Curial Commentary Thread

[General Brewster]

Indeed it shall not, Halie.
Cum grano salis
Selfironical it is, since the question was about us guys modding anything later than M2K and since I've not released anything for ETW, NTW or S2TW ...
Besides that, if anybody might feel that warscape modders are underrepresented in the CdeC, saddle up your pony and get yourself elected

Only one piece of salt ? to few man to few.

And i may just do that.

[Halie Satanus]

Obi Wan Asterix for Miraculix's Loincloth ...

He'll probably eat it, the old goat..

[Silent Assassin]

Completely agree, next time if I apply you will still find the word.
Also I would like to see people in the cdec who actually know how complicate a mod can be.
In the cded there should be a citizen cdec and artifex cdec. And then not only people who mod RTW 2 from each total war game would be good. ETW and NTW could Actually share 2 people.

Bot not criticize anyone but I'm turned down on saying "furher" and lack of content. Though most of the people in the cdec don't even know how to mod ETW/NTW.. Which seems pretty unfair to me.

Then the cdec send in my case a pm to the people who learned me modding with questions in it. But the guy who learned me 80% wasn't asked anything. He could have easy told everyone how hard it is as a beginner.

This is not me being mad at anyone but really my thoughts about it

I can honestly say that I have no modding experience but I know that it's lopts of work (a friend of mine does that) and I can assure you that some of the present CdeC Councillors have experience with modding and they all said the same, sorry if you feel like you have been mis-judged.

I'm sure you will pass next time.

[Okmin]

Also I've been posting stuff on Warscape modding whenever the CdeC needs it (ETW modder), like in that case. But even so, there's other factors they consider.

But I can say for sure we won't have two separate CdeC's. There's plenty of cases were applicants don't fall clearly into either Artifex or Civitate.

[Mega Tortas de Bodemloze]

In the cded there should be a citizen cdec and artifex cdec.

I've seen the reviews of modders who produce unbeleivable results, crash and burn because they cut corners/took shortcuts when it came to modders permission edicate and stealing other modders work.* In more than one of these instances the councilor who 1st caught the errors was'nt a modder.

Meeting the basic solid citizenship criteria is 50% of the application. If applicants fail to meet this ctriteria then the application tanks no matter how superb the contributions may be.

In modding applications, if there is tangible vocalization by the modding councilors, then the dumb dumbs like me have plenty info to extend and finish their researching with. When there is minimal vocalization, that's when modding appls crash and burn.{become contested and risk being invalidated}


*Most of these applications are never seen because the applicant chooses to keep them private. Just like 98% of the disiplinary cases.

[Aikanįr]

What Megas said and furthermore there is always the possibility for each and every citizen to post in the townhall thread in the CVRIA forum if he feels the need to raise his voice concerning a specific application. There are a couple of examples in the recent past for this.

[General Brewster]

I can honestly say that I have no modding experience but I know that it's lopts of work (a friend of mine does that) and I can assure you that some of the present CdeC Councillors have experience with modding and they all said the same, sorry if you feel like you have been mis-judged.

I'm sure you will pass next time.

You and okmin where the ones who knew where they talked about.

Also I've been posting stuff on Warscape modding whenever the CdeC needs it (ETW modder), like in that case. But even so, there's other factors they consider.

But I can say for sure we won't have two separate CdeC's. There's plenty of cases were applicants don't fall clearly into either Artifex or Civitate.

As above and why not let the people of TWC decide ?

I've seen the reviews of modders who produce unbeleivable results, crash and burn because they cut corners/took shortcuts when it came to modders permission edicate and stealing other modders work.* In more than one of these instances the councilor who 1st caught the errors was'nt a modder.

Meeting the basic solid citizenship criteria is 50% of the application. If applicants fail to meet this ctriteria then the application tanks no matter how superb the contributions may be.

In modding applications, if there is tangible vocalization by the modding councilors, then the dumb dumbs like me have plenty info to extend and finish their researching with. When there is minimal vocalization, that's when modding appls crash and burn.{become contested and risk being invalidated}


*Most of these applications are never seen because the applicant chooses to keep them private. Just like 98% of the disiplinary cases.

It can be because I am tired because I don't get you with this sadly. I think my point is made as you started a thread about it.

[lolIsuck]

Just out of curiosity, what is the topic?

I am still trying to figure that out too...

http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=530090
What is this actually about?

[Okmin]

As above and why not let the people of TWC decide ?

The Curia won't do it for the reasons already stated. And the plebs won't do it because, bluntly, they can't because this isn't a democracy.

[General Brewster]

You know this is pretty ironic considering my former posts which you did not like.

[Okmin]

Which posts?

[General Brewster]

Yh if i say it again the entire cdec will mention it again and I will again fail..
One post btw miss spelled it.

[Bolkonsky]

Yh if i say it again the entire cdec will mention it again and I will again fail..
One post btw miss spelled it.

Yeah, then there was that problem with that thing I won't mention either.

Anyways, it was a huge problem and I think people should definitely amend it, but I'm not gonna say what it is because I don't want to draw attention to it, but yeah, people that were involved should seriously reconsider their position on it.

[General Brewster]

Or they should be actually contacted about it.
Cause I asked all involved even those who weren't and they never got any message not attacking the cdec with this of course.

I wonder what you actually mean. cause you speak of 2 things or that just looks like that. could you clarify in a PM ?

[Chlοė]

This sounds excruciatingly interesting.


I must know what it's about!

[General Brewster]

Steam will do wonders legio.

[Bolkonsky]

Well then discussing it here is clearly off-topic.

[General Brewster]

then return on topic you people asked for opinions now you have them.

[Bolkonsky]

Unfortunately, I do have your opinion of a couple members here, yes.

[General Brewster]

Which is answered by several others in the same thread.