Rohan VS Gondor

[Revan Shan]

What if?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAKct...eature=related

[Alerion]

You know there was a theard named Gondor vs. Rohan do you?

[The Count(er)]

yeah we pretty much finished up with saying it'd be a stalemate

[ccllnply]

Even though in the end, Gondor would win.

[The Count(er)]

well there now you've gone and started it back up again

[Revan Shan]

Hey people, i wanted you to watch the vid, not to argue.

[ccllnply]

well there now you've gone and started it back up again

No, I didn't. No one is forcing you to respond and start the discussion up again. Still, I'm allowed to post my opinion

Hey people, i wanted you to watch the vid, not to argue. :original:

No one is arguing. So you're advertising this video? You know there is a Youtube video thread in the off-topic. In truth, I think making the video was just a waste of time. I mean, whats the point? He just edited bits of the movie in an attempt to make it look like Gondor is fighting Rohan, which is just pointless

[The Count(er)]

No, I didn't. No one is forcing you to respond and start the discussion up again. Still, I'm allowed to post my opinion

well I was mostly joking

[ccllnply]

well I was mostly joking

No you weren't! Admit it! You ing weren't!

[aNarion.]

I saw the video..

I think Night Wish doesnt fit with lotr theme at all, atleast in my opinion..

[Lü Bu]

all i liked in this video is music!

[sirfiggin]

Rohan would win, their horsemen are so fierce and strong that if they were really pushed into a war against Gondor, they would win.

[lord0thief]

Rohan would win, their horsemen are so fierce and strong that if they were really pushed into a war against Gondor, they would win.

I think Gondor would just hide in castles, and blow Rohan's cavalry up with trebuchets, since Rohan basically has the largest inability to lay siege upon a place

[The Count(er)]

the main problem is that Gondor can't attack Rohan because their cavalry will destroy the Gondor infantry and Rohan can't attack because they can't really get past any walls and since Pellenor fields is surrounded by the Rammas Echor(which is a wall around the field) Gondor won't be running out of food while Rohan can't attack and Gondor can't attack due to the reason above which will result in a stalemate

[lord0thief]

the main problem is that Gondor can't attack Rohan because their cavalry will destroy the Gondor infantry and Rohan can't attack because they can't really get past any walls and since Pellenor fields is surrounded by the Rammas Echor(which is a wall around the field) Gondor won't be running out of food while Rohan can't attack and Gondor can't attack due to the reason above which will result in a stalemate

Well... Gondor could raise an army of spearmen and just own the cavalry =D

[The Count(er)]

then comes horse archers

[Roger the Shrubber]

The Gondorian sheilds are large enough to protect them...and also Gondor does have cavalry, rangers, spearmen, Rohan only really has cavalry. I think it's fair to say Rohan would get owned.

[The Count(er)]

except a shield can't protect from all angles it doesn't matter how much armour you have you'll eventually get hit

[Roger the Shrubber]

except a shield can't protect from all angles it doesn't matter how much armour you have you'll eventually get hit

Not if the Gondorians could form shiltrom, they could block the arrows form all angles,

[The Count(er)]

trust me a shield can't block everything something will get through eventually and it's not like they can do anything in the meantime while they wait for their deaths anyways a schiltrom is a defensive position which doesn't work so well when your supposed to be attacking them so Rohan doesn't even need to do anything except keep a eye on them to make sure they don't try anything