Which race of middle-earth would you be and why? (Read First Post)

[Charger Bolt]

You know what else I notice in books, films and games about the medieval are or fantasy like LOTR yes elves have the bows and dwarves ax but human will use a variety of weapons but the "heroes" that human only have a sword, so there goes that stereo type again I'm this case

[Charger Bolt]

I can't believe the vast difference between those who voted from elves and men, i though this would be a close race but almost seems like its a runaway, also not expected I thought dwarves, hobbits and Ents would have more votes, but I guess most don't consider them exiting people perhaps?

[Mhaedros]

Guys, don't you know there can only be 9 nazgul? The rest of you 12, come and join the dwarves

[Charger Bolt]

Dwarves rule baby

[muller227]

Hobbit: because I am a way peaceful guy at heart, man is well man I know what they are like, Immortality seems daunting and a tad boring, dwarves well not into facial hair or underground living, orcs well I have to deal with enough guys who are basically orcs, why the hell would I want to be the real deal.

[Charger Bolt]

Hobbit: because I am a way peaceful guy at heartl.

Hobbits peaceful? Remember Sam? Pipin? Merry? They murdered orcs in cold blood

[Maiar93]

Yeah, and Frodo was an emo hobbit.

THIS MUST MEAN THAT ALL HOBBITS ARE EMOS!

[Macilrille]

Hobbits peaceful? Remember Sam? Pipin? Merry? They murdered orcs in cold blood

Cold blood?

How do you define "cold blood"?


AFAICR all the Hobbit's kills were in self-defence.

Yeah, and Frodo was an emo hobbit.

THIS MUST MEAN THAT ALL HOBBITS ARE EMOS!

1. How is Frodo an Emo? And how do you define Emo?
2. Socrates is a man, Socrates has a beard, ergo all men has beards...

[Charger Bolt]

Yeah your right not in cold blood, and yeah it was self defense but taking life is taking life, thy could have allowed themselves to be captured or even killed themselves but they made the choice to kill in exchange for Thier well being. What I'm
Saying is Hobbits are no different than men, they are prone to violence too or war too they are no different

[Macilrille]

Yes they are, for as Humans go to wars of expansion and wars of aggression, Hobbits have always merely defended themselves.

And allow me to point out that your argument is fallible, for self-preservation is part of all life forms, and the Hobbits' survival was necessary for the overthrow of the second greatest evil ever. So even if they were stupid enough to not preserve their own lifes, they had to for the greater good.

[Legolose]

It would be apparent who I would be

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[Ngugi]

...is that Arwen from behind?

[smoesville]

1. How is Frodo an Emo? And how do you define Emo?
2. Socrates is a man, Socrates has a beard, ergo all men has beards...

"If she floats, she's a witch."
"What else floats?"
"A duck."
"So if she weighs as much as a duck then she must be a witch..."

[Macilrille]

You forgot "pepples" and "very small churches". Ha ha ha...

[KnightsTemplar]

1. How is Frodo an Emo? And how do you define Emo?
2. Socrates is a man, Socrates has a beard, ergo all men has beards...

warning: sarcasm meter broken

[Enarec]

@Isais: 43 would be humans (32 good, 11 evil) and then we have 53 elves, only 10 more than humans. Not that much of a difference.

I'm more surprised that some actually want to be nazguls, orcs, trolls, thankfully no goblins.

[AragornElessar]

oh yes being a nazgul would be awesome! enslaved without your own will GREAT!

[Macilrille]

:-D also frees you of responsibility... many in modern society like to not accept responsibility for their own actions and life, especially not the consequences...

[Maiar93]

:-D also frees you of responsibility... many in modern society like to not accept responsibility for their own actions and life, especially not the consequences...

Nobody wants to, the current system just is like that.

I predict that it'll change soon, though. Nature is the worst mother ever.

[Heart of Madness]

Hobbit, all they do is eat, sleep, get drunk and smoke "weed", they do a little bit of work now and then. Sounds like a easy life to me!

Same as Curufin. Too much responsibility being a elf. A hobbit would be fine.

Agreed with both of you. I'd love to be a Hobbit.