Who am I ? Third Age Edition v.II

[Skald]

Lorien

[Flinn]

that's an hard one.. three possible candidates, but I'll go with Silvans

[danny X]

Silvans

[Suppersopp]

Rohan

[Prince Regent George]

Silvan Elves

[jinjo]

silvan elves

[sharkbait459]

Silvans

[Duke of Metz]

LORIEN!

[Redgrave]

I can give the answer away in ~4/4.5 hours, but as I am away from my PC I cannot post a photo proving that I am who I say I am. I will be able to post the verification photo in ~24 hours (so a long time away). Should I:
a) give away the answer in ~4.5 hours and post the photo as soon as I can post it (likely in 24 hours time)?
b) wait until I can post the photo (in 24 hours time) to give away the answer?
c) none of the above?

It would make life a lot easier if someone was to tell me what I should do

[Macilrille]

If you wait more people will get rep.


But in any case, your word is enough. Only when arguing Lore are proof needed.

[Redgrave]

Well, I'm rather impatient (although I will try to post the map tomorrow), so, here goes:

I was the Silvan Elves. It was a very interesting campaign, but I managed to defeat several large Orcish armies, allowing Lorien to expand a lot. Lorien were also really agressive in pushing back Isengard, which helped Rohan out a lot. If I was playing as the HE I would have taken the island in the north-west of the map, and normally when I play as Rohan I'm a lot more agressive towards Isengard. As Gondor I always go for Umbar, and as OoG I expand further east. I have no idea how the OotMM got into Eriador, but somehow they did (to my great surprise).

Rep has been given to:
Bladvak
danny X
Prince Regent George
sharkbait459
jinjo

Still requiring rep:
Flinn (sorry, need to spread some around)

I don't think I missed anyone out there, but if someone could rep Flinn that'd be great. Hope you all enjoyed the map!

[Macilrille]

Flinn is done, and as is traditional, you shall also have some, to show our appreciation.

[Flinn]

Flinn is done, and as is traditional, you shall also have some, to show our appreciation.

thanks Mac

correct, the mapper should receive some rep, as a general rule

[jinjo]

redgrave, +rep for nice map

[Bladvak]

Ha, my logic prevailed, I won! God knows the last time I guessed corretly at Who am I ...

Have some rep.

[Macilrille]

Many who plays this game use MOS. I love MOS, but something nags me and I need your help to clear it up.

In case you have not noticed this thread of mine, bear with me and have a look please.

[Redgrave]

Ha, my logic prevailed, I won! God knows the last time I guessed corretly at Who am I ...

Have some rep.

I often find that it's not just guessing, but more deducing and assuming based upon probabilities; I know that faction X always does Y, so the player is likely to be faction Z as they have done Y and expanded where faction X would normally, as well as holding back faction W. Well, that's how it should work in theory

[Terrorgnom]

Hm, Nobody else posting?
So...
Let's hear what you think about this:



With actual MOS and double hitpoints for all gates (didn't change that for this campaign, but didn't change it back...)
VH/VH, Scripts for everybody disabled (no arnor from start, no bonuses for evil faction), but immortal heroes and nazgul.
diplomatic meetings with the whatever called "revengeattack" from sauron enabled.

Turn 113, Invasion on Edoras and Tol Acharn on Isengard, both successful, but both recaptured soon, no more since then.
both tharbads on dunland, W.O Gondor, E.O Mordor.

And a tip:
i play very "loyal" and as a "teamplayer", so it doesn't matter for me who crushes my enemies, if the whole map is conquered from good/bad guys, thats my aim, for what i would sacrifice what is needed to do so.

Soo... have fun "guessing"

[Flinn]

Dwarves

And a tip:
i play very "loyal" and as a "teamplayer", so it doesn't matter for me who crushes my enemies, if the whole map is conquered from good/bad guys, thats my aim, for what i would sacrifice what is needed to do so.

mm not very clear, but if you have gifted one or more settlement it should be reported

and nice map, some rep to you

[Macilrille]

I agree, Dorf.

But no, gifting is not reported (would be a giveaway), it is not legal to gift in order to confuse us though.