The ship limit is pretty confusing and vague, could be easily exploited... Lets just settle for a battle odds limit requirement to be allowed to fight a naval battle (they use it in some communities anyway, such as the russian one, because naval AR is a bit funky).
1:1 is too high, lets say it should be 2:3 or higher for every naval battle (the russians use this limit)? The rule about heroic victories of course still stands.
There are some OP ships, but players cant get more of them. Royal navy is a Royal navy. Historically, it happened quite casually tbh, as technology is everything. Targaryen was given a significant fleet to stand some chance naval wise, but of course he can never win the Iron Throne without allies in Westeros.
Secondarily... you are not an admin ... so you cant add rules anymore. First talk to admins please (me or blue) or discuss it with players.
And Hightower broke a watchtower rule.... It is in a pretty bad spot (north/east of Oldtown) so he gotta replay, sadly. So heads up
EDIT
Also, dont forget Targaryen has about 5 strong armies with zero upkeep. Thats much a bigger advantage, considering most factions dont start wth an army, and it takes crazy amount of time to build one.
EDIT 2
And, I finalized how the Iron Bank works, so check the OP.
Last edited by Jadli; March 05, 2021 at 03:51 AM.
Well, I suggested that myself and Baratheon were given ships of equal status to prevent such measures in the first place. It's not exactly fair that three ships can wipe out twelve, it's absurd and Gimli's suggested ruling rectifies that.
Also, the Targaryen Fleet which was added can still be wiped against said-navy, twenty ships sunken by five? Anyhow, I'd much rather not re-play given the time I spent on my turn, and given that Greyjoy has played too, surely a fine can be put in place?
Last edited by Alertoverlord; March 05, 2021 at 03:12 AM.
This poor little thing is getting rather dusty.
Twenty ships which mostly don't even have half of the stats in comparison to yours, the faction also doesn't have access to war-galleys unlike everyone else. Tyrell, Hightower, and Greyjoy will likely be in the same situation if they were to use their navies on other players, which is why Gimli suggested the ruling.
It would prevent everyone from dealing with such gibberish in the first place and be more fair for everyone involved.
Secondly, if you're 'complaining' about a mod which arguably is in very early-alpha. Perhaps we should start with factions earning 14k every turn?
Edit - Even before the HS began I had tested it. Three Unique Baratheon ships could take on quadruple their numbers and win, it would often be a heroic-victory, but given enough reloads it was a 'close victory' which would result in the sinking of over a dozen ships while the Baratheon fleet would only lose thirty men in comparison on one ship.
Last edited by Alertoverlord; March 05, 2021 at 03:25 AM.
This poor little thing is getting rather dusty.
Bantu, well, your ships cant be simultaneously in every place from Weeping Town to The Whispers, so its not like you are safe
turn send to targaryan (new save)
This poor little thing is getting rather dusty.
Alright, this was added to the rules
To be allowed to fight a naval battle, you need at least 2:3 odds. You are allowed to use maximally two ships with total defence 20 or higher in the same battle (including allied navy).
The second part is to adress the OP ships issue, so that the OP stats dont stack together into the crazy power. Only factions that have three such ships are the Baratheons and Greyjoys, though it applies to allied forces as well.
reminder sent
Tully
Blackhaven under siege.
Last edited by Gimli; March 08, 2021 at 12:26 PM.
Stark!
Gregor Clegane has been defeated in the Riverlands! He managed to escape, but many of his men now will be forced to maintain Riverknight's aquatic museum. Tully, a fate worse than death!
The Riverlands sits in the middle of Westeros, foreign ravens constantly fly over our lands. Some of these ravens carry whispers that become fact when they're shot down.
Client of Lord William. Patron of Mausolos of Caria, Ice Eyes and FrostySOTF
Hey I'm still having trouble with sending turns on this but bantu has got his turn on discord if anyone wants it then DM me there and I'll try to get this sorted out in the meantime
Well, its quite simple, just post a link to it, see how others do it. You can either use directly a link from discord, or just easily upload it to some uploading sites... No big, deal but for the next turn please provide a link
Its problem for example right now, because I cant access the save and clear it for Bantu (who somehow managed to forgot his password in one turn )
EDIT
sent
Last edited by Jadli; March 11, 2021 at 03:38 AM.
https://ufile.io/qzba4yyr
Hightower