While Western Europeans did use lamellar armor, it never seemed nealy as popular as mail, plate, brigadine, or cloth (gambeson). Why, when it was very popular in the East and Central Asia? The Byzantinez also uzed lamellar. Lamellar seems more protective than mail, and easiermto make, yet never seemed very popular.
I was trying to think of some reasons, and here isnwhat I came up with:
1. Initially mail, especially worn over a gambeson, provided adequate protection and was more flexble, so it was performed. If you look at the Bayeux Tapestry, the bows shown are smaller the long bows shown in later medieval illustrations.
2. While mail may have been more expensive, the nobility who could afford to wear metal armoe could afford mail. Those wbo couldn't afford mail likely couldn't afford metal lamellar made do with cloth, i.e. gambeson.
3. Arabs seem to prefer mail because it breathed better in a hot climate, and somwas more comfortable.
4. Later, as bows became bigger as we can see in later medieval pictures, they becsme more powerful. Crossbows too became more powerful, going from footdrawn crossbows of 300 lbs to windlass crossbows with draw weights of as high as 1200 lbs. Also, thr crouched lance starting coming into the picture as well. Simple mail armor no longer was sufficient.
You then started seeing some knights wearing lamellar over mail. But not long afterwards you started seeing plate armor being worn, which provided even better protection.
5. When the lower ranks could start to afford armor, they seemed to prefer brigadine over lamellar. You see in China brigadine replacing lamellar as well. I can think of a couple reasons for this:
a. Brigadine.protected the iron plates from direct exposureto.the weather. If they do rust a little, it is inside the brigadine and rust does not get on you.
b. Brigadine was more comfortable to wear? And a brigadine coat was easier to put on and off, like a normal vest or.jacket?
c. In lamellar you see where the plates overlap and a potential a blade in between a wesk spot? You might see where plates have come loose due to repeated battering. In a brigadine the plates are hidden under cloth snd attacker has to guess more.
Anyone think of other reaons? Or was it possible Western artist just likrd drawing other armors better, and lamellar was really more common thsn we think?