You said he's not clutch. Driving your team on a 90 yard two minute drill to win the SB is the definition of clutch in the NFL. What is is pointed to almost always as the greatest clutch performance in NFL history? The Drive. This was about 8 yards shorter and done 2-3 minutes quicker. I'm not sure how you can ignore that and brush it off as luck. And lets not forget, SB 40 was only his second year in the league.
And yeah, i'd rather have any of those 4 guys, but that's not exactly a shocker. Then again, it's not exactly like those guys haven't had their failings. Especially Manning. Don't remember any of his games against the early Brady teams? He completely crapped the bed.