Imrahil - unluckiest general?

[philipjd]

Is he the most unluckiest general in the mod?

I'm now 110 turns into my 3rd full Gondor campaign and in none of them has Imrahil 'flourished' as a general - doesn't matter how many battles he won, heroically or otherwise, his bodyguard never rose above 8, never gained more than 3 stars, always died. He lasted longest in this one, through to about turn 70, but...

[Maxamus]

I had to do give_trait and remove a bunch of crappy traits so his citys wouldn't epic fail :/ he does suck alot sadly. Although the swan nights bodyguard is epic

[hospitaller13]

yere i have to agree he gets a good bodyguard but he just fails hard for some reason

[Mhydrian]

Yeah I was dissapointed with him to. I don't know much about him, seemed like an elf so I was like interesting. ANd then the Swan Knights as BGs made me very happy. So I sent him to the fronts againt Mordor. But he never got anywhere. So he ended up just watching some new conqured hick town forever as punishment. Yeah and his Swan night BGs stayed at 8. Seems like suicide to charge a line with only 8 BGs. So combat for him was kinda out of the question from the start.

[Vaz]

Combining his Charge with a Fountain Court Block is awesome. They hold the line, and then charge down. I always attempt to become Fear causing though.

[mattgoby]

i think imrahil shud start off bttr than he does in tatw unfortuanetly in my games imrahils pic just flicks between random buildings and units and sometimes nothing so i just leave in the woods to die

[Seleukos_I.]

i think imrahil shud start off bttr than he does in tatw unfortuanetly in my games imrahils pic just flicks between random buildings and units and sometimes nothing so i just leave in the woods to die

There is a fix for this .

[mattgoby]

i know but reached my download limit