I looked in the system.log in the root M2 folder and the last line says that my replay file is missing. I don't know why it can't find it, though. I triple-checked the reference in the config file, put in the full directory path after that didn't work, and even copy and pasted the reference from the other config file just to be sure it wasn't my eyes. If I were a town, my happiness level would be "disillusioned".