prothalamus. One of those is obviously wrong. Either it meant a Curia vote, in the manner of Opifex, or a CdeC vote in our own chambers, akin to patrician.... but which?

[Garbarsardar]

i'm puzzled

the text quoted clearly indicates a Consilium de Civitate vote, but them nentions the prothalamus. One of those is obviously wrong. Either it meant a Curia vote, in the manner of Opifex, or a CdeC vote in our own chambers, akin to patrician.... but which?

Looks like a patchwork of two systems. I thought it should be a Curial vote but...

Bel, did you wrote this?

[Søren]

I would like to see Garb enrobed.

And I have no desire to see him disrobed.

My decision is clear and perfect.

[Giorgos]

In support....of course...

[the Black Prince]

i'd love to see garb disrobed lol

i think someone either mixed CdeC forum with prothalamus, or Curial vote with CdeC vote.

the only alternative is that the CdeC alone are supposed to debate and vote on this, but in the prothalamus, which makes limited sense...

[Belisarius]

I wrote it.

We debate it in here and instead of moving to a Curia vote it goes to the CdC.

That way we get maximum input.

[Garbarsardar]

I wrote it.

We debate it in here and instead of moving to a Curia vote it goes to the CdC.

That way we get maximum input.

Yep, makes sense then.

[the Black Prince]

you might want to write an amendment at some point, to clarify the language...

[Belisarius]

Why bother? it works and is quite simple to understand. We - do - what it says.

[Elric von Rabenfels]

Add me as patrician support! Now! Get Garb that robe!

[Hotspur]

Why bother? it works and is quite simple to understand. We - do - what it says.

Well, if both tBP and Garb were confused, then it's not quite as simple to understand as one would expect.

Support, for what it's worth.

[Halie Satanus]

Support...but only if Garb does this receiving his robe.

[Garbarsardar]

Support...but only if Garb does this receiving his robe.

As long as I don't have to do this...

[Hotspur]

I think this is more his speed...

[ThiudareiksGunthigg]

Wholehearted support.