Horse breeder Guilds, bug or feature?

[Melooo182]

As title says, is this a bug or feature?

;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Tourney01
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = jousting_lists


 Guild woodsmens_guild s 5
 Guild swordsmiths_guild s 5


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Tourney02
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = tourney_fields


 Guild woodsmens_guild s 10
 Guild swordsmiths_guild s 10


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Stables01
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = stables


 Guild swordsmiths_guild s 10
 Guild swordsmiths_guild a 2


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Stables02
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = knights_stables


 Guild swordsmiths_guild s 10
 Guild swordsmiths_guild a 2


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Stables03
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = earls_stables


 Guild woodsmens_guild s 15
 Guild woodsmens_guild a 5


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Stables04
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = barons_stables


 Guild woodsmens_guild s 15
 Guild woodsmens_guild a 5


;------------------------------------------
Trigger HorseBreeders_Building_Completed_Stables05
 WhenToTest BuildingCompleted


 Condition SettlementBuildingFinished = kings_stables


 Guild woodsmens_guild s 20
 Guild woodsmens_guild a 10


;------------------------------------------

For vanilla M2TW some argued that this way the guild is aimed more for factions that can train cavalry on cities but then in SS there is also this:

building guild_horse_breeders_guild{
  levels horse_breeders_guild m_horse_breeders_guild gm_horse_breeders_guild
  {
    horse_breeders_guild castle requires factions { northern_european, middle_eastern, eastern_european, greek, southern_european, }
    {
      capability
      {
        cavalry_bonus 1
      }
      material wooden
      construction  1
      cost  1000
      settlement_min city
      upgrades
      {
        m_horse_breeders_guild
      }
    }
    m_horse_breeders_guild castle requires factions { northern_european, middle_eastern, eastern_european, greek, southern_european, }
    {
      capability
      {
        cavalry_bonus 2
      }
      material wooden
      construction  1
      cost  2000
      settlement_min city
      upgrades
      {
        gm_horse_breeders_guild
      }
    }
    gm_horse_breeders_guild castle requires factions { northern_european, middle_eastern, eastern_european, greek, southern_european, }
    {
      capability
      {
        cavalry_bonus 2
      }
      faction_capability
      {
        cavalry_bonus 1
      }
      material wooden
      construction  1
      cost  3000
      settlement_min city
      upgrades
      {
      }
    }
  }
  plugins
  {
  }
}

Horse Breeder is Castle only in SS?
oposite of Vanilla being City only

Can someone shed some light on this?

[InsaneAbacus]

Most factions can't recruit a single cavalry unit in their cities(ok the mercs)....But in the castles, so it's just more logical/effective

[Melooo182]

hmmm thats sounds reasonable.

And what about the stables and tourney buildings increasing chances for woodsman and swordsmith guilds rather than horsebreeder?

I see some sense for the tourney buildings increasing those as there might have been some archery and swordmanship competitions but then jousting which was probably the main competition was all about horses. And for Stables well it doesn't make any sense at all.

I changed these in my end so stables increase the chances for horsebreeder and jousting increases for both horsebreeder and swordsmith.

[k/t]

"And what about the stables and tourney buildings increasing chances for woodsman and swordsmith guilds rather than horsebreeder?"

That sounds like a bug.