Mariah vs Christina

OK who is more talented Mariah Carey or Xtina?

In my opinion its a no brainer and Mariah wins going away.

Don't do this Rush Limbaugh - everyone knows Xtina is a goddess - I don't want to see Mariah beaten badly - close the thread somebody!

Is this a trick question?

Xtina any day!

Don't do this Rush Limbaugh - everyone knows Xtina is a goddess - I don't want to see Mariah beaten badly - close the thread somebody!

Have you checked out the sales of The Emancipation of Mimi? Xtina can only dream of such success. Mariah has 17 number ones. How many does Xtina have and how many of those has she written? You saw the awardsd and records of Mariahs I posted. Your post on Xtinas was like one paragraph vs a book on Mariahs.

I would much rather take a shot at Christina... too bad I don't have a gun...

I think the difference is I would commit seppuku at a "Xtina" concert and I might actually like a Mariah Carey concert. Maybe.

And the winner is:

Can we close this thread now?

There's only one way to decide this one:
Put Mariah Carey and Christina Aguilerra (ironic how her "biggest fan" can't even be bothered to write her name out...) in a sealed room with speakers. Hand them both a spoon. Seal the room off, and tell them that if they are to come out alive, they must kill the other. To speed this up, the Crazy Frog will be played at full blast over and over and over again.
If Aguilerra emerges alive, shoot her.

The question is not who is more talented, the question is why the hell do we care?

These Xtina threads have all proved to be rather troublesome and spammy.

:s_closed: