Tell me what's wrong with a draft again...

[morteduzionism]

Exactly how is a draft worse than this or this or what about this, let's not forget this one either. What got me thinking about this is that I heard it mentioned on the news this morning, CNN I think, but I couldn't find the story.

But that doesn't change the question. Exactly how is knowingly recruiting misfits better than a draft? Isn't the main argument about the 'quality' of soldier a draft would produce? Are these recruits any better than what one would get in a draft?

[El Brujo]

The misfits are still volunteers. Draftees are not.

[Kiljan Arslan]

I have no problem with the draft if say your really in a war that truley effects your country(not like iraq or vietnam)

[El Brujo]

But who gets to decide how serious the war is? Certainly not the draftees.

[Rush Limbaugh]

Exactly how is a draft worse than this or this or what about this, let's not forget this one eithe

Well all of these things were reasons not be draftable. The Army should be made to stop.

Even with a draft the well to do escape it.

[Kiljan Arslan]

But who gets to decide how serious the war is? Certainly not the draftees.

Well congress of course.

[El Brujo]

They haven't even declared war since God knows when. And they are the same yahoos who thought the Vietminh were a serious and immediate threat to America.

[Ummagumma]

I have no problem with the draft if say your really in a war that truley effects your country(not like iraq or vietnam)

I am more than sure that if such an event would occur there would be more than enough volunteers - would you not want to protect your home? The problem in those situations is people lying about age, as was seen in both world wars, and people with skills that are better placed at home, such as engineers wanting to go and fight rather than use their skills for the war effort in different ways (Like my Grandfather - He was an engineer, and nearly left to fight on 3 occasions till they found out who he was and what his skills were....).

[Kiljan Arslan]

yes that was stupid.

However it time like ACW and WW2 I say we had every right to (you of course don't but you see this isn't the 19th century.)

[El Brujo]

But the ACW was in the 19th century.

[Rush Limbaugh]

And unconstitutional

[El Brujo]

At least Congress bothered to declare war back then. How stupid is it to be drafted to fight in a U.N. action?

[Kiljan Arslan]

And unconstitutional

Those states left the UNion because they didn't like the resuklts of a presidential election

[El Brujo]

Those states left the UNion because they didn't like the resuklts of a presidential election

What's wrong with that?

[Kiljan Arslan]

THats hardly a reason to leave the USA!

[El Brujo]

THats hardly a reason to leave the USA!

Lincoln thought the same way, and look at all the death and mayhem his line of reasoning caused.

[Kiljan Arslan]

Oh so you should just let your nation fall apart?

[El Brujo]

Oh so you should just let your nation fall apart?

From the CSA's point of view, the USA wasn't a nation but rather a confederation of nations. This was the view of many people across America. Even New England tried to secede a couple of times.

[Kiljan Arslan]

Well if you guys are3 going to attack Linocln why don't you attack Andrew jackson?

[El Brujo]

Because he redeemed himself when he took down the National Bank.