
Originally Posted by
Landil
In fact, the same problem crossed my mind when I was making the roster. As I said, it might need some alteration, with the role of the nobility being one of the major points of discussion.
Your argumentation however, seems faulty. Firstly because the geographical size of Flanders does not say anything about the amount of nobles it had, rather, Flanders had some 500,000 inhabitants during the 14th century, leading to a much higher population density than almost any other region of western Europe. Even this though, does not say much about the actual size of the Flemish nobility (though it can be used to make an estimation). Neither does the number of nobles present at the Battle of the Golden Spurs, because it does not say anything about the number of nobles not attending.
Instead of looking for a way to figure out the exact size of the nobility, I think we should first focus on understanding the role that the nobility had on the battlefield. Most of the knights you would find in any medieval army were small landholders. Only a handful were high nobility: the counts, the barons, and some of the lords. This latter group, rather than fighting together in a cohesive group, usually each commanded their own retinues. The low nobles, forming a much bigger group, were for most part men-at-arms in function, fighting as part of the retinue of a high noble. Only rarely would there be a group of knights, mostly consisting of low nobles and a few of higher stature, fighting together without their retinues, often under the banner of a duke or a king.
I would suggest, with this information in mind, to scrap the Edelike Riddere and Edelike Voetmanne entirely for Flanders, but also to heavily restrict the availability of knights for other factions, to only a few units at any time for the bigger factions (England, France, HRE). In this scenario, the only other way to field knights is through bodyguards, which are also of limited availability. As such, the men-at-arms truly become the mainstay heavy cavalry for any faction.
What do you guys think? Also, Polycarpe, would you like me to help you with anything else research-wise?