
Originally Posted by
Lord Butters I
My allies in the Fellowship's battle for Helms Deep routed immediately too. I found the best way to play that battle was to hold back your entire army and trickle individual units in and out making surgical strikes. The bowmen exclusively target the very-long-spears Uruk Hai unit (I forget the name), because they're damn near impossible to kill with cavalry.
Keep a large reserve force away from the combat that you can pull units back to and send units in from, attack only with non-head on charges, eliminate enemy archers as soon as possible. It's hard, but it's possible.