vote to rate all total war games

[shadowsnip]

Please rate the following because i want to see the true total war gamers rating on all total war games. I will add them up at 30 posts manually.



THE RESULTS ARE IN!!!!!!!
after talleying up all the votes here there are (took me an hour to process all those numbers)

Shogun Total war 83% average 30 votes

Medieval 1 Total war 82% average 31 votes

Rome Total war 84% 41 votes

Medieval 2 Total war- 84% 41 votes

Empire Total war- 64% 38 votes

Napoleon Total war - 75% 32 votes

Shogun 2 - 87% 38 votes

[Rex Armeniae]

Shogun Total war: 75%
Medieval Total war: 65%
Rome Total war: 94%
Medieval II Total war: 85%
Empire: 60%

What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 90%

[Babri]

Rome Total War : 82%
Medieval II Total War : 93%
Empire Total War : 80%
Napoleon Total War : 80%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 90%

[Ballacraine]

OK now you have changed to %age ratings, it makes more sense to me.

Shogun Total war: 85%
Medieval Total war: 65%
Rome Total war: 95%
Medieval II Total war: 85%
Empire: 52% ( Post patches & Mods 75% )
Napoleon: 80%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 85%

Balla.

[TW Junkie]

Shogun Total war: 100%
Medieval Total war: 90%
Rome Total war: 75%
Medieval II Total war: 50% (only because I never played it much)
Empire: 30%
Napoleon: never played it.
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 75%

[Birdofilo]

Shogun Total war: never played it.
Medieval Total war: never played it.
Rome Total war: 70%
Medieval II Total war: 80% (thanks to the Kingdoms expansion)
Empire: 30%
Napoleon: 70%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 70%

[Voodo chile]

You know it would be easier if you left them blank and had a seperate exemplar

Shogun Total war: 80
Medieval Total war: 75
Rome Total war: 90
Medieval II Total war: 75
Empire: 50
Napoleon: 65
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 85

[Sup With That?]

Shogun Total war: 85%
Medieval Total war: 80%
Rome Total war: 95%
Medieval II Total war: 95%
Empire: 85%
Napoleon: 90%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95%

Yes, I rate them all very highly. My most played/favourite game series of all time.

[Maizel]

Shogun: 80%
Medieval: 95%
Rome: 85%
Medieval II: 80%
Empire: 75%
Napoleon: 75%
Shogun II: 90%

Mostly based on the fun I had with it at the time.

[scubasteve]

Shogun Total war: 95%
Medieval Total war: 90%
Rome Total war: 95%
Medieval II Total war: 95%
Empire: 90%
Napoleon: 95%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 100% I'm really liking the product thus far. They CA team have done a great job of getting me excited for the release despite all the mudslinging in TWC. And yes, I really like Empire and Nappy that much.

[Warkeeper]

Shogun TW; 85%
Med; 65%
Rome; 65%
Med 2; 75% - With TATW mod 85%
Empire; 60% }Bearly played it
Napoleon; 55% }Bearly played it
Shogun 2 TW!; 100% (i think they will nail it)

[Andreius Pretorianus]

Shogun Total war: 75%
Medieval Total war: 80%
Rome Total war: 90%
Medieval II Total war: 92%
Empire: 58%
Napoleon: 67%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 80%

[stradar1]

Shogun Total war: 100%
Medieval Total war: 100%
Rome Total war: 100%
Medieval II Total war: 85%
Empire: 10%
Napoleon: 25%
Shogun 2: 95%

Theres my vote I still think shogun 2 total war will be great no matter the flaws.

[Maizel]

Im surprised alot of people rate Shogun 1 higher than Medieval 1. I find them to be similar, but Shogun 1 much more of an 'expirement' for medieval 1, which I think was, for it;s time, the best in the series.

[daniu]

Shogun : 93
Medieval : 82
Rome Total War : 90
Medieval II Total War : 92
Empire Total War : 88
Napoleon Total War : 85
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95

@Maizel: MTW1 had a really crappy building tree, nearly impossible to get to some of the high tier units.

[Maizel]

Shogun : 93
Medieval : 82
Rome Total War : 90
Medieval II Total War : 92
Empire Total War : 88
Napoleon Total War : 85
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95

@Maizel: MTW1 had a really crappy building tree, nearly impossible to get to some of the high tier units.

I don;t find that to be crappy at all.

I think that's just a cost/benefit choice you make. At least it;s better than 100% urban cohort armies in Rome.

[prince of tarrentum]

Shogun Total war: 80%
Medieval Total war: 60%
Rome Total war: 90%
Medieval II Total war: 90%
Empire: 60%
Napoleon: 85%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95%

[T-Duke]

Shogun : 90%
Medieval: 80 %
Rome: 80%
Medieval 2: 70%
Empire: 60%
Napoleon: 75%

What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 85%

[Tyler_the_Great]

Shogun : never played it
Medieval: never played it
Rome: 70%
Medieval 2: 90%
Empire: 90%
Napoleon: 85%

What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95%

[Herim]

The ones I played


Rome Total war: 95%
Medieval II Total war: 90%
Empire: 75%
What do you think Shogun 2 will be?: 95%