Results 1 to 12 of 12

Thread: [HISTORICAL ISSUE] - 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

  1. #1
    Bagatyr's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Some where in Space
    Posts
    1,623

    Icon5 [HISTORICAL ISSUE] - 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    On this day in 26 July 811 happens one of the biggest battles in IX century .
    The Battle of Pliska or Battle of Vărbitsa Pass was a series of battles between troops, gathered from all parts of the Byzantine Empire, led by the Emperor Nicephorus I Genik, and Bulgaria, led by Kan Krum. The Byzantines plundered and burned the Bulgar capital Pliska which gave time for the Bulgarians to block passes in the Balkan Mountains that served as exits out of Bulgaria. The final battle took place on 26 July 811, in some of the passes in the eastern part of the Balkan, most probably the Vărbitsa Pass. There, the Bulgarians used the tactics of ambush and surprise night attack to effectively trap and immobilize the Byzantine forces, thus annihilating almost the whole army, including the Emperor. After the battle, Krum encased Nicephorus's skull in silver, and used it as a cup for wine-drinking. This is probably the best documented instance of the custom of the skull cup.
    The battle of Pliska was one of the worst defeats in Byzantine history. It deterred Byzantine rulers from sending their troops north of the Balkans for more than 150 years afterwards, which increased the influence and spread of the Bulgarians to the west and south of the Balkan Peninsula, resulting in a great territorial enlargement of the First Bulgarian Empire.

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 


    While Nikephoros I and his army were busy plundering the Bulgarian capital, Krum mobilized his people (including women and Avar mercenaries[15]) to set traps and ambushes in the mountain passes.[16] Initially Nicephorus intended to march through Moesia and reach Serdica before returning to Constantinople but the news of these preparations for a battle changed his decision and he chose the shortest way to his capital.[17] The overconfident emperor neglected to scout ahead. On 25 July his army entered the Varbica Pass but his cavalry told him the road was barred with thick wooden walls and Krum's detachments watched from the heights around.[18] The emperor became panicked by the situation and repeatedly stated to his companions "Even if we have had wings we could not have escaped from peril."[19] Before they could retreat, the Bulgars blocked the valley entrance too.
    Nicephoros, unable to face attacking one of the palisades, simply set up camp, despite his generals' pleading. By the third night, Byzantine morale was shattered, Bulgar troops banged their shields and taunted them.
    On that night the Bulgarians gathered their troops and tightened the belt around the trapped enemy. At dawn they rushed down and started to kill the panicked and totally confused Byzantines. The tagmata were the first to be attacked. The Byzantines fruitlessly resisted for a short time and perished. Upon seeing their comrades' fate, the next units immediately ran away.
    On their way south the Byzantine forces hit a muddy river which was difficult to cross. As they could not find a ford quick enough, many Byzantines fell into the river. The first stalled in the mud with their horses and were trampled by those who came next. The river was filled with so many dead that the chasing Bulgarians easily passed over them and continued the pursuit. Those who passed through the river reached the wooden wall which was high and thick. The Byzantines left their horses and began climbing the wall with hands and legs and hung over the other side. The Bulgarians had dug a deep moat from the inner side and when the Byzantine soldiers were getting across the ramparts, they fell from the high wall, breaking their limbs. Some of them died instantly, others hobbled some time before falling to the ground and dying from thirst and hunger. The Byzantine troops burned the wall at several places but as they were rushing to get across it, they too fell into the moat along with the burning parts of the palisade. Almost everyone perished; some were killed by sword, others drowned in the river or were mortally injured after falling from the wall and some of them died in the fire. Among the nobles killed were the patricius Theodosius Salivara; the strategos of the Eastern armies Romanos and the strategos of Thrace.
    Only a few survived the defeat but the majority of them died shortly after they arrived in their homes. The most notable person to be killed, however, was Emperor Nicephoros, who according to historians died on a dunghill on the day of the battle.[20] Nicephoros' son Staurakios was carried to safety by the imperial bodyguard after receiving a paralyzing wound to his neck.[19][21] Six months later, his wounds finally killed him. According to tradition, Krum had the Emperor's head on a spike, then lined his skull with silver and used it as a drinking cup.










    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
    Last edited by SpyrosM91; January 03, 2012 at 10:16 AM.




  2. #2
    NikeBG's Avatar Sampsis
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Sofia, Bulgaria
    Posts
    3,193

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Hmm, indeed, how did I miss such a round anniversary?
    Here are some pics from the reenactment - it's made by Baga-Tur (who are rather infamous with their "historical accuracy" - lo and behold, the Byzantine, Slavic-shielded, children-eating Spartan ), but if none of the serious groups showed any interest - oh well, our loss...
    Last edited by NikeBG; July 28, 2011 at 07:07 AM.

  3. #3
    Bagatyr's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Some where in Space
    Posts
    1,623

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    it's made by Baga-Tur (who are rather infamous with their "historical accuracy" - lo and behold, the Byzantine, Slavic-shielded, children-eating Spartan ), but if none of the serious groups showed any interest - oh well, our loss...
    they are good at making bulgars but the other thinks are pure fantasy


    I think the Chigots will make it alot more good . But if its modus vivendi ... oh my god ... they will want 100 % proofs for every part of the dress and equipment that was used by the bulgars and even then they will still think that it may not be bulgars and for them this is a pure proof that it doesn't exist

    lets hope they don't find out this mod because they will say that 90 % of the units of the mod have no 100 % acurasy and are rong and when you ask them to show alternative they stop respond




  4. #4
    SpyrosM91's Avatar Despotes
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Patras, Greece
    Posts
    3,675

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Quote Originally Posted by Bagatyr View Post
    The Byzantines plundered and burned the Bulgar capital Pliska which gave time for the Bulgarians to block passes in the Balkan Mountains that served as exits out of Bulgaria.
    and a unexpected coincidence:

    just last night, after i looked at your thread, i was reading the "Taktika" of Leo the Wise before going to sleep (some light reading always help to fall asleep....) ...and in more than one places, he explicitly forbids soldiers to plunder the battlefiled and the city when the enemy retreats... beacause many battles have been lost this way... clearly implying the situation, as the commentator also mentions, of Nikephoros I and Krum...

    Proud Tsardoms Total War: Historian - Coder - Scripter - Mapper

  5. #5
    Bagatyr's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Some where in Space
    Posts
    1,623

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    and a unexpected coincidence:

    just last night, after i looked at your thread, i was reading the "Taktika" of Leo the Wise...and in more than one places, he explicitly forbids soldiers to plunder the battlefiled and the city when the enemy retreats... beacause many battles have been lost this way... clearly implying the situation, as the commentator also mentions, of Nikephoros I and Krum...
    yes but the intresting is that when turks invading the plunder was the main thing that inspired them to go to war and win and do the same with byz,bulgarians,serbians,hungarians and others... battle haven't finish and yet they plunder and was victorius after all ...




  6. #6
    NikeBG's Avatar Sampsis
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Sofia, Bulgaria
    Posts
    3,193

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Quote Originally Posted by Bagatyr View Post
    they are good at making bulgars but the other thinks are pure fantasy
    In my humble opinion, they're not too good with making Bulgars either. Or at least they're good in making only some light Bulgars, who sometimes look like they're out of some cheap Conan movie. The only good thing in Baga-Tur, IMO, is that they have actual serious exercises, including riding, martial arts etc. Then again, that's why they're a "Bulgar surviving school" (basically, boyscouts for teens and young adults), not an actual reenactment group.

    Quote Originally Posted by Bagatyr View Post
    I think the Chigots will make it alot more good . But if its modus vivendi ... oh my god ... they will want 100 % proofs for every part of the dress and equipment that was used by the bulgars and even then they will still think that it may not be bulgars and for them this is a pure proof that it doesn't exist
    Indeed, that's one of the problems with the serious reenactment groups - since most of them actually have academic degrees in history (or at at least still studying it in uni), they've became a bit too pedantic and often rather Western-centric (after all, it's easier to imagine yourself as a Western knight, for which there are quite more sources than for some unknown Bulgar bagatur). Fortunately, as you said, some groups are lately opening up a bit.

    Quote Originally Posted by SpyrosM91 View Post
    and in more than one places, he explicitly forbids soldiers to plunder the battlefiled and the city when the enemy retreats... beacause many battles have been lost this way... clearly implying the situation, as the commentator also mentions, of Nikephoros I and Krum...

    Well, in that particular case, there was no retreating army. IIRC, the sources speak that Genikos first defeated a 12 000 strong army of selected warriors after he passed through the Balkan Mountains and then another army of 50 000 men before the walls of Pliska (obviously an exaggeration). After that there was no resistance, so the Byzantines entered the capital and did their things there without much worry - the emperor was already walking around the palace, thinking how he'll rebuild the city and rename it after himself. It's only later that he found out Krum (who in the meantime kept humbily offering him peace, "take what you want and leave") had amassed a new army (including female militias, Avar mercenaries and Slavic troops from the nearby Sklavinias) and was preparing to ambush him. Besides, Nikephoros I wasn't exactly known as a good general (he was more of a financial guy, IIRC) and he was an iconoclast, from what I remember, so the Byzantine sources aren't very well-disposed towards him either.

  7. #7
    SpyrosM91's Avatar Despotes
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Patras, Greece
    Posts
    3,675

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Quote Originally Posted by Bagatyr View Post
    yes but the intresting is that when turks invading the plunder was the main thing that inspired them to go to war and win and do the same with byz,bulgarians,serbians,hungarians and others... battle haven't finish and yet they plunder and was victorius after all ...
    no... Leo said that the plunder should be gathered by special teams that have this specific job... and then distributed to all the soldiers...


    Quote Originally Posted by NikeBG View Post
    After that there was no resistance, so the Byzantines entered the capital and did their things there without much worry - the emperor was already walking around the palace, thinking how he'll rebuild the city and rename it after himself. It's only later that he found out Krum (who in the meantime kept humbily offering him peace, "take what you want and leave") had amassed a new army (including female militias, Avar mercenaries and Slavic troops from the nearby Sklavinias) and was preparing to ambush him.
    i didn't know that there was such a big time gap between these two events...
    Proud Tsardoms Total War: Historian - Coder - Scripter - Mapper

  8. #8
    NikeBG's Avatar Sampsis
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Sofia, Bulgaria
    Posts
    3,193

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Quote Originally Posted by SpyrosM91 View Post
    no... Leo said that the plunder should be gathered by special teams that have this specific job... and then distributed to all the soldiers...
    What's funny is that the Bulgars (and Magyars), although they're often seen as barbarian robbers, are actually reported (in the Tactica, I think) to not break up ranks in order to loot (like it's usual for the Romans, Franks etc), but instead they chase the enemy until he's utterly vanquished and only after that they loot.

    Quote Originally Posted by SpyrosM91 View Post
    i didn't know that there was such a big time gap between these two events...
    The Byzantines stayed in Pliska for several days, maybe even over a week, I think (I'm not sure, would be better to re-check the sources, but it's certainly several days at the least).
    Last edited by NikeBG; July 28, 2011 at 08:56 AM.

  9. #9

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Well, the romans didn't only plunder. The sources say that Nikephoros was so happy of his success, that he started enjoing himself by torturing and killing women and children. He thought that he has already defeated the Bulgars and In no doubt that helped Krum's tactic success.

    Happy anniversary!
    Proud Tsardoms: Total war Concept Artist.


    Best of my work for Tsardoms: TW [link]
    thinkerman.deviantart.com/

  10. #10
    NikeBG's Avatar Sampsis
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Sofia, Bulgaria
    Posts
    3,193

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    The torturing and killing of the children is particularly believed to be made up by the Byzantine authors who, as I said, quite seriously disliked him. It's not totally impossible that he did it, of course, but it's not very likely either (there's no point in doing so, he wouldn't gain anything, but only lose the morale of his men and any chance of controlling the newly "conquered" population).

  11. #11
    The Noble Lord's Avatar Holy Arab Nation
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Peshawar, Pakistan - Kabul, Afghanistan
    Posts
    7,822

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Very interesting, Khan Krum was an awesome warrior. He almost took Constantinople!
    [IMG][/IMG]
    أسد العراق Asad al-Iraq
    KOSOVO IS SERBIA!!!
    Under the proud patronage of the magnificent Tzar


  12. #12

    Default Re: 1200 anniversary of the Battle of Vărbitsa Pass

    Quote Originally Posted by NikeBG View Post
    Hmm, indeed, how did I miss such a round anniversary?
    Here are some pics from the reenactment - it's made by Baga-Tur (who are rather infamous with their "historical accuracy" - lo and behold, the Byzantine, Slavic-shielded, children-eating Spartan ), but if none of the serious groups showed any interest - oh well, our loss...
    There are multiple reasons for why the more serious groups did not participate:
    1) Their period of focus is the High and Late Middle Ages, not the Early Middle Ages/Dark Age.
    2) Modus Vivendi, the Chigots, Sila and some foreign reenactors specialising in the period actually did a reenactment of the battle a few years ago. Unfortunately, while the Eastern Romans were represented accurately in terms of eqipment, they were overwhelmed by a "Bulgarian" force from Shumen, which to this day holds the dubious distinction of being a worse equipped bunch than Baga-Tur (sheepskins, cauldron lids for shields and 19th century Russian sidearms in lieu of real equipmen, enough said). The serious reenactors vowed to never participate in such a parody again.
    3) The reenactment was organized by the Plovdiv Municipality, and as we say, whoever pays, orders the music. Obviously, the organizers chose showmanship over historical accuracy.

    The result is obviously, quite sad, but at the same time a perfect reflection of the general ignorance of the ordinary people and the political elite in Bulgaria of the country's history, combined with an inability and unwillingness from the serious reenactors to find a way to share their advanced reenactment acumen with a wider audience.

    Fortunately, Total War mods give a better platform to provide the public (or at least the small gaming community) with an adequately accurate representation of what medieval armies and soldiers actually looked like.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •