Every Settlement is a Walled Settlement (Poll)

[Petellius]

As of right now, every settlement in the Ancient Empires campaign is walled and can be besieged. The province capitals are now the administrative heart of a province, providing aqueducts and roads which smaller regions cannot build on their own.

Do our fans like the idea of having every settlement have walls?

[LordKainES]

TOTALLY YES!!!

For future releases could be done maps exclusively for each settlement... could be great!!!

[SickRabbit]

Yes yes yes Sir

Gesendet von meinem E6653 mit Tapatalk

[Petellius]

TOTALLY YES!!!

For future releases could be done maps exclusively for each settlement... could be great!!!

That sounds like a lot of work xD! We've got a decent amount of variation right now, as well as many custom maps for famous cities such as Carthage, Rome, Syracuse, Antioch, Alexandria ect.

[LordKainES]

That sounds like a lot of work xD! We've got a decent amount of variation right now, as well as many custom maps for famous cities such as Carthage, Rome, Syracuse, Antioch, Alexandria ect.

I know, I know hehehe

Yeah that´s something great about your mod, all the maps you´ve done... but I mean other modders could collaborate in the future adding new cities for example...

But for now the mod itself is wonderful, so I´m fine! :-)

[rick1063]

Yes excellent idea, also better from a gameplay perspective as walled settlements harder to capture


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Prometheos]

God, I love you guys from the AE mod.

No preferences, just that.

[Viking1978]

I especially logged in for this: Yes!

[Dicanio35]

Yes good idea as long as the settlements are not all massive walled settlements.
I do however think that if possible for walls to be scaled based on settlement type, so for instance minor settlements would have a wooden palisade or wooden platformed walls.

[Mithrillian]

Apparently I am not allowed to vote. Regardless, I think it's great to have walls around every city. After all, only Spartans would see no use in them for city defense.

[SWAT400]

Apparently I am not allowed to vote. Regardless, I think it's great to have walls around every city. After all, only Spartans would see no use in them for city defense.

Same here. Also All Settlements walled +1

[Nikron]

Yes, please!

That would be the realistic thing to do, since each city represents the capital of an entire region therefore it has to be quite developed.

[Eldgrimr]

Most important settlements in the ancient times did have walls, so I think it would be historically accurate. Therefore I'm gonna vote yes!

[sobaos]

YESSS!!!!!

[Petellius]

I'm interested to know what the other side of the argument would be? Does anyone not want walls, why?

[jdofo]

Absolutely YESSS!!! Due to engine settlement limitation, it historically makes sense and would be realistic! Another fix to CA faulty design...

[sobchack]

im going with no, part of the strength of rome 2/attila was that there was a ridiculuous amount of battle type variety (walled and unwalled, naval, field, naval/land, amphibious assault). Unwalled settlements play a lot differently and require differfent strategies to walled. Additionally attila already comes with the feature to build walls on any settlement so I don't think it is necessary.

just my opinion

[iEplekjekk]

How about walled settlement on tier 2 or 3 instead of vanilla tier 4? I really like the idea of walled settlements for minor cities, but sobchack has a good point. Defending unwalled settlements can be so much fun.

[Relf]

Pls no, also if I'm remembering my early imperial Roman history right, a lot of early imperial Roman colonias were built without walls, as were at least a fair number of other settlements including, famously, Sparta.

[Seresox]

I normally would like to have all settlements walled but when remembering rome 1, I think it will turn out to be rather repetetive and annoying. I think sieges should be special and I really like the non-walled settlement battles of attila. If every settlement has a different layout, its better for making it not as repetetive / boring. It all comes down to map variety.