Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 94

Thread: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Welcome guys...

    The truth is that I gave this thing a long thought and if this would be of any interest for other players but then I flimsy remembered a thread where this was mentioned and I think that I recall a few who where not unkeen of having this for their Roman Legions so since I have finished it I thought I share it with those who are interested.

    History
    HISTORY:
    One of the great advantages of the Roman Legions where their training, discipline and equipment.
    They fought both in tight formations,where the men had direct contact with their neighbour, and in opposition to the rigid phalanx, in more loose formation which enabled them to outmaneuver the unflexible phalanx formations for example kicking some serious ass in Greece and take over the entire thing.
    The vanilla "default" formation represents more the ancient loose formation than a tight formation where men are in closed ranks...on the other side the vanilla "loose" formation for Legionaries is probably the most useless feature in the game as I dont know of any player ever to use it for whatever reasonable purpose and probably they never fought that way,too. LOL.. being ambushed is a different thing of course...


    Game Related
    GAME RELATED:
    While Shieldwall became available with BI.exe all players with either TW.exe or Alex.exe could not make use of it and even if implemented in BI.exe for Roman Legions they had to give up on the Testudo Formation as there is just one button for the special ability. Something which is sort of an unacceptable compromise as Testudo is part of the Legions way of fighting and maybe one of the most famous ancient formations...not to mention that it probably will come in very handy in the later game when facing Parthians


    Why only Legions,Praetorians and Triarii ?
    WHY ONLY HAMATA SEGMENTATA, PRAETORIAN TRIARII WILL MAKE SHIELDWALL ?
    This is meant to reflect that with the Marian Reforms as well Roman Battle Tactics evolved and that from this moment on the normal heavy infantry would make use of advanced tactics which in the Polybian System only where used by elite units like the Triarii.



    What have I done ?
    WHAT HAS BEEN DONE ?
    I implemented a "fake" Shieldwall Formation working with all .exe for the Hamata and Segmentata Legions, Early Praetorains,
    Late Praetorians, Republican Triarii ( In BI.exe the Republican Triarii have Shieldwall anyway) and Allied Triari while maintaining the other important Formations like Testudo, Guard or default Formation.

    IMPOTANT TO NOTICE:
    This Shieldwall is not the one implemented with BI.exe and therefore units will not hide permanently behind their shields. This is only permanent in the implemented special abilitys like "Testudo" or "Shieldwall for BI.exe" but once the enemy gets close enough they will forward their shields and from then on it works in the same way as the original and gives a few nice advantages when used properly, especially to such highly trained units like the Numbered Roman Legions.
    Only "loose" Formation will not be available anymore for these units....I dont think its a great loss...
    The RTW Veterans know that this has been used many times before in the similar manner in other mods like SPQR and is not new stuff but I wanted it for RSII. Unfortunately there is no tutorial on this particular issue
    so I really had to have a close look and eventually found out how this could be done.
    Its not a great deal (if you know how,of course) but it can bring another great facete to the tactical tools the player can use during battle.

    As well I implemented a new button to the User Interface replacing the

    "tight" and "loose" Formation button with a new button with three overlapping Roman Shields
    referring to be in "Default" or "Shieldwall" Formation or "tight" and "loose" for all other Roman and Aux. Units.

    So for the Units able to make use of this ability the highlighted button means Shieldwall activated and if grayed out Shieldwall Inactive=Default Formation.


    As there is only one interface for all Roman units this means that ALL other Roman Units have the Shieldwall button highlighted when setted to loose.

    Grayed out is the deafult position for all other units.

    In the following for Shieldwall "On" or "Off" I will refer to this as zipped or unzipped.


    1. Formation
    1. FORMATION
    Lets have a look at the different size for the unit when zipped or unzipped....
    I used Legio I Germanica. Left picture is default Formation and right picture in "Shieldwall" when the enemy is closing in.
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 


    Its really nice to see how their Gladius stick out of the wall of Shields and that Legionaries are shoulder on shoulder.

    This Formation can withstand a 3:1 superiority without being pushed back as the second line is forwarding its shields into the back of the first line and so on herby duplicating the mass of the front units.
    Very handy especially against swarming Units of Barbarian Factions who normally manage to slip into the cohorts ranks and pushing them back when outnumbering them.
    As well it gives a nice additional protection against arrows or javelines thrown at them...so your casualties through shelling will drop considerably.


    2. New Interface
    2. NEW INTERFACE
    I think we all know the buttons and will see the difference instantly.
    The "tight" and "loose" Formation button on the top left of the "Testudo" button has gone and there is a new button. "Shieldwall" or "Shieldwall off" respectively "Default Ranks" or "Loose" (for all other units)
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 


    3.Quickguide
    3. QUICK GUIDE
    When arranging for battle get in mind that when you zip the units they will be alot smaller.

    A line of 5 zipped or unzipped cohorts may look like this:

    -------zip------------zip------------zip------------zip------------zip--------

    ----unzipped---unzipped---unzipped---unzipped---unzipped----

    I usually group the first line with 5 Cohorts in proper distance and then zip them...
    the second line goes with 5 cohorts unzipped.
    Remember:
    Only because the unit is zipped it does not mean that is is unflexible or slow like in Testudo.
    When zipped they can run as normal.
    Another advantage of moving zipped units during battle is that their size is smaller and hence the possibility that they will get stucked in a fight while trying to outmaneuver another unit.
    Especially usefull is Shieldwall against Barbarian Factions.
    My default battle Formation for them is as follows
    First line -----------5 Cohorts------ Shieldwall,Guard,Fire at will
    Second line---------5 cohorts-------Default Formation, Fire manually once first line is in melee
    Third line--Speer/Aux--Skirmishers---Speer/Aux---- Default,Fire at will,Guard

    Have a look here:
    1. Battle Formation Against Barbarians
    2. Barbarian Charge into the center.
    3. First line heavily outnumbered but cant be pushed back thanks to "Shieldwall"
    4. Outflanked the enemy and starting with Cavalry charges into his back to root the first unit. At the same time I sent the second battle line to attack. In the moment the first unit routs because of cavalry charge into its rear and the neighbouring units getting massive pressure by now approaching Cohorts their morale will drop to zero and the entire army starts to root.....happy slaughtering initiated...


    4. Unit response on changing formation
    4. UNIT RESPONSE ON CHANGING FORMATION
    There seem no easy way of making the unit respond with "Shieldwall" as this apparently would need a total rewriting of export_descr_sounds_units_voice as all units with the tight-loose button are tied to the same response. If I would tie the "Shieldwall" response to the Legions all other Units like Velites would give the same response too. So I let it with the original which has the donwside that once you activate Sheldwall Legionaires will respond "loose formation"....yeahhh...I know...I wish I could do something about that.
    If anybody knows of a way to make the units response "Shieldwall" when activated and "Tight Formation" when deactivated without affecting all other Roman Units with the Tight-Loose Button response....please let me know. I would be more than happy to take that on...


    INSTALLATION 1TURN AND 0TURN

    INSTALL FOR PLAY_ROME_ONE_TURN:
    Unzip file:
    Copy
    BATTLEPAGE_2 to the following folder overwriting the existing one:
    Activision/ Rome-Total War/ Data/ UI/ ROMAN/ INTERFACE
    Make a backup of your original file just in case.
    Copy export_descr_unit and copy it to the following folder overwriting the existing one:
    Activision/ Rome-Total War/ Play_Rome_One_Turn/ data
    Make a backup of your original file just in case.

    INSTALL FOR ROME 0TURN:
    Unzip file:
    Copy BATTLEPAGE_2 to the following folder overwriting the existing one:
    Activision/ Rome-Total War/ Data/ UI/ ROMAN/ INTERFACE
    Make a backup of your original file just in case.

    Copy export_descr_unit and copy it to the following folder overwriting the existing one:
    Activision/ Rome-Total War/ Play_Rome/ data
    Make a backup of your original file just in case.



    I tested this with 2.1 and my advanced One_Turn_Campaign from 2.0 playing as Rome and it is savegame compatible and obviously 2.1 compatible.
    If there are any issues let me know and I try to fix it.


    I really hope that this will add a bit to the great fun this mod has been for me so far... even when I was more busy in studying tutorials the last 10 days to make all my little submods rather then playing the game......but this has been fun too

    UPDATE 1 24.11.2010: I turned the system to opposite setting as this is more user friendly.Units will now load in default formation to the battlemap and have to be setted manually to "tight shieldwall". Just download the new files and follow Installation Guide.
    UPDATE 2 24.11.2010: Included Shieldwall Roman 0Turn. New File Uploaded
    UPDATE 3 24.11.2010 Rome One Turn should now work properly. New File Uploaded


    Last edited by chris10; December 05, 2010 at 08:18 PM.

  2. #2

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe

    looks good

  3. #3

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe

    Hello,

    I tried your submod but it gave me some strange results. It has nothing to do with any CTD's or anything like that but the units I tried it with (the Reppublican Triarii) they don't get behind their shields, they just appear in a really close formation and clicking on the "shieldwall" button just makes them step one time to the side and always in that very close formation.

    So I checked the export_descr_unit of the submod and I saw that the Triarii "formation" settings were 0.6, 1, (for the spacing between soldiers which may explain the fact they were very close one to another). And then I checked about the "legio I Germanica" you used for demonstration and I saw that they only have the "square" and "testudo" formations but not the "shield_wall" unlike the auxiliary units and Triarii's, and they also have this 0.6, 1, spacing.

    By the way I use RTW, and I don't have Alexander or BI, and I use the 2.1 RSII 1 turn roman campaign

    Thanks for your two other submods for the numered legions by the way

    ps: If you want I can upload pictures of the triarii's formattion.

  4. #4
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe

    Quote Originally Posted by jerichoo27 View Post
    Hello,

    I tried your submod but it gave me some strange results. It has nothing to do with any CTD's or anything like that but the units I tried it with (the Reppublican Triarii) they don't get behind their shields, they just appear in a really close formation and clicking on the "shieldwall" button just makes them step one time to the side and always in that very close formation.

    So I checked the export_descr_unit of the submod and I saw that the Triarii "formation" settings were 0.6, 1, (for the spacing between soldiers which may explain the fact they were very close one to another). And then I checked about the "legio I Germanica" you used for demonstration and I saw that they only have the "square" and "testudo" formations but not the "shield_wall" unlike the auxiliary units and Triarii's, and they also have this 0.6, 1, spacing.

    By the way I use RTW, and I don't have Alexander or BI, and I use the 2.1 RSII 1 turn roman campaign

    Thanks for your two other submods for the numered legions by the way

    ps: If you want I can upload pictures of the triarii's formattion.
    thanks a lot and you are welcome...

    yes...you wont find shield_wall formation in the EDU as this is not tied to the formation implemented with BI.exe (I specified this in the opening thread) .
    This is tied to the "tight- loose" button and therefore the ability will not be shown as such in the EDU.

    as for the other point that the units wont be permanently behind their shields...
    this is normal...they will get behind their shields once the enemy gets into a certain range........
    and then they form a shieldwall...

    btw: there is another little gimmickry here for Roman Players...
    http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=405019
    Last edited by chris10; November 24, 2010 at 05:15 AM.

  5. #5

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe UPDATE

    Is there a way to use it for the 0-turn campaign?

  6. #6
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe UPDATE

    Quote Originally Posted by TW-fanboy View Post
    Is there a way to use it for the 0-turn campaign?
    make a backup of your EDU from 0Turn and throw this one in instead...It should work but as I did not tested it I wont swear...
    the BATTLEPAGE_2 file is the same for all and goes into the main data folder...here again...backup the original...

  7. #7

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe

    many thanks chris10

  8. #8
    C-Rob's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    somewhereinorneartheUS
    Posts
    3,492

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe

    WHY is this not in teh standard mod? : D

    Very nice.

  9. #9

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 0TURN AND 1TURN CAMPAIGN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe UPDATE

    Thanks for this great modifications !!!
    Last edited by gerard; November 25, 2010 at 05:20 AM.

  10. #10
    Legofan4's Avatar Civis
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Chicago IL USA
    Posts
    141

    Default Re: SHIELDWALL FOR ROMAN HAMATA AND SEGMENTATA LEGIONS ROME 0TURN AND 1TURN TW.exe BI.exe Alex.exe UPDATE

    will this work with the UREE submod




  11. #11
    DarthLazy's Avatar Protector Domesticus
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Karachi
    Posts
    4,867

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Increasing density will make them horribly overpwered.
    Quote Originally Posted by Heathen Hammer View Post
    Real imperialism is shown by Western apologists who are defending Ukraine's brutal occupation of Novorossija.
    Quote Originally Posted by Heathen Hammer View Post
    Sovereignty of Ukraine was recognized by Yeltsin and died with him.

  12. #12
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazy O View Post
    Increasing density will make them horribly overpwered.

    Sure it makes them stronger...thats the idea...
    As this was one of the many tactics employed of later Roman Cohorts I dont see why the player should not be able to use it.
    Especially when outnumbered 3:1 or more....
    I mean...everybody is free to use it or not...

  13. #13

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    is it possible to make the shield wall for all the hoplites?

  14. #14
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Quote Originally Posted by gerard View Post
    is it possible to make the shield wall for all the hoplites?
    sure but that would work in the wrong direction...
    the hoplites dont have big shields like the legionaries...
    when they get under fire while in that formation they are chewed up in no time...

  15. #15

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Quote Originally Posted by chris10 View Post
    sure but that would work in the wrong direction...
    the hoplites dont have big shields like the legionaries...
    when they get under fire while in that formation they are chewed up in no time...
    thorakitai e machairaphoroi... they can do it!

  16. #16
    chris10's Avatar Primicerius
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    3,239

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Quote Originally Posted by pcp View Post
    thorakitai e machairaphoroi... they can do it!
    true...on BI.exe

  17. #17
    Sethiiro's Avatar Civis
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Lincolnshire
    Posts
    144

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Nice mod Chris I'll give it a whirl when I play as Rome. I've done the same for the Spartan hoplites and the machairaphoroi (higher ranked)
    " Fear is a potent weapon "

    Pinky: "Gee, Brain, what do you want to do tonight?"
    The Brain: "The same thing we do every night, Pinky—try to take over the world!"

  18. #18

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Wow, this is a great submod, thanks. A good idea with an intelligent way to implement it ingame. Trying it out with Alx.exe, 0-turn, hope it works fine. Cheers, mate.

  19. #19
    DarthLazy's Avatar Protector Domesticus
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Karachi
    Posts
    4,867

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    ^Wrong. Hoplites had a different shape but it was just as big. Not phalangites, he meant classical hoplites. There are 22 so it would be quite abit of work
    Quote Originally Posted by Heathen Hammer View Post
    Real imperialism is shown by Western apologists who are defending Ukraine's brutal occupation of Novorossija.
    Quote Originally Posted by Heathen Hammer View Post
    Sovereignty of Ukraine was recognized by Yeltsin and died with him.

  20. #20
    Julianus Flavius's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Victoria, Australia
    Posts
    1,655

    Default Re: [RS 2.1] Shieldwall for roman hamata and segmentata legions rome 0-turn and 1-turn Updated

    Incidentally, does anyone know why Spartan hoplites can do a shieldwall but all the other 'city' hoplites can't? like I know it's possible to give them shieldwall but I'm wondering why the team chose not to. And Triarii using both shieldwalls at once = winnage
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 
    What have the Romans ever done for us?? apart from better sanitation and medicine and education and irrigation and public health and roads and a freshwater system and baths and public order... what have the Romans done for us?
    Some of my favourite quotes:
    "Your god has yet to prove himself more merciful than his predecessors" ~ Hypatia, as represented in the film 'Agora'
    "If you choose to do nothing, they will continue to do this again and again, until there is no-one left in the city, no people for this governement to govern"
    ~ Hypatia, as represented in the film 'Agora'

Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •