GC #45 [Magic] ~ Vote!

**Tzar** · November 01, 2009, 06:46 PM

Nine high quality submission but only one can be a winner and the theme was "Magic" .

Vote for your favourite entry!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

"Members may vote only for one submission and can not vote for their own work. If you do vote for yourself, your submission will be disqualified."

Good luck to you all!!!

**Saint Nicholas** · November 01, 2009, 07:13 PM

Wow all of them are amazing. Think I have to go with 8 though, that just looks badass.

**Rebel Jeb** · November 01, 2009, 08:11 PM

Ratings for all...

Submission 1: 9/10 The picture is good, but something about the right side seems empty. Her not being centered also looks a bit strange. I also prefer a full border, not just top and bottom.
Submission 2: 10/10 Very good, nice lighting, good picture. Nothing noticeably wrong, but nothing that in particular stands out. Just a very good, solid submission. I LOVE the shadow effect!
Submission 3: 6/10 A bit basic, no special things about it, but still a decent submission.
Submission 4: 9.5/10 I like the idea, but he is not centered well. Also I don't really love the text going behind him. Also, again, prefer a full border.
Submission 5: 6.5/10 The left side is lacking, the picture itself isn't super great. I like the effects near him though. And the right side is also a bit empty. Just an average submission, nothing super great.
Submission 6: 5/10 I don't love the shape, nor the picture. The circle is near, but isn't blended and just seems pasted in. The left side is also a bit empty and needs something else.
Submission 7: 10/10 The shape is questionable, but its a very, very good submission. The idea captures Magic very well, though, it could show a bit more of the lady, as though she is the focus of the submission, she isn't anything special looking. Other than that, stellar. Very, very well done.
Submission 8: 8/10 The picture is good, along with the red lightning-like lines. The background though is very basic and not very good at all, which takes a lot away from it.
Submission 9: 10/10 A very good submission. The magic spell he is casting looks amazing, along with the town in the background. My only issue is the text, which is out of place and not very funny. Still, amazing, especially the demon itself.

In the end I go with Submission 9, followed closely by Submission 7 and Submission 2. Those are my favorites.

**Louis Lux** · November 01, 2009, 09:49 PM

Sub 7, really unique.

**Raglan** · November 02, 2009, 06:30 AM

dang i've finally got the time to do one today and i've missed it!

oh well,

sub 1 looks great

**lolgast** · November 02, 2009, 10:53 AM

Went with Marcel so unique and beautifull, but got to love abb's and fev their submissions too
And yes you figure out wich subs I'm talking about

**Subuatai de Bodemloze** · November 02, 2009, 11:32 AM

Sub 1: Nice clean image, but lacks something.
Sub 2: Artistically a great sub but just missing something to clinch the win.
Sub 3: Basic clean sig, nothing bad but nothing great either
Sub 4: good sig but not my cup of tea.
Sub 5: Doesn't really do anything for me.
Sub 6: Well TBH I didn't have the time nor energy this week to fix it up the way I wanted.
Sub 7: Great overall sig, a contender certainly.
Sub 8: Great overall again, a bit grainy in the BG.
Sub 9: Not bad but not great either, and the text seems irrelavant, and out of place to me.

**Wildrek** · November 02, 2009, 01:49 PM

Sub 9 for sure!

**Fev** · November 02, 2009, 03:22 PM

7 for me.

**Giovi** · November 02, 2009, 03:35 PM

Submission 7

**leif_erikson** · November 02, 2009, 06:09 PM

Hot chick gets me vote!

**Eöl** · November 03, 2009, 03:55 PM

8 for me. It is so beautifull. Please everybody look closely to 8 before voting. I first didn't thought it was special, but if you look closely and watch every part it is amazing!!! The lightning is very good. Just wow!