youre comparing vanilla m2TW to TATW is not even close. you should be comparing SS to TATW if you want to do that. I personally play both, i just change between when i want a different flavour.
Medieval 2 Total War
Third Age Total War
They are both as good as the other
I played M2TW for years and really enjoyed, but after I started to play TATW I realized how imperfect was the original game in some mechanics.
Anyway, no M2TW no TATW, so I'll keep a place on my heart for it.
TWC Member Awards 2014: Nominations Thread is out now
Why participating? Because Total War Center is a wide community composed by thousands of members; many of them contribute to it in an evident way, while others do a more hidden "job"; if you think someone is worth more recognition or if you simply want to express your appreciation to the quality of posting or the commitment of some members, do not lose the chance to nominate them now!
Son of the magnificent Finlander, member of the glorious Imperial House of Hader
There ARE other mods you know... M2 with a extensive realistic mod would be as good as TATW.
EBII fan appeal: The Europa Barbarorum II team [M2TW] is in dire need of YOUR HELP RIGHT NOW! - Dear modders, please get in touch >HERE!
TATW hands down, Germanicus battle ai, units the various STRAT file sub mods. All are a great improvement, that said SEGA's original game is the base and I remain complimentary of it.
Now a comparison to SS is a different matter all together, it really depends on my mood. I honestly prefer SS over the TATW main mod, which is why I only play with MOS on top of TATW. RC just changes everything.
ďI am in fact, a hobbit in all but sizeĒ― J.R.R. Tolkien