Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: [S2] Returning Elegance to War (Ch 2)

  1. #1

    Default [S2] Returning Elegance to War (Ch 2)

    Chap 1: A More Civilized Age

    No arrow flies truer than the Chosokabe shot
    But no flight more deadly than the Oda volley.



    After getting a computer that is better than the one that died, it's time to play more Total War: SHOGUN 2 as Steam so elegantly identifies it.

    Take a read, see if you like it.

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    War. War never changes.
    So they say. What they mean is somewhat different. Warfare evolves, grows slowly from 1 to ten to ten thousand. Its end is more horrifying than anyone could anticipate from the start.

    1545. This is Sengoku Jidai, the age of the country at war.
    The exquisite archery of the past has been forgotten, trampled under the feet of a thousand yari ashigaru. Battle has regressed back to the beginning of man's dabbling in the art, Thousands of warriors hack and thrust at one another as though we had only just learned to make yari and forge swords.

    A shameful display all around.
    Men of great stature needs must struggle with the common body to body like animals testing their strength. Victor and defeated are both splattered with the blood of one another. One wades through the reek of the enemy's press to join battle. All because a genius discovered that enough ashigaru with yaris were not as ineffective as their wages and equipment would imply.

    He was not wrong, rather he was not right enough.
    Did not take it to the logical conclusion. Samurai use the yari too, but the bow is their premier weapon. One asks the logical question, why are the ashigaru not equipped in a similar manner?
    The answers are many. That have not trained much - but the same is true of their yari use. They cannot aim - but the target is large. Bows are expensive - save on other equipment, or use simple bows. The cost of outfitting a unit of archers is slightly higher than a unit of yaris. Of course the unit has less men, and wears less armor (almost none). But they are effective.




    A samurai draws his bow in one smooth action, aims and calmly releases. The arrow flies true, striking close to the center of a target.
    "Master, you're amazing! To shoot so well at such a distance!"

    His ashigaru, a newly made unit of yet more Oda bowmen, had been training under him for a week. Of course they did have experience with hunting and simple target practice. However, the realities of shooting in a battle were new to them all.



    "Your turn. Give them a volley. On my order."
    The new archers hurriedly move into a ragged formation, nock arrows and raise their bows, waiting to draw.

    "Shoot!"
    Though they begin to draw as one, inevitably different archers will take different lengths of time to aim and loose. However, the result was still impressive as a hundred and sixty arrows flew down range, thudding into targets."

    Captain: "Not bad. See, you're close to being able to shoot in a proper battle."
    Ashigaru: "But most of the arrows didn't even hit a target."
    Captain: "True. A man is a much bigger target, though he can move. Consider - men don't stand so far apart, or in a single rank, in battle. Especially not in a yari wall."

    The men gathered around nodded. They had seen the yari units drilling in another yard.

    Captain: "For example, if your arrow went low, he might have taken it in the leg. High, in the face. To the side, it would have hit his neighbor or perhaps someone in the ranks behind him."
    Ashigaru: "Don't the Oda have the most fearsome yari walls?"
    Captain: "Much so. But the new doctrine is a wall of arrows. This 'new' wall can be projected as far as you can shoot. Charging massive yari blocks into the enemy is war by brute force. Being better at it than others implies simply that we are better brutes. Rather, the yaris are to be used tactically - but we will go into this later."

    The captain stood up from his folding chair and began to lead his men toward the armory to equip them with a full set of ashigaru armor. A little more training would be necessary to help them adapt to the often ill-fitting protection.
    There was always more work to be done.








    Nobuhide admired his new sword.
    Well, it was an old one. from a time long past, but it remained unstained and most importantly sharp. Unfortunately, it had been dug up out of its rusted iron coffin scabbard-less only a few days ago. The master scabbard-maker was having problems as it was not shaped like a normal sword. For now, his sword bearer had to carry it with the sharp blade wrapped in soft cloth.

    "Men of Oda, we have prepared for this moment. The time has come to cease training and begin a warrior's true work - battling."

    Already about half of the newest yari makers had been cleared out and replaced with boyers and fletchers. However, changing a fundamental army doctrine took time, and only one unit of his newest archer corps was ready enough to be tested in combat. But his enemy had already begun to march.
    The Oda required a complete victory. The momentum from such would carry them onwards, and the unprepared yari and bow troops would have to stream towards the front as Nobuhide's spearhead moved ever forward like an ever growing mass of rocks falling from a mountain.

    "Finish your preparations tonight. Sharpen your sword and make sure your yaris are straight. Count your arrows and bowstrings. Tomorrow will be the start of an age of Oda glory!"




    The plan was only a scratch on the surface of the new methods Nobuhide had in mind.
    First of all, they had to eliminate the enemy horsemen. By forming his archers up directly in front of his spearmen, the Oda lured the rebels' yari cavalry into the forest. When they turned around to run, this encouraged the enemy horsemen even more, and they galloped their horses right into the charging Oda yari troops.

    Nobuhide nodded in approval as the last of the riders disappeared into the distance. His men reordered their formation as the archers moved forward to find of the enemy infantry. Nobuhide headed for the right flank, as his left flank leader, Muneyori, moved into position.







    As his men marched forward, the sound of arrows hitting trees overhead gave warning of enemy archers. However, though the shooters were soon spotted, Nobuhide kept his men moving forward. The arrows did not do much, and it as more important to try and shoot down enemy infantry.

    Unexpectedly, however, the rebels did not retreat. Perhaps they were unaware and thought the Oda infantry were skirmishers. Either way, a unit of yaris burst out of the forest right into the archers that had been harassing them. Following the plan, the units on either side moved up to form a battle line and flank coverage.
    The initial plan had only been slightly disrupted, but in a good way. With the enemy archers caught in a melee it remained to see how the enemy would respond.

    Nobuhide quickly looked over his lines. It seemed they were standing their ground instead of charging forward - good. Even if the enemy tried to pull back, their archers had been pretty badly mangled. Oda archers were shooting out of the forest into the enemy infantry gathered outside the trees, trying to encourage them to simply attack headlong into the Odas' prepared wall.

    Nobuhide: "Wait for it..."







    Nobuhide: "Yes! Look out men, the enemy!"
    Possibly because he was out of the forest, the enemy infantry began heading towards Nobuhide. Oda infantry on the right moved up to block both units, hopefully holding them in place.

    Muneyori: "Most of the enemy have engaged. Forward!"
    On the left flank, Oda infantry were unengaged. Running ahead of them, Muneyori saw a perfect setup for a flanking maneuver - and also the predicament of the right flank. Enemy yari samurai were pounding the center, while a unit of ashigaru were holding the right in place. Oda archery was focusing on the right, but the center was struggling against the better trained samurai.

    Nobuhide's plan called for infantry to flank while the horsemen would circle around to the rear to complete an envelopment. With samurai, though, breaking their ranks would be hard, but hopefully not impossible.






    Two enemy units routed when they saw the Oda horsemen wheeling around to face their backs.
    The bowmen, fleeing from their tormenters at last, pushed their way though the samurai formation, breaking up their ranks. In response, the samurai formed up into something like a circular formation, which they were able to hold, but unfortunately allowed the Oda infantry, though partially depleted, to surround them as help arrived.
    On the right, a unit of ashigaru that had been working on the join between center and the right flank gave up the fight. Standing just outside of the forest's cover, Oda missiles had inflicted serious losses on them, and the horsemen were the last straw.

    Chasing routers, Nobuhide watched as Muneyori turned back around and headed towards the samurai formation. But he didn't have to worry, they were unable to form up before Oda yari were attacking them from all sides. In the confusion, the Oda troops managed to draw swords and infiltrate into the samurais' ranks, turning the battle into a brawl where Oda numbers broke them. There were no survivors.








    The rebel army had not only been broken, but completely destroyed!
    This was the decisive victory that Nobuhide had hoped for. Now, as long as the Oda were kept focused on exterior threats, the momentum from this first blow should keep the clan unified, with arrows pointed in the right direction - away from fellow Oda.



    Spoiler for Details



    Muneyori: "Your rebellion is at an end, and your head is mine!"

    Exultant as he was, Muneyori knew he had to move fast. There were always enemies looking to capitalize on Oda's internal strengths, and who knew but an army was marching towards Owari, sent out as soon as their overlords heard of the new rebel uprising.




    It was necessary to reinforce Owari against such a threat, but also to move forward and seize the initiative, keep foes confused and backpedaling. That was the Oda way.
    With that in mind, Nobuhide led a small force, consisting of his archers, south. They would block the road, and do their best to slow down any enemy that might try to use to to march northwards.


    Casualty Tally:
    Oda losses: 184
    Enemy Losses: 781
    Last edited by Alavaria; February 05, 2012 at 12:00 AM.

  2. #2

    Default Re: [S2] Returning Elegance to War (Ch 1)

    Chap 2: The Manufacturing of a War

    The beginning of war is a yari in one hand and a bow in the other
    For any general, these are the foundations on which victory is built



    The first thing an aspiring general learns to command is a unit of Yari Ashigaru.
    As a staple of Oda warfare for generations, they were ideal for the earlier yari block tactics, however these crude methods of war-fighting are being phased out.

    New Oda tactics call for two main deployment strategies:
    First, and simplest, on the defensive. Rather than the yari block used to push forward and force the enemy back with sheer momentum, the newer yari wall deployment type is to be used defensively. As the name implies, the men are formed up in relatively thin formations in order to extend their frontage. However, it also means that enemies making use of yari blocks can grind their way though such a line.
    Second, they are very capable of fighting horsemen if the latter are caught alone. Flank screening in even thinner lines than on the front also discourages enemy cavalry, leaving them away from the melee and center stage targets for our archers. As archers are obviously vulnerable to horsemen, the flank deployment is invaluable. After enemy horsemen have been neutralized, a simple move forward leads naturally into a flanking action.

    Unlike a block, the wall should not be moved forward due to the brittle nature of the formation. However, these ashigaru are capable of fighting enemy infantry well. Their sidearm is quite capable to doing damage, and they can give even yari samurai a hard time if they manage to infiltrate their formation. Support them with missile fire - the stronger the enemy or less well armored, the earlier and heavier the extent of missile support.
    As capable defensive units, they can be used as bait, or to force the enemy's hand. The sight of a block of Oda yaris on their flank is enough to provoke a reaction, pulling out their reinforcements into arrow range and disrupting their plans. Be aggressive!




    Bow ashigaru are the new force appliers of Oda might, but need support from the yari troops, thus generals learn to use them second.
    Massed archery is the way forward, a true revolution stemming from Oda thought. They are deadly to enemy yari blocks. In time, the powerful Oda Volley will become an intimidating display of Oda missile doctrines, filling the air with thousands of arrows as battle is joined.

    For logistics and army composition, the usual rule of one for one plus two is applied to yari troops, that is, one for each unit of bows and two extra (one for each flank). Naturally, as forces become larger, not all yari troops are on the front, so the flanks become stronger, leading to aggressive flanking-under-bows advances.
    To flank or attack under bows is when infantry are moved under the arrows of friendly archers. Care is necessary to avoid friendly casualties, however the combination of missile attack quickly followed up by an infantry charge can be devastating. In particular, yari formations can be destabilized, leading to vulnerabilities that can be exploited. Do not forget swords in an engagement of two yari units!




    Back in Owari, Nobuhide's military advisers were discussing the recent developments.
    His top adviser firmly quashed any discussion of returning to the mass yari tactics of the past. Simply meeting yari with yari was not a path to ultimate success, and in his mind, that was final.

    Oda ashigaru were already the most numerous around as well as superior in their training and motivation. Development of the archer corps was important to avoid dangerous over-reliance on a single arm of decision.
    Already, the Oda way of recruiting, training and equipping its yari ashigaru were being applied to the many bow units being drawn up. In days to come, this would result in a tradition of mass archery to rival the glory days of the yari.

    The numerous advantages of range could not simply be ignored in a knee-jerk return to brute force.




    As one of the first few generals proficient in the new model armies, Muneyori went on to lead his own forces after being adopted into the Oda ruling family.
    He was also made Commissioner for Finance, a role that would prove to be very prestigious when the recruitment and pay of many thousands of Oda ashigaru was considered.




    Following on a hunch, Muneyori continued his march south, his small scouting and harassment force somehow missing the enemy moving towards Owari.
    Spoiler for Arrows













    My forces
    in the open
    shot to death



    The last Tokugawa died in a horrible manner for a samurai. A thoroughly shameful death by ashigaru arrow.
    His final thought was of what would become an increasingly common sight - samurai being laid waste to by massed archery.

    The Tokugawa forces in the field simply melted away, probably out of fear when they saw the defense of Owari. With no hope of taking it, and no home to return to, the ashigaru returned to their farms and the samurai became ronin overnight.







    This victory was only the cornerstone for the building of a massive Oda empire. Nobuhide could see further successes ahead, though they would be pricier and harder fought. Regardless, progress was taking place.
    Additionally, it acted like a sort of field test, allowing some gauging of the penetrating power of ashigaru bows and arrows against samurai armor at different ranges. While encouraging in that even well made armor was not impenetrable at close range, it was equally troubling to know that a dedicated group of samurai could reach the front lines, albeit taking some casualties. In future battles, the strength of Oda yari formations would still continue to be tested.







    Nobuhide's strategy was known as the shooting arrow. By swiftly moving ahead, the capture of important strategic points was facilitated, denying the enemy crucial resupply and reinforcements.
    Their problems would then be compounded on the field by heavy harassment and skirmishing. By the time it came down to open battle, the trademark Oda Volley would inflict terrible damage to their bodies and morale.

    Also, moving light and pushing hard was not unexpected by the ashigaru. As long as they were not driven ragged, they would put up a good show if the enemy survived long enough to see it!
    His new Waka Poet was also receiving a first hand education in the wonders of massed archery. He would go on to tell tales of the immoveable Oda yari walls and the equally intimidating first volley by its archers. These tales would of course be spread into enemy ears, so that they knew properly what to fear.






    After waiting on the walls of Owari, Muneyori found nothing. The Saito had been intimidated by the Oda and did not even march south of the river. This was a serious display of weakness of their part.
    Following the orders that he had been given, Muneyori assembled a small force and headed north to the border. Nothing.
    Even further, he crossed over into Saito land. Nothing.

    And so he marched his men right up to the walls of the Saito fort and commenced an attack. Careful watch was set for the Saito reinforcements that never came. It seemed that they simply abandoned their fort to the Oda.










    I could not
    Oda yaris break
    one was enough



    As the last hardcore Saito retainer charged into the Oda yaris, sword at the ready, a single spearman stopped him.
    The samurai had avoided, dodged or parried all the yari thrust at him except this one. The speed of his charge drove the sharp point deep into his chest. He stopped in amazement as the ashigaru pulled the weapon free, then, as in their drills, automatically thrust it into the samurai a second time.

    The Saito were finished. Any hope of an organized resistance, let alone attack, had been lost due to their fear of taking to the field.









    Muneyori was well on his way to becoming an excellent strategist. However, for the time being, he was to head south to assist Nobuhide. Little did he know that Mikawa had in fact fallen to surprise attack - which was why the Tokugawa never appeared.
    Whatever agreement the Saito had forged with the Tokugawa was of no value when the latter were removed as a force in the region, and thus they simply gave up any hope of victory in battle.





    After removing one of the dojos that yari samurai used to train in, some expected an archery one to replace it. But no, ashigaru didn't need such specialized training facilities.
    Instead, Oda's small samurai forces would be concentrated on cavalry, specifically fast light cavalry. The new role of samurai was first "head-hunting" enemy generals or chasing routers. More importantly, though, they are capable of engaging enemy horsemen, harassing enemy archers and scouting.




    Our poets in Owari developed a new philosophy known as Chi.
    When asked if this could be used to make more powerful arrows, the military advisors were turned away with a negative answer.




    A minor trade disruption went unnoticed. Who were the Asai anyway?




    About the time strategists in Owari came up with their suggestions for steps forwards, it was already too late.
    Take Mikawa to remove the Tokugawa? Done.
    Remove the Saito? Already accomplished.

    In any case, the Oda would continue marching onwards. This was never in question.




    In fact, Oda forces were massing in Mikawa as Nobuhide counted his units and prepared for the inevitable too-late appearance of an Imagawa force.
    Should they prove too unwilling to march on (now) Oda ground, he would have to take the fight to them. But for now, the forces would stop and increase their numbers, as an attack from not only the Imagawa, but also any remnants of the Tokugawa that they were able to absorb, was no small issue.

    The main plan, however, was to hole up and wait for the enemy to make a move, if indeed he would do so.







    The Mino defense force marches out to confront the remnants of the Saito. After a few months of banditry in the countryside of what had once been their province, enough was enough.
    A small force was sent out in the hopes of a clean removal of these pests. Even though Saito retainers would be present, their obsession with being mounted would give the well-trained Oda spearmen a massive advantage.




    With the agility of mounted troops, however, the new warfare would be put to an early test, with Oda yaris unable to attack until the enemy samurai horsemen committed to an attack.
    The archers were split into two groups. The first group would meet the enemy man for man, but would advance far enough to begin shooting the Saito horsemen. At the same time, the spears would be directly behind them, so that when the horsemen did attack, their mounts would bring them straight into Oda yaris!

    In relative safety, a second unit would assist the front line skirmishers by projecting their missiles into the enemy bowmen to relieve the pressure on their brethren.
    The line grouping of front archers - spears - second line archers would become the most basic core of Oda armies in the future.







    The battle began with a flurry of arrows from the Saito, but the Oda, running forward, managed to avoid the worst of it. A few fell, but the rest quickly reached a good range. Oda arrows flew over the Saito archers, striking the samurai behind them.
    As their horses began to drop, followed by their archers, the Saito leader realized they would not win a proper missile fight. As such, their instinct led them to decide on a head on charge into melee !

    Once the archers saw horsemen bursting through Saito ranks, they began pulling back as spearmen rushed forward in turn with yari's leveled. Horsemen urging their steeds towards the running archers suddenlly found themselves running into an Oda spear formation.

    Oda Yari Ashigaru: Surprise !







    It didn't work as well as hoped. In fact, though an Oda yari wall is nigh imprenetrable to cavalry charges, these men were not in a proper wall formation. In fact, they were mostly running forward blindly while avoiding the archers they were supposed to be defending.
    So the samurai broke though the line of spearmen. But it changed nothing - they were still trapped in a mass of men with yaris, and despite their brave efforts with swords, they were overwhelmed by sheer numbers. Victory!










    We suffered not insignificant losses, however it was a fair and honest battle. The wounded were gathered up and treated as well as possible on the field. Basic treatment of arrow wounds would be an important part of any soldier's training.




    The Imagawa chose to attack. Now that they had made their move, it was time for the Oda to make their move.


    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Casualty Tally:
    Oda losses: (184) + 10 + 9 + 149 = 352
    Enemy Losses: (781) + 60 + 60 + 155 = 1056
    Last edited by Alavaria; February 05, 2012 at 12:04 AM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •