Finally some new debate; I guess the flame in Mudpit about Europe and Muslims caught most of us' attention so no time for a new debate?
Anyway, it is an interesting topic; I have practiced Kendo and fencing before and know a lot of people who practice other types of martial art, and all I can say about my experience is only sabre fencing is still "close" to reality in my opinion (well, you probably can count epee too, since that is a damned heavy sword and a very realistic target area). The closest "realistic" duel I had watched before is two seniors of my fencing club once practicing rapier fencing and it was very interesting to watch.