TATW Rate it.

[DeliCiousTZM]

between a 1 and a 10. How would you rate TATW?

and please when you rate dont use "its free so its good" please rate the Qualiity of the work.

Make suggestions here http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=284367

My vote is 8/10.
Whine and cry is welcome and debating to

10/10 means perfect that also means if anything were to change it would not improve it seeming as it was already perfect. the highest rate i think humanily possible to give is 9.9. we can never achieve perfection

[Inarus]

This is a brilliant mod because of the Units are sooo perfect looking, there are Heroes and - sorry I don't have enough hours in which to list the advantages - so I gave it a ten, especially since the custom settlements are still to come!

And it is also brilliant because its free!!!!!!!! (But that moves it from 10/10 to 100/10)

[Bela]

I give it an 8/10, because there are many little point to improve and I'm quite sure that the team will do their work on it (1.1 was 7/10, 1.2 was 8/10. Next patch: 9/10 maybe? We'll see.)

This mod is amazing, keep up the good work!!!

[Lordinquisitor]

Déjà-vu.

[Nurk91]

9/10 (I'd give the vanilla 7/10 comparison )
But of course I hope to be able to give it a 10/10 after some future patch(es). There are still some things that disturbs the Lotr feeling, but I must say that I have experienced a much better game play, compared to the Vanilla.

[DeliCiousTZM]

i disagree i think vanilla SS had alot better feel to it then this. its not SS and its not LOTR but ends up somewhere inbetween with first tier archers that have 7 damage (Dale) which makes it very confusing for me to play.

Visual 9/10
music 9/10
balance 8/10
Gameplay 4/10

It dont feel like LOTR but it sure looks like it. music helps to make the atomsphere but gameplay still dosnt feel like LOTR

[Revan Shan]

As a mod: 9 (great work, not a 10 cause no one is perfect)

As a game itself: 8 (custom cities and the Fellowship are left)

[Blackorc]

10/10 best mod for medeieval 2 and best lord of the rings game

[mikk]

10/10 best mod for medeieval 2 and best lord of the rings game

That said everything.

[Inarus]

10/10 best mod for medeieval 2 and best lord of the rings game

I hate to dissagre but you understated on an EPIC degree!

[beerin]

rates a 9. You always need to leave room for improvement. the atmosphere is great and with the current team in place and the example of the progression of Stainless Steel this puppy is going nowhere but up!

[Achilla]

9. Because nothing is perfect

[miniwally]

crap ticked wrong 10/10

[Warmaster Tibs]

8/10 because custom citys and envirments are missing. Realy annoys me fighting in the MM to find its actual a grasy plain. 9/10 when the get those made. Nothing can be perfect.

[Black_ice_Spain]

8 bcs of cities, but its awesome anyways

[Klierowski]

I woud giwe 7 or 8 we need more units and more balance ...then mod with some sub mods woud be 10/10 for me.

[Ranger of Ithilien]

for now... as a game i give 8(i accidentally rated seven>.<) it is a great mod but is unfinished... in later versions it will be perfect!

[paradamed]

I rated it a 9 cause there are still some bugs to be solved.

[Mune]

and please when you rate dont use "its free so its good" please rate the Qualiity of the work.

I chose that option, because you told me not to. Shouldn't you just not have it as an option if you don't want anyone to pick it?

Also because it's true. Even if it had one unit per faction, 3 factions, 6 cities, and immediately CTD'd on startup, it should still get a 10/10 because it's free.

If you ask me to bake you a pie, so I do and serve it to you, you better say it's a 10/10 otherwise no pie next time. Or go bake your own damn pie..

EDIT: Anyway, my point is that the only people who should be able to ask for criticism of their work is those who created it. Did you make TA:TW Mr. Monetary?

[Gadadngor]

8 for me, there is three thing to improve in my licking to reach perfection, first Eriador, they got heroes yes but I can't play them because I'm don't find this funny playing with nameless bandit-unit. 2 the overal balancing of the game need improvement and the AI too.

Ho and if you want to find a spoiler on what the team surely want to implant go to desc_unit file and scroll down to the bottom XD I don't know if they will do something with that but if they do that's will be great.