Why Couldnt the Allies have just given the jews a chunk of Germany's territory?

[Exarch]

it makes sense;
nazi germany had persecuted the jews, give a portion of germany's terroitory to a 'jewish homeland'\

If you committed this big crime, then why should the oppressed Palestinian nation pay? This is our proposal: If you committed the crime, then give part of your land in Europe, the United States, Canada or Alaska to them so that the Jews can establish their own country.” (New York Times, December 15, 2005)

“Why do you want to force Israel on the holy land of Palestine by killing Muslims? Give a piece of your land in Europe, the United States, Canada or Alaska so the Jews can create their own state.” (Los Angeles Times, December 15, 2005)

“Is the killing of innocent Jewish people by Hitler, the reason for their (the Europeans’) support to the occupiers of Jerusalem? … If the Europeans are honest they should give some of their provinces in Europe – like in Germany, Austria or other countries – to the Zionists, and the Zionists can establish their state in Europe. You offer part of Europe, and we will support it.” (Washington Post, December 9, 2005)

why make the innocent palestineans pay for it when the allies could've jsut given the jews a 'homeland' in what's now germany.

[hellheaven1987]

Because those damn Jew actually wanted Israel.

Stalin offered some piece of land to Jew on Far East and Chiang Kai-Shei offered Yunnan to Jew too but they refused all.

[Војвода Драгутин Кесеровић]

Stalin offered some piece of land to Jew on Far East and Chiang Kai-Shei offered Yunnan to Jew too but they refused all.

Check yr. political geography atlas - there still exists a Jewish Autonomous Region within the Khabarovsk region of Russian Federations Far East

[Exarch]

Check yr. political geography atlas - there still exists a Jewish Autonomous Region within the Khabarovsk region of Russian Federations Far East

pls provide maps and proof
i'm intrigued by this jewish autonomous region
why not just use that as the jewish homeland?
that way they get the proteection of then powerful russians as their allies.

[hellheaven1987]

pls provide maps and proof
i'm intrigued by this jewish autonomous region
why not just use that as the jewish homeland?
that way they get the proteection of then powerful russians as their allies.

Russian was one of biggest allies of Israel in 50s...(they were the one who strongly supported the creation of Israel)

You clearly need to read some information about Jewish state in Middle East from 20s to 40s, then you would know why Jews wanted Israel so badly.

[Exarch]

Russian was one of biggest allies of Israel in 50s...(they were the one who strongly supported the creation of Israel)

You clearly need to read some information about Jewish state in Middle East from 20s to 40s, then you would know why Jews wanted Israel so badly.

i thoguht te only reason why they wanted that area was because of some bull from the roll of toilet paper i call the Torah

[Војвода Драгутин Кесеровић]

pls provide maps and proof
i'm intrigued by this jewish autonomous region
why not just use that as the jewish homeland?
that way they get the proteection of then powerful russians as their allies.

jeez Exarch, this is like "providing proof" of the existence of Bavaria or whatever other region

but seeing how you come from the states, and I've heard legendary stories about the "quality" of geography classes in your school system, I'll indulge you, take your pick:

Attachment 27831Attachment 27832Attachment 27833

And I believe that they already have all the "protection of their powerful allies" they could possibly wish for , so this curiosity doesn't count for much more than a proof of how absurd are the accusations on antisemitism constantly thrown at both USSR and modern Russia.....

[Visna]

And I believe that they already have all the "protection of their powerful allies" they could possibly wish for , so this curiosity doesn't count for much more than a proof of how absurd are the accusations on antisemitism constantly thrown at both USSR and modern Russia.....

Could it be that the Soviet support for a Jewish state was given in the hope that the Jews would go there instead of staying in the USSR?
Antisemitism is hardly a new concept, and Russia was right up there along with the rest, in the late 19th and early 20th century, when it comes to engaging in that particular activity. After all, Pogroms is a Russian word, not German

[Panzerbear]

Because those damn Jew actually wanted Israel.

haha true.

Stalin offered some piece of land to Jew on Far East and Chiang Kai-Shei offered Yunnan to Jew too but they refused all.

as a matter of fact, there is such thing in Russian Far East as Jewish Autonomous Region, with capital in Birobidzhan.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Autonomous_Oblast

(far away from civilization, but at least they live there in peace)

Stalin was also an avid supporter of creating Israel, just fyi, and gave a lot of Jews a chance to emigrate. the problem is that he clearly assumed that he can make Israel to be a socialist state. a very naiive move...

[Yosemite]

Because those damn Jew actually wanted Israel.

Stalin offered some piece of land to Jew on Far East and Chiang Kai-Shei offered Yunnan to Jew too but they refused all.

too bad they were forced to go there

also let's just on palestine, they are just filthy arabs right?

Right?

[Flavius Maccus Opium]

Because those damn Jew actually wanted Israel.

Stalin offered some piece of land to Jew on Far East and Chiang Kai-Shei offered Yunnan to Jew too but they refused all.

Interesting , I didn't know that
Anyway...I saw here some strange ideas..."parts of germany given to Jews"

[Surgeon]

Probably because the Jews wanted somewhere far away from countries that have persecuted them for so long.

[Exarch]

Probably because the Jews wanted somewhere far away from countries that have persecuted them for so long.

antarctica would be good for them
or siberia

[hellheaven1987]

antarctica would be good for them
or siberia

I already told you the Jews rejected that idea.

[skag]

antarctica would be good for them
or siberia

hahaha



ok, let's put the jokes appart

Ahmadinejad is right anyway. Problem is that it was english colony, so "part of Europe"
Since the first day things went violent, and england cowardly retreated : oops, things getting y outta here, ok => that's your problem, we GTFO of here, bye bye

.....

Anyway, what would happen if jews had lands in Europe ? they would have declared war uppon Europe lol

[Xen]

hahaha



ok, let's put the jokes appart

Ahmadinejad is right anyway. Problem is that it was english colony, so "part of Europe"
Since the first day things went violent, and england cowardly retreated : oops, things getting y outta here, ok => that's your problem, we GTFO of here, bye bye

.....

Anyway, what would happen if jews had lands in Europe ? they would have declared war uppon Europe lol

What the are you on about?

Germany is an English Colony?

The Jew's wanted Isreal, in their eyes its their homeland and it's very important too them. Whether or not this is true is debatable.

The Jew's wouldnt invade us, our milltary is much more advanced than the palestinians. Nor would they have any reason to want to invade.

[touchmaster]

antarctica would be good for them
or siberia

LOL. Fantastic.

[Exarch]

@topic
if the allies thought the jews needed a homeland so bad, why didnt the US just give hmmm new york to them?

[Alkarin]

Probably because the Jews wanted somewhere far away from countries that have persecuted them for so long.

so they picked an area where the romans and muslims slaughtered them?

i thoguht te only reason why they wanted that area was because of some bull from the roll of toilet paper i call the Torah

your putting down the torah yet you are christain? so your saying half of your religious text is wrong?

[GeneralLee]

so they picked an area where the romans and muslims slaughtered them?


your putting down the torah yet you are christain? so your saying half of your religious text is wrong?

An enemy who just tried to exterminate you last year or the one from a thousand years ago hmmm hard choice.