EDIT: it seems that every forum has now a thread devoted to the RTW:R, so we shouldn't be the laggards!
My take on the RTW:R:
- the best review I've seen is that of Darren, while the walkthrough by Jackie Fish (eg. this one).
- he mentions the potential issues with moding the map - that would be rather lethal for porting the mod,
- I'd prefer to have a brand new Med3 with map moding possibility.
- my recent experience with TW is rather disappointing: I've played Thrones and stopped after like 7 games (and painting the map, the only time in my life B-), I've played Troy and stopped in the second part of the first campaign (perhaps because of this or maybe of this).
- however, the change of the UI in the RTW:R is really great, really, it seem that steering will really up to current standards;
- if the RTR team would port RTR8 to this game, this would be extraordinary;
- I'm going to buy the game, I think it's worth to have it, have a look, and perhaps to play.
JoC
edit: I have bought the game and played 2 comparatively short campaigns. I think it's a good game, with very good changes but still sporting the biggest problems of the RTW that make me not playing that game (even with the mods):
- very dumb AI, bot CAI and BAI.
- very bad patchfinding in the battles; soldiers also tend to get stuck in the siege battles.
- no recruitment-pools that make rebuilding of an army very easy - you don't care about the loses.
- stack-spam - endless battles as the AI is able to recruit 1 unit per turn per city.
I've forgotten a few superiorities of the Med2 engine over the RTW. In recruitment, it's not only the recruitment pools but also:
I don't like a few UI changes:
- no openable double-sided settlement panel (I like RTW and Med2 way of showing the information).
- going through the faction infos requires a lot of clicking.
- small icons of buildings and no cards deprive of the feeling of a "settlement" I have in Med2 and RTW (and I don't have in Rome2 - small and limited icons of buildings are horrible).
I find the following reviews to be to the point:
- HappyCompyTW
-