Opinions needed!

My Mates have started a little band and they made there first demo, a cover of Knockn' on Heaven's door. I'm helping them out and I was wondering if I could get some opinions and feedback from guys here to tell them, it would be really appreciated.

please feel free to make comments on the video's page.

They're good! Very nice cover. A criticism? If any thing, I found it a little fast for my taste, I prefer the speed at which Bob sang it originally.

Pretty good, I liked it. One quip about it, though, is that I didn't like how suddenly he ended some of the words in the first half of the song, or so.

Thanks for that guys that's some useful feeback, I'll get on to the guys I'll suggest to them about doing another slower take of the song and try and work on the the way the words are sung a bit more. Thanks again guys!

If anyone else has any more views please feel free to share them.

Hi again, the guys have done a new cover of knockin' on heaven's door if you'd all be so kind to check it out. I would love to hear so views and feed back on the cover.

There are 2 videos, there are slight changes in each. It would be really helpful if you could say which is best. Thankyou.

Here is part 2 -

I liked version 1 more. 2 was kind of all over the place.