Need some help to make a decision

[giesbrecht1989]

The thread says it all . .
I changed some units a bit and ended up taking out grenades from grenadiers . . now they seem a bit underpowered, they still have a good accuracy but there reload skill is set to 35 while regular infantry like the British foot is set to 47 in my file. . I was thinking to bump up there reload skill but that just did not feel right at all . . so I was thinking to bump up there melee attack and defense to make 'em more of a "Shoot n' Charge" unit . . I really do not want to put the grenades back so . . any suggestions what I should do with them?

[♔Icebear77♔]

i would do it like this:
- give "good stamina"
- give "immun against loss of men" (dont know the name exactly)
- increase their defense and melee values... (but only +1 vs Lineinf)

[richardsharpe]

I'd give them +morale and +attack. Defense should be similar to other line units, and they don't need to be great marksmen. Also, they were bigger/dressier than other soldiers, so :"good stamina" might not model grenadiers very well. Giving them the ability to scare is also reasonable, though it may OP them. just DONT GIVE THEM GRENADES! lol