Hey guys, turns out I don't have time for this competition. But I had a few more ideas that you people can use, as well as 2 rough unfinished badges you can use as inspiration:
The moderator one is based on a
mycenaean dagger, as are the dark rusted metal and gold inlay that form the theme of the banners.
The citizen one furthermore had its soldiers on the left taken from the
Hirschfeld workshop Krater. That one's still a wee bit too modern for the Trojan war setting (750 BC, whereas the Trojan war was 1200ish BC, but then again, the Iliad and the Odyssee were written down around the late 8th).
One obvious issue is of course, that the two symbols don't totally match, and that the citizen one's a bit sparse on the right side. But it should be good enough for inspiration if any of you need it.
d