Edoras Wood walls only?

[Deedlit]

Should Edoras in future versions only have wooden walls? I don't know if this is possile. And while it's not a custom settelment issue. Is there some way to make it so it can only have wooden walls no matter what level the city is at?

[Seleukos_I.]

As far as I know it's not possible.

[Deedlit]

Ughh, that sucks.

[Inarus]

I must say though that TW games are a "What if?", Sparta did not have walls but you could build them in Rome.

[Jean=A=Luc]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

It is possible to stop edoras from having stone walls:

In export_desc_buildings add "and not hidden_resource Edoras" to the end of the list of conditions for each stone wall.

At the top add "Edoras" to the hidden resources (it may be there already).

Add "Edoras" to the list of resources in the Edoras region in "desc_regions" (It may be there already)

DONE.

Then you won't be able to upgrade it.

[Russian Gondor]

Then all the invasions will easily take the city over.

[Inarus]

Then you won't be able to upgrade it.

Bugger, I'm used to RTW.

[Russian Gondor]

They have a RTW version of this mod if you want to play it.

[Inarus]

They have a RTW version of this mod if you want to play it.

Mmm, nah, why go for Win when there is Epicness?

[Jean=A=Luc]

If you get into a lotr:tw vs. tatw thing I'll strangle this thread, I swear it.

[tyberriuss]

Maybe Stone walls with a wooden skin? like how mordor walls are black...

And why is there the need for a discussion about Lotr:TW vs TA:TW? TA is clearly better. Psyche!

[Deedlit]

Maybe Stone walls with a wooden skin? like how mordor walls are black...

And why is there the need for a discussion about Lotr:TW vs TA:TW? TA is clearly better. Psyche!

Thats a cool idea, but wouldn't that effect all walls?

[tyberriuss]

Thats a cool idea, but wouldn't that effect all walls?

No i don't think so... The game has faction specific textures and skins so gondor cities for example look different from mordor ( that black disrepaired look ) and harad ( the turkish, arab look ) cities as far as i know. And the skin gets ,,updated" to the latest owner when he upgrades the walls. Anyway, the point is, i think you can place a wall skin for just Rohan without affecting anything else

[The Doge of Venice]

The biggest problem is the invasions always being called on Edoras, that's one thing that should definitely be changed, it should be random or somewhere in Gondor as long as defense scripts could be generated easily enough.

[Raiven]

The biggest problem is the invasions always being called on Edoras, that's one thing that should definitely be changed, it should be random or somewhere in Gondor as long as defense scripts could be generated easily enough.

Same here...only I think Helms Deep should be set as a target,as it is more easy to hold it, and it more logical target for invasion

I would like to see Lithuanian hill towns model for rohan's towns and villages...it looks nice in my opinion

[Hero of the West]

Same here...only I think Helms Deep should be set as a target,as it is more easy to hold it, and it more logical target for invasion

I would like to see Lithuanian hill towns model for rohan's towns and villages...it looks nice in my opinion

indeed i think those town models should be nice to

[The Doge of Venice]

Same here...only I think Helms Deep should be set as a target,as it is more easy to hold it, and it more logical target for invasion

I would like to see Lithuanian hill towns model for rohan's towns and villages...it looks nice in my opinion

Yeah i agree with you there on helms deep.
Also when I begin to think about it the ability to build stone walls at Edoras DOES make sense. The point of TATW is to be able to do things that were not done in canon, the people of Rohan could have built stone walls there but they didn't choose to and that doesn't mean you should not be able to, it just means it shouldn't start with stone walls.

[freitach]

ANother possibility would be to lock uprgading Edoras, and create unique buildings for it, so you can build the most important buildings in it, without having to upgrade it, but if that makes sense, i don't think

[son of romans]

For example I think that Rohan Gold Hall must provide recruitment of Mounted and Dismounted Royal Guard(I made this changes for me),Mounted in every 10 turns and dismounted in every 6,the city can remain with stone wall but with wood skins on it.

[eregost]

Once TA:TW has Fell Beasts and custom settlements I'll agree it beats LOTR:TW. Until then not a chance