Before you jump on me- I noticed and read the Seleucid elite thread but I think my problems/suggestions vary a bit.
First the cavalry problem: I played with both cataphracts and hetairoi against roman provincial cavalry (the best they can get- don't find the bloody name) and even though the Seleucid units are more expensive I lost because of the Roman cavalry 2 hit points. I find it unrealistic- the best Succesor cavalry (both hetairoi and cataphracts) should wipe the floor with the best Roman cavalry. I know you try to keep the general alive but it's still a problem. Make the Roman general leading a infantry unit?
Second problem: the seleucid elites (Seleucid Thorakitai Argyraspides, Pherasphidai and Hyspapistai) are weaker then the roman regular legionary units (the imperial ones)- might be because of the low numbers but still- it's not quite realistic. A elite unit being defeated by a roman regular army unit? I hardly managed to defeat a antesignani (that's not a late unit and considered light infantry) unit with thorakitai argyraspides on the flat map- head on! At least one of the Seleucid/Succesor elite units should chew the regular legionaries up- I suggest an increase in the number of the unit. They should be able to withstand an elite Praetorian unit, too- not necessarily win but hold the line.






Reply With Quote






