As Archer accepted his nomination, I cannot understand why he, or anyone else would like to hide this information from us. It would only give us a better view on the matter so we can provide as...
Type: Posts; User: Ragabash; Keyword(s):
As Archer accepted his nomination, I cannot understand why he, or anyone else would like to hide this information from us. It would only give us a better view on the matter so we can provide as...
And there is no difference between CC and TW contributions? There are reasons to disagree with this proposal, but not with the logic you present us in above post.
Nature cares nothing for logic,...
I would like to request all the relevant data inside the Hex posted for us too see regarding Archer's actions and views in November and January crisis.
Unless we are provided with all the actual...
It's not even possible to compare tribal warfare, its affect to people and organized slavery in railroads, mines and rubber indrusty that King Leopold II started when he aquired the region.
It was...
I don't think we can ever compare tribal warfare to brutal slavery and human right violations in railroads and especially rubber indrusty after King Leopold II negotiated the area for himself and...
For the name, it remains for now, lets decide the content of the bill first, and then re-discuss about the name.
pannonian.
I woluld like to remind that there are as much deserving CC debators...
Lets hear all the sides before we make decision. I have to admit this propably won't get my support but nevertheless I'm more then eager to hear everything regarding this VonC.
Moved to the Arts.
Removed references to Curia, and section of the bill that could have granted past holders of Patrician rank this award.
If council decides to veto this bill because of its award name, please let...
Moderators cannot knock these doors, only admins, Curator and Speaker of the House. :ninja:
I will attend some the questions later tomorrow or day after that but for now Ragabash must do something else, otherwise my brains start to melt away.
Remember to provide me with more constructive...
Shouldn't that be two days instead of a one, like Simertical told, we lost 48 hours.
Remember, it's our duty to give feedback when it's needed, but it's also our duty to give the person time to take the feedback, respond to it, and show possible improvement that the person has made....
Publius and Wild Bill Kelso.
I admit I might have had different impression from the post, but even then, we should evaluate his actions, not his motivation.
Wild Bill Kelso.
As I said...
pannonian.
Yes, the bill is a bit different(thanks to all feedback I got last time). And I have even myself started to doubt this part of the bill.
Curial Decision: Automatic AwardsIf the...
And as I explained before; ranks can be changed whenever wanted, so that isn't a good indicator for member contributions.
Also, ranks are always more confusing to new members then any awards....
And I offer different solution, to have own awards for both CC and TW.
If you disagree with the award, or not, that is not essential, what is; is that we need a decision about this matter before...
Perikles.
Even when the award was not officially meant just for modders, it basically turned out one as the time went on.
I only know two persons who got(?) the award for their contributions...
I remember to read from somewhere that he wanted to get the site but imb39 offer kind of messed that around.
I could be all wrong, but I'll take a look if I can find that post somewhere.
EDIT:...
It's not as much of an problem then it's lack of a "feature" that should exist in my opinion. Remember that I did not come with this idea overnight, I have thought this some time after Mim... posted...
http://img110.imageshack.us/img110/5403/his1qg9.jpg
American Revolution - Battle of Lake ErieAuthor: Brokenfingers
The Scriptorium Article: American Revolution - Battle of Lake Erie
This is a...
Archer created chaos to get the site for himself, not for the community.
Belisarius.
Archer might have had best interests of the site in mind, but his actions had other impact. If we want to give this reward for administration who always wanted best for the site, I...
Yes Ozymandias, that is why this bill was created, for the sake of shiny baubles. And how thoughtful and constructive feedback from you, I doubt you even read the whole discussion with a thought and...
And as I explained, ranks can be changed whenever wanted, so that isn't a good indicator for member contributions.
Also, ranks are always more confusing to new members then any awards. Medals are...
Perikles.
As I said in my above post; I will need to reconsider Curial Decision: Automatic Awards section of the bill, but even then, I find it quite insulting that I'm being accused of...
That is why I want the Curia to decide should past Patricians have the award or not.
I need to think more about Curial Decision: Automatic Awards section of bill, but other then that, I don't see...
I favored Superfluous Rank and Medal Removal Amendment but never agreed that we should have just one award for exceptional contributions for the site in both, CC and TW. This is not an award that was...
This award has nothing to do with the actual rank, other then the name.
And I don't believe we are heading to same road with medals as before if we create own medals for exceptional contributions...
This bill was meant for old medal part of the constitution, as there it was then the CdeC who voted the medals, not the Curia.
This thread can be closed as it server no purpose what so ever no...
I just wanted to give an option for the curia to decide should we award past Patrcians with this award(if the bill passes the vote) as this has quite little to do with the actual rank, other then...
Proposer: Ragabash
Supporters: jimkatalanos, =Eclipse=, Arakorn-eir
Version 1.5.
Curial DecisionAll references to medal sizes are removed in section: Article 2 - Community Medals.
Large...
I want to point out that we should evaluate Archer'a achievements for his own, and not to turn this nomination discussion to a debate about previous Divii, or their actions compared to Archer's.
...
I don't think that the original poster meant we should get focused too much in general vs. armies aspect as much as we should try to give views which one of them played more important role in our...
I suppose it depends quite much what time frame we want to look.
Ancient times:
Both had significant roles, troops had to be well equipped(this was done mostly by themselves), but it was...
Trade does not increase yearly income, but monthly. While yearly income is used to maintain armies, advisors, to build new buildings, recruiting, etc, monthly income is used to either get new...
the Black Prince.
I don't want to tell any of the councillors how to evaluate nominees, but I don't think we should give citizenship just for clever one liners and offences, no matter how...
Me and Ragabash think that we allow, and have already quite amount of controversial members as citizens. For the posts, we do not take action against posts that do not violate ToS, no matter how...
Baarikärpänen
Bar Fly
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3VagnARqPY
Mua puri baarikärpänen mut miksi suremaan.
Jo kauan sitten lääkkeen löysin siihen puremaan.
Alla konjamiinipullon onnellisten...
I would like to know more about his "contributions" inside the site as like Garbarsardar said; all I have seen are clever one liners and offences.
Please, those who have seen more of his posts,...