Anyone else feel like auto resolving sieges always favours the defenders?

[arrahik]

I'm playing as Macedon. Have a 20 stack besieging a town with no walls and a garrison of 11 severly weakened units. Every time I auto resolve it shows evenly matched chances and results in a close defeat for me. Tested it 3 times so far. Is it because the garrison has 2 ballistas?

[arrahik]

Holy crap, I tested this 10 times and the same thing keeps happening. What the hell lmao. At one point they had 4 units defending against 18 units. "Crushing defeat" for me - they lost more men and I barely lost 200 guys.

[Whitey McKnightey]

I think auto-resolv should within reason favor the defenders, but this is clearly a bug. You should post this in the bug report thread.

[gdwitt]

Once you lock horns with a town you can run it 100 times; the result will be the same.
Unsiege and try the next turn.

[Palaiogos]

Auto-resolve is kinda broken in this mod. Anyway, as Macedon, why auto-resolve when you can just use your pikes and gain heroic victories all the time?

[Zom]

Playing as Rome, I prefer to build a siege train of several trebuchets, ballistas, and scorpions with some ground troops for defense. Pair the siege train with a legion and lose maybe 200 at most on auto resolve.