Originally Posted by
wulfgar610
And once the armor has taken too many cuts, in reality what were the chances of the owner being in good health or even alive? Do you forget we are dealing with an era when life was short, nasty, brutish and cruel.
If armor could provide protection in one round of combat, it has done its most essential work.
I'd forget the anti-leather armor argument, there's too many contemporary ancient sources that refer to its virtue.
Many Roman soldiers would have spent their entire service without seeing a true battle.
On it's own, sure it didn't last like maile in battle, but then it was 1/5 the weight.
Put on the 20kg of double maile and then march 20 miles and tell me how you feel then?
Personally I suspect the muscle cuirass was about giving legionaries the looks, the same was bearskin hats and epaulets did later. Drape maile over an ordinary body and they look underbuilt, drape it over a muscle cuirass they look like a titan.