The Trojan War Mafia (Game Thread)

[Double A]

Why would we lynch you? You're white.

[Agamemnon]

[Double A]

EDIT: Or literally.

My post was completely justified.

[dcmort93]

I'm going to Vote: Paladin Vargas due to some of his day one actions. His vote was slightly sketchy.

[Treva ★]

vote: dcmort93

[dcmort93]

1) You might want to bold that one
and 2) Why?

[Spike]

don't you watch MLP? Spike is clearly male baby dragon

[Jarema]

Vve: Visorslash.
you were fighting for a 'lynch place' with Spike, who is innocent. Therefore I think you are mafia

[Jarema]

because some letters were bad above,
vote: Visorslash

[Visorslash]

vote: dcmort93

You're dead, read the update, Cassie.

1) You might want to bold that one
and 2) Why?

Also, Treva is dead, you might want to read the update.

Vve: Visorslash.
you were fighting for a 'lynch place' with Spike, who is innocent. Therefore I think you are mafia

Your reasoning is quite possibly one of the worst reasons to vote someone I have ever seen. And on Day 3 too.

First of all, being in a tied vote with someone regardless of alignment is not an indicator of scum. How can it possibly be? I was trying to get an unknown lynched over someone who I knew was town? In the scenario I had, it was either lynch an unknown or lynch a townie, so of course I'm going to lynch the unknown, because lynching myself would be stupid.

And just because Spike was innocent doesn't mean that I'm mafia because I was in a tie with him. You're saying that the town can't lynch incorrectly then? That's a weird one, I seem to remember them doing it most of the Death Note game.

[Visorslash]

Skivvies/Aga

I would like to hear more from you, what are your thoughts so far?

[Visorslash]

Sorry for the triple post, but I can't edit.

@Jarema

I was fighting for a lynch place with Atheotes in your game on the Org, You know my alignment, was I scum then? No I wasn't. Your reasoning is completely flawed.

[Skivvies]

Skivvies' thoughts: This game is going to be fairly difficult over the internet, since we can't really gauge people like we could if we were all just sitting in a circle playing it. It appears that the Mafia members are being intelligent enough to not post anything that would out them. I'm unsure if we will win this game.

[Visorslash]

Skivvies' thoughts: This game is going to be fairly difficult over the internet, since we can't really gauge people like we could if we were all just sitting in a circle playing it. It appears that the Mafia members are being intelligent enough to not post anything that would out them. I'm unsure if we will win this game.

Forum mafia is certainly different to real life mafia (I have never actually played real life mafia). But there are still scumtells and other things to go off. With only a few deaths so far (one lynch and one nightkill) we don't have that much in the way of concrete, rock solid evidence. But mafia is very rarely based of that.

[Skivvies]

Jarema is too quick to vote for Skivvies' liking. Unvote, Vote Jarema

That oughta shake things up a bit.

[Jarema]

@Visor

I am not saying it is flawless reasoning.
I am only saying it is correct in about 1% of its content. And that this 1% is better than totaly random vote. And I do not have any other idea whom I should vote.
Also, I have bad feeling about you yesterday, and I still have

[Jarema]

Forum mafia is certainly different to real life mafia (I have never actually played real life mafia). But there are still scumtells and other things to go off. With only a few deaths so far (one lynch and one nightkill) we don't have that much in the way of concrete, rock solid evidence. But mafia is very rarely based of that.

I play a lot real life mafia games.
Maybe because of that I am so weak at internet ones

In live mafia, you have a lot of clues to analyze, and you have tense athmosphere. No time to sit, relax, and write 'most townie post ever'.
And, of course, there is nothing similar to mafia quicktopic

[Visorslash]

@Visor

I am not saying it is flawless reasoning.
I am only saying it is correct in about 1% of its content. And that this 1% is better than totaly random vote. And I do not have any other idea whom I should vote.
Also, I have bad feeling about you yesterday, and I still have

Actually 100% percent of the content is wrong. You are saying that because I was in a tie and the other person was innocent, I must be scum. That is terrible logic, about as bad as random voting.

I would urge you to read the thread and come up with something better then that.

[Visorslash]

I play a lot real life mafia games.
Maybe because of that I am so weak at internet ones

In live mafia, you have a lot of clues to analyze, and you have tense athmosphere. No time to sit, relax, and write 'most townie post ever'.
And, of course, there is nothing similar to mafia quicktopic

Internet mafia isn't all that hard though. I mean, I sucked when I first started, but you get better if you keep trying. Forum mafia has clues in it as well, and whilst the atmosphere is different, I wouldn't say it isn't tense, at least in some circumstances.

Mafia Quicktopic is a pretty good advantage though.

[Makrell]

Vote: Skivies

Because i think voting for the first voter is bad, and makes first voterrs less inclined to vote first, if that made sense.
Also i think you might be scum