JWANT's 2

[JWANT]

I like #2 as well. I'm willing to take OotMM (along with my SE) if Chieftain doesn't want them. If finding players for the other team is an issues I'm willing to take any faction.

[Chieftain Khuzaymah]

It's not that I do not want to take them, perhaps it's easier for you to coordinate if you have SE & OotMM? I can always sub too, if you are too busy.

On the other team I'm guessing themzr takes Harad and Rhun. Then Joe and Adanedhel have to make a decision who plays Gondor and who plays Rohan and who gets Dale extra. Dale is a small faction I believe, so shouldn't be too much work....

I suggest we keep all Mordor lands in play. Now sure about all Isengard lands?

I'll PM Joe and Adanedhel to join the discussion.

[joerock22]

I don't feel like I'm in a good position to make a decision, as I have no idea of the situation of the factions. I will say that playing Rohan or Eriador would be weird for me, since they are the same factions that killed me before. Gondor helped, but only with one small army at the very end. I could play any faction, but my preference would be to avoid Rohan especially.

[Adanedhel]

Scenario #2 seems fair. I'd be willing to play my own faction that I had from the start, where I invested most of my time - Rohan.

[Chieftain Khuzaymah]

Allright so if I'm not mistaken:

Team A:
JWANT: SE & OotMM
Chieftain: Dwarves (&OotMM)

Team B:
themzr: Harad & Rhun
Adanedhel: Rohan
Joe: Gondor (& Dale?)

--------

I just have 2 more points:
1) I'm starting to wonder if the addition of Dale, even though it's small, is not too much? After all, Team B already has all Isengard and Mordor lands and an extra faction in 4vs3.
2) Borders of the map? All lands east of the Misty Mountains and all lands south of the river at Tharbad. Passage from Byrig to Eregion will or will not be allowed?