OT: The Greatest Fighter in Westeros

[Noobio]

i still think bronn would outbest everyone..i'd say oberyn too, but he used poison, so that's extreme cheating..bronn is the man...sneaky, agile, skilled, streetsmart... everything

[Antoniusz]

In my oppinion any of these fighters have chance against other. It would be just a matter who have better day. Also I don't like the hype "prime" king Robert gets on some forums.

[Noobio]

it's all fiction..so, obviously anyone has a chance..hell, even tyrion chopped off some heads (wtf!) but some would have more chances than others..anyway, who cares

[Sandy]

My vote goes for Balerion the Black Dread. The criteria for this vote was fighters not people. Dragons can definitely fight. Heh.

My champion will eat your champion for breakfast...

Literally

[Pinkie Pie]

Ser Barriston Selmy will have your champions skull turned into soup

[Pinkie Pie]

I have to change my vote to Oberyn Martell. He easily defeated The Mountain in combat.

[Antoniusz]

Actually The Mountain smashed his head if you call that an easy win : P

[Pinkie Pie]

The Mountain never touched him. If it had been a standard fight then Oberyn would not have stood over him in a last effort to wring a confession.

[TWWolfe]

Yeah, oberyn would have won if he had waited a little bit longer to get close enough to use Gregor's sword

[Pinkie Pie]

That specific fight was lost because Oberyn wanted a confession which means any n0ormal fight between them would end in an easy victory for him (although the same defence could be used to say Oberyn only fought so well because he had a reason to).

Sticking all of these fighters into an arena together to fight to the last man would be interesting
People like Robert Baratheon and the Cleganes would kill a lot of people very fast but in the end they would fall to the faster people like Syrio Forel and Jaime Lannister.

[flopsies]

it's all fiction

What do you mean, its all fiction?

[Pinkie Pie]

I am not sure. Is this not taking place on the moon right now?

[-Myth-]

I find your lack of Ser Arthur Dayne disturbing.

[klappspaten]

wtf? The Riding Mountain of course!

[Captain Melon]

Hodor is obviously one of the best fighters and some of the Wildling leaders. The Others I bet have the best fighters because they are superior to humans. Jorah Mormont also is pretty good.

[Antoniusz]

On slight off-topic, I just got my hand of ADWD and started reading. When I got to "Reek" chapters and did some thinking about Ironborn, I realized how badass Balon Greyjoy was having such characters as Euron and Victarion obey his rules and not try anything (especially Euron).

[Skizbot]

On slight off-topic, I just got my hand of ADWD and started reading. When I got to "Reek" chapters and did some thinking about Ironborn, I realized how badass Balon Greyjoy was having such characters as Euron and Victarion obey his rules and not try anything (especially Euron).

Unless the theory is correct that

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Euron hired a faceless man to kill Balon.

[Pinkie Pie]

Hodor is obviously one of the best fighters and some of the Wildling leaders. The Others I bet have the best fighters because they are superior to humans. Jorah Mormont also is pretty good.

Hodor is strong, this does not make him particularly skillful.
Not much information is given about the Others apart from that one defeated a Black Cloak of unknown skill.
Jorah Mormont was almost killed by a lightly armoured Dothraki but other than that we know little of his skills.

wtf? The Riding Mountain of course!

He was defeated by Prince Oberyn Martell (I know som e will say he won but that was because Oberyn wanted a confession and did not kill him at the end).

[Captain Melon]

Brienne is also not bad. I wonder who would win a fight between Sandor and Brienne.

[Pinkie Pie]

I am not sure, Brienne was considered one of Renly's best warriors on par with Ser Loras Tyrell but Sandor Clegane was at least a match for his brother Ser Gregor Clegane.