Re-doing Arnor?

[Raradir]

Ok I don't what your thoughts are, but Arnor is very well done but, I personly like the style of Arnor being like this....
http://www.games-workshop.com/gws/ca...otCatGameStyle=

Don't know what your thoughts are but I think they look very nice like that, But i'm happy either way

Thanx
Raradir

[DisgruntledGoat]

You've got to be ing kidding me...

[Raradir]

You've got to be ing kidding me...

nope, all I was saying is those look nice, I'm not discounting your work or anything as its 100% perfect, all I was saying maybe sometime in the future it would be kool to add something like that.

"Well done Raradir gone and got yourself into it again, not turning out to be a good week for me lol"

[Muffer Nl]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[Grimbold']

sorry Raradir, (btw I was the one that made your sig )
but

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

NOT A GOOD IDEA MATE!
credits to THP for the pic

[Raradir]

Ok sorry then I wasn't saying "Do it, do it now!" all I was doing was adding a little suggestion and I go and get my head bit off

[AnthoniusII]

Come on guys...let the creators finish what they started...
They accomplished what no other mod has...
And they continue to expand the M2TW engine to its limits.
Asking of them to recreate a whole faction the time they have more important
tasks torwards to the finall completion is a crime...

[Korsan82]

Use Durex please.

[Big Pacha]

Use Durex please.

The Units are good enough as they are
But only one thing:
There should be 7 (and not the present 5) stars on the soldiers' shields. After all, Arnor was the kingdom of the SEVEN stars :p

They're very good indeed but they're inspired by the Battle of Gorgoroth that you see in the movie intro, when in fact Elendil & pals are in ancient Numenorian gear.
Of course, assuming that Arnor style was close to that is fine to me - TATW graphics being based on the movies - there's nothing in JRRT's books that fully describes them. We can only guess because JRRT depicts Arnor & Gondor as the heirs of Numenor & therefore their style is derived from Numenor's. Ex: the wings on the helmets is a reminder of the Sea Kings (seabird wings). As for the 7 stars, It might just be a graphic issue.

Ok everyone I re-tract my comments and offer my sincere apologies if I have offended you all, I will not voice my suggestions in the future and keep them to my self. As I said again I apologise for offending everyone with my utter stupidity, and will go tell my mother off for giving birth to me.

Faked modesty ahead BTW as some other posters said you don't have to apologize for sharing your opinion, It's fine...
It's just that for true Tolkien fans, introducing GW material into Tolkien's lore (even a TW mod) is a case of incestuous rape. Some can be horrified I don't like it either but I wouldn't call for your public execution. Some posters overreacted, most of them are just kidding (like Muffer, of course! )

[Muffer Nl]

They're very good indeed but they're inspired by the Battle of Gorgoroth that you see in the movie intro, when in fact Elendil & pals are in ancient Numenorian gear.
Of course, assuming that Arnor style was close to that is fine to me - TATW graphics being based on the movies - there's nothing in JRRT's books that fully describes them. We can only guess because JRRT depicts Arnor & Gondor as the heirs of Numenor & therefore their style is derived from Numenor's. Ex: the wings on the helmets is a reminder of the Sea Kings (seabird wings). As for the 7 stars, It might just be a graphic issue.

Faked modesty ahead BTW as some other posters said you don't have to apologize for sharing your opinion, It's fine...
It's just that for true Tolkien fans, introducing GW material into Tolkien's lore (even a TW mod) is a case of incestuous rape. Some can be horrified I don't like it either but I wouldn't call for your public execution. Some posters overreacted, most of them are just kidding (like Muffer, of course! )

A very good post Pacha. You don't have to fake modesty and all. It's just that I didnt have time to write a lenghty post on why they do not look like the units from GW, instead I opted for my favourite of a few pics from my massive collection of comments in picture form and let other people handle it. I was, however, forgotten how strange all the new people on this forum react sometimes.

Thus I am sorry if I ofended you.

(Oh and if you liked the pictures, rep please, I art rep-whore.)

[dannyalex]

Use Durex please.

you will have better results with AGAIN

SORRY FOR THE DOUBLE POST...ban is needed not to do it again

[Miroslav Klose]

No. I don't like those units.

[Raradir]

Ok everyone I re-tract my comments and offer my sincere apologies if I have offended you all, I will not voice my suggestions in the future and keep them to my self. As I said again I apologise for offending everyone with my utter stupidity, and will go tell my mother off for giving birth to me.

[Vandril]

No one is flaming you for posting your opinions. However, this suggestion was made during the 2.0 development process and it obviously got nixed. No one is suggesting that you stop giving ideas but maybe do some research first, and word opinions so they don't sound like you are asking for a re-do of something that was just finished. ;-)

[The Black Goldfish]

The Units are good enough as they are
But only one thing:
There should be 7 (and not the present 5) stars on the soldiers' shields. After all, Arnor was the kingdom of the SEVEN stars :p

[trance]

No.

Make a sub mod if you want Warhammer inspired models, simple as that mate.

[Beregond]

actually mate I haven't seen a single tolkienist or tolkien-lover, or dunno who else, who would enjoy these 'green Saracens'

[Tactician]

actually mate I haven't seen a single tolkienist or tolkien-lover, or dunno who else, who would enjoy these 'green Saracens'

green Saracens?
well definetely not something we would like to see in the mod ...

[dannyalex]

i just see your title thread(havent read the next posts)... and mate, neither now, neither ever, maybe in the next dimension

BUT

small (minor as a sub mod) add-onns for the Kingdom are welcome,especially if we talk about light units like Eriador has in the beginning,fixing the colours of Arnor because GREEN does not fit into Arnor
and done some unique buildings like .. Minas Tirith by KK..Fornost will be great from my point of view.

and some other minor fixes and Arnor will rule them all

beside we are to many Dunedain\Arnor\Eriador players that we LOVE them and with no fixes

[Himster]

When this mod first came out I would have agreed with you Raridir, but it makes sense that they'd go back to how their armour originally was. That gondorian armour was the result of an evolution from turbulent history, various wars etc, Arnor had a comparitvely bare history and wouldn't have an equally evolved armour design.