A rather simple answer, but I find it fun to talk about.
Id say we would have become something like Canada
Agreed.
Most probably quite decentralized, maybe ending up like Canada or a confederacy of independent states.
Or perhaps independant states, but still members of the commonwealth (just as canada). Btw I heard some time ago that the 13 former colonies had the right to join the commonwealth (because they were british colonies). How extraordinary would dat be if that happened.
Yes, there would be a very important and strong country there, but like you guys said. Something more like Canada and Australia.
Or New Zealand
so what would Mexico look like then?
At least I'd have ####ing health insurance...
Yeah, if we British had won, i imagine America would have ended up a Dominion and virtually Independent by the 2011 of this Alternative reality. The chance might of been that Canada and America would have formed one single dominion in this reality too, considering most differences between Canadians and Americans arose due to the War of Independence.
Honestly, America should not have rebelled. They had the lowest taxes and the most plentiful natural resources.