Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

  1. #1

    Icon1 The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    Source: http://membres.multimania.fr/japon1868/
    Nice pictures there, but annoying advert/pop-ups all over the place.



    - The Shimonosoki War, 1863-1864.

    In 1863, some foreigners in Japan were killed by samurai. Indeed, this ones were against the Europeans since contact with commodore Perry in 1854. The French warships SEMIRAMIS and TANCREDE bombarded Shimonoseki on july 20th, 1863. The French marines troops were landed . They had successfully taken a fortified position. On september 5th, 1864, Shimonoseki was still bombarded by British, French, Dutch and American warships. The ships attacked the prince Nagato's batteries. A expeditionnary corps was landed to destroy the fort. 60 guns were taken, three of them are still to the Invalides (Army museum) at Paris, France. On october 22th, 1864, the Shimonoseki agreement alllowed a return to the peace.





    II - France reorganised the shogunate army (1867-1869).

    On july 1865, Shibata Takenaka (1823-1877) was send in Europe, in France, to prepare the last details of the Yokosuka navals facilities project. But, he was also charged to ask to the British and French government about a military mission in Japan. The British government seemed to not be interested in the japanese demand. Shibata had a rendezvous in september 1865 with the French foreign office minister Drouyn de Lhuys (1865-1881). The minister agree the Japanese proposition.

    On february 1866, the shogun Iemochi Tokugawa (1846-1866) send a letter to the Emperor Napoleon III.

    The minister of War general Randon decided to send in Japan a mission of 15 membres.The staff capitain Charles Sulpice Jules Chanoine, who was at this time an attaché to the military staff of Paris was appointed as chief of the military mission.The mission was composed of 15 instructors, an officer for each weapons - infantery, artillery and cavalery - and 10 non-commissionedofficers, and two soldiers. Chanoine had a good experience of the Far-east as he spend four years in China as chief of the French occupation force during the Second Opium War from 1859 to 1862.

    List of the member of the first Western military mission in Japan :

    - Charles Albert Dubousquet, lieutenant to the 31th Rgt of the line, instructor of infantery,

    - Edouard Messelot, lieutenant to the 20th bataillon of chasseurs à pied, instructor of infantery,

    - Léon Descharmes, lieutenant to the Empress Dragoon Regiment of the Guard, instructor of cavalry,

    - Jules Brunet, lieutenant to the Horse Artillery Regiment of the Guard, instructor of l'artillery,

    - Jean Marlin, sergeant to the 8th bataillon of chasseurs à pied, instructor of infantery,

    - François Bouffier, sergeant to the 8th bataillon of chasseurs à pied, instructor of infantery,

    - Henry Ygrec, sergeant to the 31th Rgt of the line, instructor of infantery,

    - Emile Peyrussel, sergeant, sous-maître de manège à l'école d'état-major, instructor of cavalery,

    - Arthur Fortant, sergeant, Horse Artillery Regiment of the Guard, instructor of artillery,

    - L. Gutthig, trumpeter to the bataillon de chasseurs of the Guard

    - Charles Bonnet, chef armurier second class,

    - Barthélémy Izard, sergeant, chief artificier of the Horse Artillery Regiment of the Guard,

    - Frédéric Valette, sergeant, maître en bois,

    - Jean-Félix Mermet, brigadier, ouvrier en fer,

    - Jourdan, captain, Engineer of the 1st Engineer Regiment,

    - Michel, sergeant, Engineer of the 1st Engineer Regiment,

    The group is directly under the conrol of the minister of War: general Randon.

    In France, the public annoucement of the military mission in Japan tiggered a general enthusiasm. This event appeared on the front page. The officers left Marseilles in november 19th, 1866. First steps of this long trip to Japan: Egypt and Alexandria, they crossed Suez by railroad and went on board "Cambodge" Ship. The ship went to Singapor, Saigon then Hong-Kong. They took an other ship: "l'Alphée". They went to Shanghai and arrived at Yokohama in january 13th, 1867.

    The shogunate had preparated the drill field near Yokohama, Otamura and near Edo, Komaba. Artillerie and cavalery were studied at these two places and the infantery, at Kanda (Edo). The first cadets were student at the Franco-Japanese college of Yokohama. The French officers learn the japanese way of life. The relations between the French and the Japanese were exellent. But the work was hard. The French officer had the job to create an army on the european model for the first time of this country. The shogun engaged some reform, creating a military administation, and a military hierachy on French model. The military arsenals were modernised by the French officers at Yedo and Sekinoji.



    III - The odd story of the French officers during the Japanese civil War (1868-1869).

    The first military mission was at the end with the Japanese imperial restoration. On the october 15th, 1868, the fist group prepared his departure for France. This group was composed with an officer and seven sub-officers. They took a boat of the French Imperial Messagery compagny. An other group composed by captain Chanoine, chief of the military mission in japan, and the other officers Messelot, Jourdan, Brunet, Perrusel, Fortant, Bouffier, Marlin and Cazeneuve, left Japan aboard an american courrier. Du Bousquet stay in Japan as military attaché. This is what capitain Chanoine said to the French minister in Japan, in fact, it was untrue!

    The second group did not leave Japan! All of them choosed to stay in Japan with their cadets except Chanoine to cover their actions. To not be consider as deserter, Brunet decided to hand in one's resignation. He send a letter to capitain Chanoine dated from october 4th, 1868. He send an other letter to the Emperor Napoleon III. In this letter, he explained the reasons why he decided to join the Tokugawa resistance. He said that he will support the Northern daimos because he consisdered its as pro-French and because his former cadets was there.

    Who was capitain Brunet ? He was born in 1838, graduate of l'école polytechnique and of Artillery military School. He joined the Imperial Guard. He participated to the Mexican Campaign where he was honored for his bravery. He became captain in 1867.

    The Tokugawa bakufu came to an official end on November 9th, 1867 with the resignation of the 15th Tokugawa Shogun Tokugawa Yoshinobu and the "restoration" ('Taisei Houkan') of imperial rule. Shortly thereafter in January 1868, the Boshin War (War of the Year of the Dragon) started with the Battle of Toba Fushimi with the defeat of the old shogunate's army by the army of the new government, the armies of Choshu and Satsuma. On october 4th, 1868, Brunet and Cazeneuve went to Shinagawa Bay from Yokosuka. They joined the former shogun fleet led by Takeaki Enomoto. Brunet went on board the amiral ship, Kaiyo-maru. The Enamoto's fleet went to Sendai where he hoped to encourage Yoshikuni Date to help the tokugawa. For his part, Captain Brunet wanted to meet the other French officers Bouffier, Marlin and Fortant. These one with their cadets went to Sendai by road. A conference at Aoba Castle at Sendai on october 27th, 1868, was organised to united the shogunate resistance. Unfortunatly, the victory of imperial forces against Aizu Han changed the situation. The northern resistance begun to collapse. Enamoto decided to go on Hokkaido.



    - Emperor Meiji - -Takeaki Enomoto -

    The Enamoto's fleet left Sendai Bay on november 23th, 1868. A plan prepared by the French officers allowed to Enomoto forces to take Goryokaku fortress. On december 25th, 1868, Enomoto organised elections to create a government like american's one. Capitain Brunet led the military organisation of Goryokaku fortress and Hakodate's line of defense. On march 1869, the imperial government launched the campaign against Hokkaido. On may 20th, 1869, the southern forces landed on Hokkaido and took the Fukuyama fortress. Most of the defenders surrendered to the imperial army. The final attack against Hakodate his launch on june 30th by land and by sea. The Enamoto forces were out numbered. They were 800 against... 7000! In the Goryokaku fortress, Enomoto decided that the fight was now futile. He surrended. This was the end of the Boshin War. Brunet and the other officers were
    Ceci est une signature

  2. #2
    wis's Avatar Miles
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Denmark
    Posts
    363

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    I don't see Tom Cruise anywhere on your list?

  3. #3

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    Lol

    You didn't finish it Drakon. Brunet and the other officers were allowed to travel back to France on the corvette Coetlogon.

  4. #4

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    oops.
    I failed at copy/pasting Cheers Jihada.

    Quote Originally Posted by wis View Post
    I don't see Tom Cruise anywhere on your list?
    As a matter of fact...

    Captain Nathan Algren (T. Cruise) in the film = Capitaine Jules Brunet

    Thumb rule of the US film industry:
    If the enemy isnt french, make it french => British frigate in the book Master and Commander became a French privateer in the film
    If the hero/ally is french, make it american => French captain became a US captain in the Last Samurai

    On topic: I find it fascinating to see the energy Napoléon III put in lost causes:
    helping the CSA against the USA (which had, just as the former japanese bakufu a french rank and organization system)
    then helping the Shogunate against the Imperial forces.
    All finishes in their own lost against Prussia after 1870...
    Fascinating to say the least. Perhaps the search for some kind of political ideal, dunno.
    I guess that without that tragic ending the French would have been ready for Napoléon IV haha
    Last edited by Gauloisier de la Gauloiserie; March 23, 2012 at 12:46 AM.
    Ceci est une signature

  5. #5

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    I've seen the film 'Master abd Commander' but I don't remember all the details or how it differs from the book.
    In the book Aubrey is commanding the brig Sophie and a lot of the story concerns the battles with the Spanish frigate Cacafuego and other actions against the Spanish. At the end there is a description of battles between a British and French squadron near Gibraltar. Do you mean the film changes the Spanish into French ships ? I don't remember.
    Last edited by Jihada; March 23, 2012 at 04:50 AM.

  6. #6

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    Yes, the enemy frigate was british in the book, french in the film.
    Ceci est une signature

  7. #7

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    An american frigate, british vs british would be strange.

  8. #8

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    My bad.... et bien décidement... haha
    I should stop drinking.
    Keyser is right: US frigate.
    Ceci est une signature

  9. #9

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    Some confusion here. I don't know about the film but in the O'Brian book the British brig Sophie,commanded by Jack Aubrey, is involved in action with the Spanish frigate Cacafuego and later action against other Spanish vessels. At the end there is a battle between a British and French squadron in Algeciras Bay. This is before the 1812 War against America which features in later books where HMS Surprise battles various US ships such as the Spartan if I remember right.
    Perhaps the film is loosely based on a few of the books rather than a true account of the first in the series 'Master and Commander'.
    Actually O'Brian is very respectful of Britain's enemies of the time. The series is an excellent read compared to the Hornblower series but O'Brian takes a rather too genteel view of the horrific punishments meted out to RN sailors and portrays life on board as all jolly good fun with caring paternalistic officers, Life on board a RN ship of the time was brutal.
    Last edited by Jihada; March 23, 2012 at 08:23 PM.

  10. #10

    Default Re: The Napoleon III's officers in the Japan of the Last Shogun

    We do agree, Jihada. I took the example of M&C just to make a parallel with the Last Samurai. But it doesnt matter really


    Tokugawa Yoshinobu dressed as a Napoléon III's Général de division (lieutenant general)
    Ceci est une signature

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •