I say it is, but then again I have no idea what your talking about. Jess Eisenberg is a crap actor you can no way compare him to Heath that at the time of DK already had a Knights tale, Brokeback Mtn, Patriot among other roles under his belt. He was an up and coming actor it was only a matter of time until he got abreak out role.
I dunno. I think he is going to be a very "Jess Eisenberg" Luthor. But I cant really decide if that is a bad thing. No he don't have the chameleon abilities of Ledger, but his version of the character might still be interesting.
Gal is very underwhelming and has only been in a few things,
Yep.
Affleck is a far better director than he is actor,
Not really a big fan either. But then again I can only really remember him acting in
The Town. Pearl Harbor does not really count..
Jeremy Irons has had as many dubious roles as he has good ones etc.....
Jeremy Irons is pretty much the only safe bet they got in my opinion. Hell of a solid but intense actor.
Maybe even a problem since he might just end up out-menacing Affleck as Batman just by his sheer presence lol.
specially when a woman is merely thin(she can put muscle on, it's called working out and getting into a certain kind of shape for a role, good and bad, many have done it), and another is just mostly in movies they don't care for, is hilariously funny.
Well its not only muscle. She also needs to have that confident look, sort of like Xena did in her time. Right now she is just a small girl with a pretty face for the guys to hit on. Lets hope she got the acting chops to pull it off. But preferably it should come
naturally.
Disclaimer: I don't really know squat about comics. I just find this "does the actor fit" discussion interesting.