Peloponnesian War And Greek City States

[Punk18]

I think it has probably been recommended but a mod that would include as many regions and factions as possible and a system to make the rebel settlements autonomous and possible for recruitment in a faction but with some form of autonomy during the Peloponnesian War would be awesome. Every city would be a faction (limited of course to the max factions possible), some cities would be in the factions and the others instead of being Rebel they would be autonomous and neutral and it would be possible to take them with you by conquest or diplomacy. I have many many ideas about features and stuff to be included to this mod but the possiblity is that most of them even if the mod is created would be impossible to do... If someone is interested i can go on...

[Hrobatos]

can you mod or you are just another "idea giver"

[Punk18]

Sorry to disappoint you but i am just an idea giver. If i could mod i would try it mysellf....

[Nesimî]

If you want this mod go learn how to mod.

[Punk18]

I really don't understand your tone. Isn't this section of the forum for ideas and proposals? If i were you i wouldn't even post a reply if i was going to be like this...

[irishron]

Ideas are great. How about helping carry them out?

[Punk18]

I know next to nothing about models, skinning, mapping and editing the game files. I'm just a guy that loves the Total War games and would like to see some of his ideas take shape IF someone has the time and the knowledge to try to make them true. Is that a reason for replies like all the above?

[IVIarkI2I]

I know next to nothing about models, skinning, mapping and editing the game files. I'm just a guy that loves the Total War games and would like to see some of his ideas take shape IF someone has the time and the knowledge to try to make them true. Is that a reason for replies like all the above?

2 years ago , I had also known nothing about moding , there are tutorials and great people always ready to share their knowledge with you , start with something easy (mapping or coding) , maybe you will find somebody who will be interested in your mod if you show some progress to others ... dont say I dont know , thats easiest way you can do but not a best one

[ComnenusTheOne]

Ideas are great. How about helping carry them out?

It says "Wips, Ideas and Proposals". Doesn't say "Learn mod you ing idiot or you lose your right to breathe"

If you want this mod go learn how to mod.

And you go to school again so they can teach you manners.

no, the reason for that is fact that people dont understand simple fact, if you have mod idea, you ahve to make it on your own, as those who can make mods, have their own ideas

You don't have to do NOTHING, on your own. Modders exist to make mods.

[Hrobatos]

no, the reason for that is fact that people dont understand simple fact, if you have mod idea, you ahve to make it on your own, as those who can make mods, have their own ideas

[Hrobatos]

yes but to make their ideas, not yours, if you want to see your idea as a released mod, you will have to become modder

or hope that some one with same idea will become moder in order to make his idea reality

[ComnenusTheOne]

yes but to make their ideas, not yours

Really? Since when they got that privilege?

[Hrobatos]

what privilege?

[ComnenusTheOne]

what privilege?

To be picky. Well actually that's some small word to describe what kind of persons modders are, or become after making 2-3 new units. Or maybe later they gonna charge us for a mod, CA/SEGA style. Which might not be a bad idea after all, since all people got a price. Maybe a few euros in a modder's pocket will make him do every mod, instead of pretending the internet diva.

[Hrobatos]

its nothing about being moder, but being here for a while, let me ask how manny ideas like this " just thrown out to modders" have you seen released as mods?
you'v been here in WIPS for some time yourself, so how manny?

[ComnenusTheOne]

its nothing about being moder, but being here for a while, let me ask how manny ideas like this " just thrown out to modders" have you seen released as mods?
you'v been here in WIPS for some time yourself, so how manny?

0.

And to return your question back. Who's fault is that? Who is wrong here? The poor gamer who just had an idea? Or the modder who doesnt make it? As if the modder's idea is better. Well let's see how better a modders idea is:

SS, DLV, PDER and another bunch of Europe map mods. Meh.
Warhammer, Third Age, Broken Crescent, the only three interesting mods, taking them up to 3-4 years to make.
A bunch of dead or non-released or broken or whatever mods of which i hardly remember their names.
Thousands of WIPs having the same future.

Yeah....now i try to figure out why CA suddenly took a step against modding, i mean....seriously, this is not even competition.

In fact, if i send a signed letter to CA, proposing some DLC setup, or some sort of provisional campaign or whatever, they will at least take the matter into consideration. The average modder's reply in here is " off do it yourself".

[AnthoniusII]

Let all of us calm down a bit...
Having an idea is not a bad thing.
Trying to make it happen is an other issue.
This thread is about ideas.
I started with an idea and people with the same dream or idea helped me
to make it real.
I had no modding skill until recently.
Trying to learn something though is a good start to motivate others to work with you .That is what i did. I learned (and still learning) some basic things about modding to help the rest of the team that participates in the same projects.
So...let 's not be rude with anyone here.
With ideas or modding skills we all have the same pasion for the same game.
So if someone does not have modding skills lets not discurage him to present his idea. Who knows someday someone with a great idea will come up and motivate us all to it.
There is nothing wrong in listening people.

[Hrobatos]

Let all of us calm down a bit...
Having an idea is not a bad thing.
Trying to make it happen is an other issue.
This thread is about ideas.
I started with an idea and people with the same dream or idea helped me
to make it real.
I had no modding skill until recently.
Trying to learn something though is a good start to motivate others to work with you .That is what i did. I learned (and still learning) some basic things about modding to help the rest of the team that participates in the same projects.
So...let 's not be rude with anyone here.
With ideas or modding skills we all have the same pasion for the same game.
So if someone does not have modding skills lets not discurage him to present his idea. Who knows someday someone with a great idea will come up and motivate us all to it.
There is nothing wrong in listening people.

well not everyone is like you, you are great knower if Byzantine history, and for historical mods historians are very important
but more than anything, you keep bringing very skilled modders in the mod...

[ComnenusTheOne]

well not everyone is like you, you are great knower if Byzantine history, and for historical mods historians are very important
but more than anything, you keep bringing very skilled modders in the mod...

Which doesnt come out for how long?

[ComnenusTheOne]

Seriously Antonaki?