The Circle of the Black Thorn: Angel Mafia (Angel Investigations Victory)

[dcmort93]

Ya ummm warlord is pretty screwed with my Vote Warlord

You missed one Auto

[wideyedwanderer]

I don't like this bandwagon on War lord.

Vote: Askthepizzaguy.

[cpdwane]

I don't like this bandwagon on War lord.

Vote: Askthepizzaguy.

Er, it's not a bandwagon. We have a very good reason.

http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showt...72#post8603072

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't like this bandwagon on War lord.

Vote: Askthepizzaguy.

This is because you are Circle of the Black Thorn aligned, and you want to create a counter-wagon on Angel aligned people.

It's kind of obvious, that's why you're not giving reasons for voting for me.

[JR48fan]

WUUUUZUUUUUUUP

Vote:War Lord

Gary voted, too.

[robbiecon]

Yeah, this is what makes me think it's Angels, Circle and Mafia. The game simply makes no sense otherwise, unless it is simply horrendously designed. And I trust auto to make a game that isn't horrendously designed.



Even though I've kinda proved that that makes absolutely no sense? Unless you'd like to refute my argument.

I mean, hey, you could be right, but I'd at least like to see some discussion of it, rather than what seems to be a simple assumption contradicting logic as made in your post here.

Sorry Camikaze, I hadn't seen your argument. And I guess mafia as an imbalancing factor makes sense, and it means this game isn't just a carbon copy of Rebel Jeb's.

[Gary141]

25 hours remaining
Vote Tally:
Warlord: 6-Jr48fan, Nictel, Skooma Addict, classical_hero, robbiecon, TheFlax
Atpg: 2- Camikaze, Warlord
Nictel:1- Atpg
Not Voting: 5- Secura, dcmort93, Gary141, Wideyedwanderer, Treva

If Gary doesn't post today, he will be replaced.

I posted thrice, though.

[Spartan90]

Yeah, I thought Gary had posted at least a couple times.. Nevertheless, if someone goes inactive, I'm ready to replace.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Should I assume those not voting are Circle of the Black Thorn people?

Especially if they already posted?

Methinks they don't want to see a teammate die, but don't want to vote for fear of hitting their own teammate.

[Askthepizzaguy]

unvote, vote: War Lord

Since it wasn't counted the first time.

[wideyedwanderer]

Er, it's not a bandwagon. We have a very good reason.

http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showt...72#post8603072

I saw that, and I responded before. I don't think that's a good reason at all. Circle does not necessarily mean mafia.

This is because you are Circle of the Black Thorn aligned, and you want to create a counter-wagon on Angel aligned people.

It's kind of obvious, that's why you're not giving reasons for voting for me.

The reason I voted for you was because you were the only other person with even a few votes, so it was really between two options: War lord or you.

[Askthepizzaguy]

The reason I voted for you was because you were the only other person with even a few votes, so it was really between two options: War lord or you.

So your reason for voting for me is specifically because I am not War Lord.

That's a heck of a good case.

Your real reason for voting for me is because War Lord is Black Thorn, and you don't want Black Thorn people to die.

Therefore, you're Black Thorn. Why are you EVEN DENYING IT?

[Treva ★]

Should I assume those not voting are Circle of the Black Thorn people?

Especially if they already posted?

Methinks they don't want to see a teammate die, but don't want to vote for fear of hitting their own teammate.

Or else they're completely clueless, like me

[Askthepizzaguy]

Or else they're completely clueless, like me

Well it would probably be better if the Angel people behaved in a varied manner, so as not to tip off the Black Thorn people who they are. At least until more of them have died than we have.

It is.... too late for me, Treva. But you can use the dark side of the force to save yourself from certain death.

[Treva ★]

I don't kinda like that much, Mr. pizzaman. Anyway, it's late at night and I have a long RL day ahead of me. Bye!

[wideyedwanderer]

Why are you EVEN DENYING IT?

I never denied it.

Well it would probably be better if the Angel people behaved in a varied manner, so as not to tip off the Black Thorn people who they are. At least until more of them have died than we have.

It is.... too late for me, Treva. But you can use the dark side of the force to save yourself from certain death.

I already know who isn't black thorn, so there's no point in trying to hide it. In fact, all of the Black Thorn should know who they shouldn't be voting for, so don't lynch your own teammates.

Whatever the case, there should be 7 Black Thorn, 7 Angels, which leaves 2...other roles. The 2 extra roles are probably seeking to outlive both teams.

Honestly I am confused by this game.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I never denied it.

Excellent. You'll be next, wideyed.




Now, are we supposed to be working together to destroy a third party, or.... is this just a straight-up war?

We could postpone such a war until after the mafia are dead. But you guys already have a lead over the Angels so I'm afraid War lord has to go.

[wideyedwanderer]

Excellent. You'll be next, wideyed.




Now, are we supposed to be working together to destroy a third party, or.... is this just a straight-up war?

We could postpone such a war until after the mafia are dead. But you guys already have a lead over the Angels so I'm afraid War lord has to go.

As I said before, I do think there are at least 2 players in a third party that both sides want removed. So it's probably best to eliminate those two as soon as possible.

[Askthepizzaguy]

As I said before, I do think there are at least 2 third parties that both sides want removed. So it's probably best to eliminate those two as soon as possible.

It's not me. I pretty much didn't understand this game and outed myself as Angel. If I were mafia I would have understood the game setup and not claimed anyone.

WIFOM arguments aside, that's the truth.

[Nictel]

I assume all Black Thorn need to eliminate Angel Investigations and vice versa. So outing yourself as on or the other only helps the other side. I don't think there is a mafia or town. Just two warring parties with a third for balance.