So in the course of playing SS, a question has come to mind every once in awhile. It goes as follows:
Assuming a citadel has the cannon towers upgrade, and a full stack army lays siege and attacks, what is the smallest possible garrison that could mount a successful defense? Overall losses are no factor and total destruction of the attacking force is not necessary, the defenders just have to be victorious at the end. Also, what faction would be best suited for it?
The attacking army can have up to three artillery pieces, but I've never seen the AI target towers, so I'd assume they'd just be used to punch holes in the walls and that's that and then run their troops by the towers as they try to get in. Constructed equipment is standard for the AI: maybe two rams, a siege tower, and two or three ladders (assume they waited only one turn to attack). The rest of the attacker's make up is a standard army for that faction.
The defending garrison can be of any make up.
Personally, I'd say no fewer than six units could do it...I'd go with two stake-laying archer units and the other four as spearmen-type units. I'd lay the first line of stakes somewhere before the third gate at a chokepoint that the AI cannot go around, forcing their units to run through them (lol cavalry), and then the second line of stakes behind the third gate and then pile my spearmen around it in scintillation (yeah I totally spelled that wrong) formations. The archers I'd initially have running back and forth on the walls to activate the cannon towers and gate oil until either the gate is rammed open or artillery opens a hole in the wall, pulling them back as the main army enters the breach (making sure to keep them on the walls and out of harm's way for the most part) and then do the same for the second wall before falling back to the third wall and then parking them around the third gate for the final showdown.
Alternatively, I'd swap out one spearmen unit for another stake-laying archer unit for a third line of stakes; these I'd put right behind the second gate.
So could something like this be done? Or has anyone managed a successful defense against a full stack with a smaller garrison?