Rome TW Commentaries - Feedback/Replay Submissions

[Vonlin]

Hey everyone, I wanted to share my recently created Total War focused YouTube channel and ask for feedback. I hope plugging my videos isn't against the forum rules, I skimmed them and didn't see anything about it, if so please let me know!


http://www.youtube.com/user/VonlinTheN00b


I haven't done a lot with the channel yet, but I have my first few videos up from Rome TW with many more TW videos to come. I am looking for some feedback on my first round of videos, so pleae check them out and let me know what you think. Provide helpful suggestions and positive criticism!


I will also take submissions of good replays that you think would make interesting commentaries! Please email them to vonlinthenoob@gmail.com


The directory for Rome TW replays if you are a steam user is:


C:\Program Files (x86)\Steam\steamapps\common\Rome Total War Gold\replays


I will accept replays from any TW game!

[Lancy]

Good clear speaking voice, tactical commentary, and good showcase of different factions and maps.The battles themselves would be considered low level, in the tournament playing community anyway. In RTW there's 15k cwb but normal rather than large scale, or there's 31k large scale, no art/ele, 3 zerks, 6 cav. Both are grassy flats.The actual armies, going by the egypt vs rome battle would not be considered competitive. Egypt would bring 6 normal, 2 long range and 2 chariot archers, and would have 4-6 chariots and then maybe some desert cav. Rome would bring 8 archers and jav cav to try and combat the chariots.So from a pure entertainment factor is good, but won't appeal to the competitive community. But then it just depends what the target audience is.

[Vonlin]

Good clear speaking voice, tactical commentary, and good showcase of different factions and maps.The battles themselves would be considered low level, in the tournament playing community anyway. In RTW there's 15k cwb but normal rather than large scale, or there's 31k large scale, no art/ele, 3 zerks, 6 cav. Both are grassy flats.The actual armies, going by the egypt vs rome battle would not be considered competitive. Egypt would bring 6 normal, 2 long range and 2 chariot archers, and would have 4-6 chariots and then maybe some desert cav. Rome would bring 8 archers and jav cav to try and combat the chariots.So from a pure entertainment factor is good, but won't appeal to the competitive community. But then it just depends what the target audience is.

Thanks for the honest feedback, seems very accurate. My personal experience and knowledge tailors the channel for now towards a casual entertainment style, but down the road as I develop I can grow into a more competitive approach perhaps.

[simonsimons]

Very good!

[Vonlin]

Just wanted to say that I've posted several more videos now and am still looking for feedback, more importantly replays at vonlinthenoob@gmail.com