Originally Posted by
Trasibulos
ok.
i've bought the wos dlc... with a lot of doubts... but anyway, it's a total war product... and it's been plus than ten years they stand by me, so, once again, i trusted them.
But for who, like me, expect since RTW (the first!) a Peloponnesian War focused campaign there was only a huge disappointment.
1) ok, we have to forget Sicily and Magna Graecia, it have been said...
2) hoplite formation degenerate into chaos after half a minute of clashes
3) why only four factions playable? Where is Persia? Where is Makedonia? Where is the democratic city-states of Argos (the second major power in peloponnesos)?
4) political system (that should be very important at this time) is simply insgnificant for the main gameplay (should be more hystorical accurate if tribalism was changed with the government form)
5) it's impossible to "feel the time", for who knows the sources, if i can take Argos (it's just an example) with an "immediate assault"! The most of the greek city states had walls. So Plateia, so Argos, so Mantineia, so Elis, so also Naupaktos (where are the Messenian Hoplites there?), so Potidea etc. etc. And the walls, without siege engines, means, for any attackers, years of siege... that was just the hystorical reality, you can't change this element!
6) where is the "demographic element"? At the time of Peloponnesian War the armies were not so "large", because of the low levels of population (in RTW I you have to recruit one unit for turn and, also, you have to not erode too much the people of the cities, or you could find those without men to make an army! Just another thing: a decisive defeat, for example, should leave you really without defences... more exciting and hystorical accurate!)
anyway sorry for my really bad english.