Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

  1. #1
    Omnipotent-Q's Avatar All Powerful Q
    Content Emeritus

    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Oxford, United Kingdom
    Posts
    6,820

    Default The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review



    June 28th, 1914, Sarajevo
    A Serbian student, Gavrilo Princip, fires two fatal shots at Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria and his wife. These two shots will launch Europe and the world into four years of bloodshed. One of the deadliest wars in history, a war thought to end all wars, a war known as the Great War.

    The Great War mod for Napoleon: Total War focuses on the European theater during the bloody days of the First World War. You can choose from multiple factions, each having its pros and cons. You want to play as Germans or Austrians? Go right ahead. Want to dominate the seas as the United Kingdom or be the huge but slow Russian steamroller? You want to save Belgium from German occupation or sit back, eat popcorn, and watch war roll over Europe as Switzerland? Each faction provides a unique window into the chosen countries history in World War 1.


    Fokker plane in campaign.

    The Great War has same system requirements as Napoleon: Total War, but you need about 2 GB of extra hard drive space for the mod itself. You also need the latest Napoleon: Total War patch.

    Gameplay
    For the campaign game, you can choose your faction and settings just as with any Total War game. You're first greeted by an option to have the AI preserve the real historical alliances of the Central Powers and the Allies (Germany-Austria-Turkey vs. Russia-France-UK). Nevertheless, you can also tick a box to have the usual TW diplomacy where alliances can shift drastically. The feature adds a lot of replay value and sprinkles of sheer randomness into a campaign. Although you should keep in mind that the campaign starts after war has already been declared so either way you choose, you are initially at war with opposing factions, unless you are a neutral power such as Switzerland. There are also revolutions to contend with including the Russian Revolution, which of course leads to the formation of the Soviet Union.


    Austro-Hungarian troops holding out on the Eastern Front.

    There are very few units available at the start of the campaign and no real armies to attack with right away. In some respects, it's the one disappointing thing about this mod, but it does stop the campaign turning into a quick Blitzkrieg rush that would be more suited to the Second World War. As a compromise, it works but as a history buff, massive armies locked in a standstill from the get go feels like a must.

    In my first campaign playthrough I played as Kaisar Wilhelm's Germany. Infamous for its large manpower and an emperor with an elaborate moustache, it was not until June 1915 that the Reich had its first full army stack available and at my disposal. It would have been longer, but I quickly realized that my economy could not accommodate any more units. I wanted to see how quickly armies can be raised. Using DarthMod for NTW, by the same amount of turns I already had four full stacks as Denmark.


    German forces on the move.

    For gameplay reasons proper hardcore artillery and even Machine Guns cannot be trained until later, so there's a fair chance you have to go into your earliest battles with just riflemen. As the game progresses and you research new technologies, you start to train some truly sweet units such as tanks (a personal favorite), Heavy artillery, and even early sub machine gunners that are perfect for clearing out trenches. If you have the patience to play long enough and not destroy others or let them destroy you, you will have some terrific battles every bit as bloody and worthy of the name 'The Great War'. Given enough money and enough time, you can see enemy raising large amounts of armies in a terrific spectacle.

    When it comes to battles, The Great War mod excels. This is what makes this mod truly special. You'd think it would be infuriating to take an army of riflemen to try to capture an enemy town while under heavy machinegun and artillery fire but it's a really fun challenge. It's a shame Napoleon: Total War does not let naval battles be modded easily and as such there are none in The Great War. Thereís however plenty of fat to chew on with land battles that should keep you up until dawn. As the campaign progresses you get access to colonial and foreign forces depending on your faction, with the United States running to the aid of the Allies.


    Chaaaaaaaaaaarge!

    Battles are a bit unusual to a seasoned NTW player at first, as units will stay on the field until they're almost completely wiped out. Artillery is like an angry Zeus raining hellfire from above and striking chaos among the very much more mortal infantry. Machine guns and tanks are tough to beat, but satisfying when you manage it. Rifle range is also much much longer than in NTW because of historical improvements in rifling between these two periods. The tactics you have to use to win couldn't be more different from the days of brightly coloured coats and muskets. Remember that defence is far stronger than offense but you do need to be successful at attacking to win overall.


    One of your most trusted buddies early in the campaign.

    The AI is also very good. It can surprise you if you do not pay much attention but it still does stuff you'd only expect from Artificial Intelligence at times. In a French campaign I played, the United Kingdom gave Ireland to Russia in exchange for Estonia and Livonia and I have witnessed AI soldiers desperately focusing fire on one singular unit. However, thereís only so much a mod can do to change the base game.


    Early version of Russian rifleman in-game.

    Another constraint NTW imposes on this mod is the campaign map. Yet the TGW team did a superb job of setting borders and selecting factions and many borders are as correct as possible. Battle maps, particularly custom ones, are excellent with trenches, barbed wire, and an atmosphere that perfectly captures the tone of one of the bloodiest and bitter wars in history. It's all you can ask for and more from a period of history game developers and modders will seldom go.


    Austrian forces under artillery bombardment.

    The tech tree is well thought out with researched techs giving you an advantage in travel such as the ability to build better railways. Technology can do the essential of improving units and training speed, as well as giving you the ability to unleash airplanes! Some parts of the tech tree are seemingly not fully complete, so you there are some situations where researching one technology can take one turn and a technology on the same level can take 8 turns or produce undesired effects. Thatís a minor issue in the grand scheme of things because the tech-tree is supposed to give you advantages and disadvantages just like any Total War campaign.

    As I alluded too earlier, the economy can be difficult to work with. It allows you to support smaller amounts of armies but if you conquer key trade areas, you will be rich from the associated trade routes.

    The Great War has many submods, such as World War II: Sandstorm, which is based on The Great War mod but is otherwise standalone. Many more submods are 'work-in-progress' too such as The Spanish Civil War submod.

    Summary
    Despite some flaws as a result of the huge scope of this mod and the constraints of modding Napoleon: Total War, The Great War is a must-play mod for any Total War fan. If you can get past the slow start to the campaign and get to grips with economic issues you will have a very enjoyable time playing The Great War.


    Get ready for an epic journey.

    The Great War accurately depicts units and technology of the era allowing you to test many "what if" scenarios. Whether you want to re-write history or have large and ridiculously bloody battles, this is the mod for you. The mod is a great way to re-live and re-capture a war that was costly too many, yet so important that even a hundred years on since 1914, history still feels its effects today. Download it now - you will not be disappointed.

    Remember to visit Total War Center tomorrow for Part 2 of 'The Great War Weekend' - an interview with TGW developer and Total War modding veteran Mitch.


    Under the patronage of the Legendary Urbanis Legio - Mr Necrobrit of the Great House of Wild Bill Kelso. Honoured to have sponsored these great warriors for Citizenship - Joffrey Baratheon, General Brittanicus, SonOfOdin, Hobbes., Lionheartx10, Mangerman, Gen. Chris and PikeStance.

  2. #2

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    Hi, it is good. I did review for TGW 5.0/5.1 yet last year, when this mod released. My review is intended for Czech and Slovak players, so it is in Slovak language... It is just out of curiosity

    http://www.totalwarforum.cz/forum/vi...php?f=24&t=980

    Yes, and I doing AAR too. Version is 5.4 and I begin shortly before WW I 100 years anniversary. It is in Slovak language too and I playing for UK.

    http://www.totalwarforum.cz/forum/vi...php?f=8&t=1120
    Last edited by kubo4747; October 11, 2014 at 04:22 PM.

  3. #3
    Meelis13's Avatar You fight like a cow!
    Citizen

    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Estonia
    Posts
    1,632

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    i'd like to ask as much feedback on this as possible- first mod review i ever tried and tbh, without help of other content staff members, it wouldnt be so readable
    still, im extremely happy atm
    Heidinn veor- dark age mod for M2TW now recruiting scripter/coder


  4. #4
    mav61's Avatar Civis
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    195

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    I don't know if this mod has been updated latley, but what i will say is that its a very nice piece of work...i stopped playing it because i thought support for the mod had stopped since Rome2 released, but if it has been updated will definatly reinstall...

  5. #5

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    I have never been able to play this mod because of crashes. Their installations instructions are really bad; I do exactly what they tell me, and still, crashes all the time. But I've watched many campaigns on youtube, and The Great War looks like it is an amazing mod.

  6. #6

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    Nice review. I agree with most of the criticism and (along with the rest of the team, I'm sure) am flattered by the compliments

  7. #7

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review


  8. #8
    Flinn's Avatar In Dude We Trust!
    Content Director Citizen

    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Italy
    Posts
    5,539

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    Great review and very nice mod. I'm not very active as a player at the moment, but I have reinstalled NTW and will install this mod as soon as I have some real free time!
    Under the patronage of Finlander, patron of Lugotorix & Lifthrasir & joerock22 & Socrates1984 of the Imperial House of Hader.


  9. #9
    B-DizL's Avatar TGW Lead Modeller
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    America
    Posts
    5,421

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    Well done sir + rep

    EDIT: My only nitpick is the picture of the rifle you posted is the French Lebel which isnt in the game yet. I have a rather large collection of pictures for TGW so ill pm them to you
    Last edited by B-DizL; October 15, 2014 at 06:03 PM.

  10. #10
    Meelis13's Avatar You fight like a cow!
    Citizen

    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Estonia
    Posts
    1,632

    Default Re: The Great War Weekend Part 1 - Mod Review

    Quote Originally Posted by B-DizL View Post
    Well done sir + rep

    EDIT: My only nitpick is the picture of the rifle you posted is the French Lebel which isnt in the game yet. I have a rather large collection of pictures for TGW so ill pm them to you
    Thank you very much
    as for rifle picture- didnt honhestly notice it isnt ingame yet (pc allows to play only on low graphics on NTW)
    Heidinn veor- dark age mod for M2TW now recruiting scripter/coder


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •