All Powerful Q
Content Emeritus
Administrator Emeritus
Re: Is the CVRIA...

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
Handing out medals and awards is fine. Voting on membership is fine. But what else does the Curia do? Not much. And there is so much more it could do.
I totally agree with what you're saying Sir GrnEyes! I'm glad someone from Hex has come out and said "hey, Curia - you could be more useful".
We've got some of the people in the Curia who visit the site the most, contribute the most, do the most on the site. It obviously doesn't include everyone in that category but there's a good amount. I'd personally love to see people come up with suggestions that effect the site more than just colour changes - I think there's a culture of not thinking about these things in the Curia, or people are scarred of being lambasted or being told their idea isn't a goer. I personally am going to bring some stuff to the table I think could improve the site myself - however I'd be lying if I said I wasn't concerned that any suggestion would rile anyone doing their job or be seen as the Curia interfering in business nothing to do with them. But I've come to the conclusion if an idea isn't a goer - you don't know until you propose it and we all have a little chat about ideas. Improving a site for users isn't always obvious - especially if you're looking at it from a position of authority at the top, say on Hex - someone could propose an idea and Hex could be like "why didn't we think of that?". I think we all should be more proactive.

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
Once you have responded to 20 PMs, gone through the Q & S, gone through the moderation forums, dealt with 5 forgotten passwords, and the million other things you never see that an administrator does, you simply dont have the energy to start new projects.
Have you considered of upping a few choice moderator's access permissions to deal with these matters? Or hiring up another admin specifically to do these tasks?
I've always found it strange that the head of content isn't an administrator. I remember when gigiagiaigaigia was in charge of content and an admin - stuff was done very quickly and he would have had more support thrown his way in an admin position I imagine. There's an advantage to be had for the top content voice at the top giving feedback - asking for stuff technically that would make the job easier in terms of content creation. News is definitely under-developed for example - the ability to comment on news on the main page should be standard, and there should be more posts more often on relevant core TW matters - previews of Shogun 2 when coming up to release for example. But there's no structure for posting news from what I can see - Aradan does most of it and does a good job, but I think it's a fair summation that if he had a news team producing concise, accurate, objective and interesting news for visitors, it would help hit higher goals of turning visitors into posting members. Would Hex welcome some input in structuring news/technical suggestions on news improvements through Curial decisions?

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
This is where the Curia can and should step in. Just take a look at all the
defunct committees. The only ones the Curia are remotely interested in are the Awards Committee and stuff like peoples rights to post the F-bomb. Nobody wants to make any real commitment to expanding the site because that means putting in more work than merely posting your opinion. It means being in charge of something, organizing it, maintaining it, and helping it grow.
I and various others I think would be up for being more proactive in making things grow. I don't know who is in charge of the Wiki, but I think there should probably be a forum in the Forum Magnum for it - help communicate where articles could be improved and stuff to do - get more people interested in it and editing it. Yeah there's some who debate for the sake of it - but there's others willing to get involved in projects. I think there should have been a curial decision before Shogun 2 setting up a temporary content team specifically to create a thorough guide for the game - as good as a Prima guide. You can't setup something like that easily in terms of manpower without setting up a specific team for it and having the more experienced content authors acting as editors. When a Shogun 2 expansion is inevitably announced at some stage (not DLC) - I think this is something that could add real value. Hell, you could even find a gem who comes in to help specifically on the project, who could add something to their team permanently.

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
But preparing, managing, and overseeing a class is a LOT of work. I probably have over 100 hours in each class I held. If just a few members (3-4) of the Curia stepped up to the plate they could go out and recruit professors and help them get a course done. And the hell of it is you dont have to be a particularly technical person to handle that portion of the work. Yes, some of the classes will be very technical, but getting it organized doesnt require a technical person, just a person willing to keep everything running.
My knowledge of the TWC University classes is personally quite limited - what's everyone else's view on the TWC University at the moment? I need to research before I form an opinion!

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
The same could be said of the
Modding Registry. Hader has busted his ass for years now, with absolutely no help, to make that function.
Then maybe he would like some help? Perhaps integrating a bespoke solution into the system - almost a ModDb that people can comment on with their forum account - the solution to helping Hader might not necessarily be just people to help him - perhaps some better tools to make his job easier/users can navigate the mod registry better? Something like that wouldn't be a simple project, but could perhaps add massive value - if such a system existed, then the talk of covering mods for other games could easily be tried too. Sir Hader of course is the best man to give his 2 cents on the Modding Registry - what I just said may be totally inapplicable.

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
Competitions, tournaments, all kinds of stuff can be done. Beli was going to do some tournament stuff, but with everything he is doing in Content it was too big of a chore to take on. I had requested volunteers to help run that, got a whole TWO responses, and then didnt hear back from anyone. Eventually I said to hell with it and the forums were removed.
Indeed I'm sure CA would throw goodies towards a competition - developers love to do things like that. If the Curia was to think of some ideas for competitions and passed one as a decision, would Hex consider running with it?

Originally Posted by
GrnEyedDvl
Another thing the Curia could and should be involved in is the expansion to cover other games/platforms. This is something we in Hex have kicked around a few times, but the last time the Curia looked at it was in
2007, which I might add is the year I joined, well before I became involved in the running of the site. We are now taking that up obviously, but when its come up before it has always gotten stuck on the back burner for various reasons. Again there is only so much that 7 or 8 people can do.
What games/platforms specifically are you/were you considering? Consoles are very badly covered on the internet in general - mainly because if there's a PC version of something, then it is easier to write content for it - easier to provide support for it etc. Maybe you could consider setting up a sub-forum in other games that takes key news from RSS feeds of some big games news sites, and auto-posts it - you can view the news story in the thread, people can comment on it here - see what people are interested in most in terms of the stories, make moves to support such games more. I've not seen such systems very often but they generally go down well - the News Node is the best example of such a system implemented in my opinion. In any case, traffic in Other Games should probably be encouraged more if any movement into other games/platforms is to be successful in my opinion.