Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 75

Thread: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

  1. #1
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    The Constitution of the Roman Republic
    LEGITIVM DE CIVITATES ROMANI.

    All Citizens of the Republic have, yet are not limited to, the following rights;

    I.The right to vote in elections.
    -
    II.The right to be a candidate in elections.
    -
    III.The right to support any other senator by means of campaigning or offered help in their terms or candidacies.
    -
    IV.The right of free and uncensored thought and expression;Further each citizen can make known his ideas in the senate with the only restriction of the polite and dignified manner of expressing them.
    -
    V.The right to be gifted a clean trial if the citizen is questioned for misdoings against the Res Publica.
    -
    VI.The right of protection from cruel, unusual, or unreasonable punishment
    -
    VII.The Right of the citizen to be represented in his trial by either himself of anyone willing to speak in favor of the defendant.
    -
    VIII.The right to be protected from unwarranted search and seizure.
    _____________________________________________________________
    I.
    Elections of the Res Publica
    This section shall deal with the Republican electoral process

    I.
    The Consular term:
    The consular term will be 1 week, after which period we shall have new elections for the next Consuls. Every two days,the elected official must play a turn, no matter if a conclusion has been reached in the senate. Once elected, the Consuls cannot re-run for office for one Consular term,but can put themselves up for Pro consulship.

    II.
    Censor term:
    The active Censor will be voted each 1 month and cannot be Censor candidate again for one week after the end of his term.

    III.
    Tribunes,Praetors and Quaestor offices:
    For these three offices the previous rules apply;Elections once per week,starting in Friday up to Saturday. The only restriction placed is that the active Tribunus cannot rerun for Tribunal office after two completed terms.

    In General:
    Henceforth the Senate will have three different elections;The Consular Elections will be held at each time the Consuls finish their terms with the maximum delay possible being 20 days after their elections.The Censoris Election will be every two weeks;Finally the Magistrate elections(Tribune of Plebes,Praetor,Quaestor) will be held every weekend.
    _____________________________________________________________________
    II.
    Cursus Honorum
    From this day forward, all senators shall follow their Cursus Honorum. Senators shall declare themselves a Patrician or a Plebeian when they enter the Senatus.

    Patrician Cursus Honorum
    Quaestor – Treasury
    Praetor - Magistrate/Orator
    Consul – Senior Magistrate
    Pro-Consul – Optional Governorship
    Censor – Senior Senator

    Plebeian Cursus Honorum
    Tribune of the Plebs – Senatorial Role with veto power
    Praetor - Magistrate/Orator
    Consul – Senior Magistrate
    Pro-Consul – Optional Governorship
    Censor – Senior Senator
    _____________________________________________________________________
    III.
    On the governing of Political parties:

    A. A political party shall be defined as a group of more than three senators with a common ideological goal, that work together to pass bills and amendments in the senate.

    b. The senate shall make no law restricting the amount or number of political parties.

    c. Political parties shall each be granted their own thread, the ability to create a signature, and the ability to craft an official ideology, which shall be displayed in the first post of their thread.

    d. Political parties are absolutely not allowed to sponsor an official candidate in any election whatsoever. However, they are free to vote for someone based on party affiliation, so long as it is not official.

    II On the Governing of Political Alliances

    a. Any group of senators three or smaller will be officially termed a political alliance, and will not be allowed their own thread, signature, etc.

    b. Political alliances may sponsor a candidate, but he also may not be an official candidate.

    c. Any and all political alliances must be announced, in a thread that shall be designed for such a purpose, and must disband after two terms.
    _______________________________________________________________________
    IV.
    Magistrates Romani
    This section deals with the offices of the Roman republic

    Office of Consul
    (Must have Roma Surrectum mod,Elected position,Heavy workload,Plays the .sav file,Very powerful and dignified position)
    -Must provide the senate with reports of all events happening during his term;
    -Must obey the will of the Senate;If the Consul refuses to comply,he will be severely punished.
    -Both Consul's have the right of Consular veto over each other.
    -The Consul that has the majority of the votes will be the one to play out the game,until the Senate by vote gives the second Consul imperium.For easy discrimination of both,the Senior and Junior terms still apply.
    -He is the General of the Roman army in the field and the Governor of the Republic in peace time;While he can order constructions,he may not recruit legions without the consent of the Senate.Also in the case of war,the Consul must wait for the senate to give him command over some Legions or the right to train his own men,called from now on Consular Legions.
    -In every occasion(invasion,campaign against a foreign enemy etc) the Senate will by vote give imperium to one of the two Consuls.In the case of the Roman army been attacked without declaration of war,the active Consul will lead the battle.
    -The active Consuls,after a positive vote from the Senate,can have some legions faithful to them,called Consular Legions,which can be used at the Consuls discretion.
    -The Consuls can use their men to expand to the so called,Consular Expansion Areas(CEA in short),which will be a province or two under foreign sovereignty and be voted by the Senate.
    -They can have the Pro consul give some battles or be the General in command for some turns if both Consuls will it so.Still,if the senate vote for a Pro consul to lead a war they are obliged to give him the save file.

    Office of Proconsul
    (Appointed Position,High Responsibility Office,Changing Workload,Influential Position,Needs Roma Surrectum)
    Each Consul after finishing his term can apply to the senate to be given some province(s) to govern(the Proconsulate - any province or even a stack of provinces outside Italy).If the vote is passed,the Senator is named Proconsul and given a small army(plus a character) to use as he wills. The Proconsul can run for no other office except from the Censor office unless he is willing to abandon his imperium.His term will last one month, or four full consular terms; He also can ask or be asked in return to lead a campaign by senate or Consuls.

    Office of Censor
    Appointed Position, Influential Position, Moderate Workload, Receives the Game Save, Needs Roma Surrectum.)
    The Censor receives the save game file from the previous Senior Consul, there is only one Censor.
    Their main job is to investigate the previous Senior Consul’s term, and make sure no cheats have been used (e.g. the ‘process_cq’ cheat)
    Make sure no illegal wars are occurring,
    Generally make sure there are no discrepancies in the save game file.
    They must also scrutinize the economy and make suggestions to the senate on how to improve it etc.
    The Censor must then report their findings to the senate in the form of a report.
    Also the Censor must constantly keep the Census updated and make sure the the candidates follow their respective Cursus Honorum.
    A very important job of the Censor is their duty to investigate over senators, however no public action can be taken until they tell either sanada or winter, and have there permission.
    If a senator seems to be distorting, rigging elections in anyway or other matters such as these, it is the Consuls job to investigate further and find ample evidence to lead an Inquiry.

    Office of Princeps Senatus
    (Appointed Position, Most powers Symbolic, Heavy Workload, Responsible Position.)
    There is only ONE Princeps Senatus.
    · Princeps Senatus can be from any party.
    · They should keep track of Motions, Acts, Bills and Votes in the senate and then post their findings in the appropriate thread.
    · They should keep track of Military casualties in battles, wars, conflicts etc and then post their findings in the appropriate thread.
    · They should keep the peace in the senate, by ending debates that degenerate into name calling etc (Note: they do not have the right to end the debates, but if the Princeps decides that a debate has degenerated and sees fit to end it, the Senate should comply)
    Office of Tribune of Plebes
    (Elected Position, Influential Position, Powerful Position, Light Workload.)
    There can be anything up to five members in the Tribune (of the Plebs), however the number of places available is subject to the number of people who put themselves forward for election to that position. The Tribune is there to act in the best interest of the senate and people of Rome, which generally means they request tax reductions etc.
    · The right of Ius intercessionis, The Tribune's Veto. This power is used to counter act Motions, Bills, Acts, Votes etc that the Tribune member feels that it may take away power from the Senate or people.

    Office of Praetor
    (Elected position,Moderate power,Light workload)
    The Praetor is a reporter of shorts; Every once or twice a week he will post an update on how the senate is doing,some personal stories,some funny comments etc.
    The point of this position is to give an update on what the Senate thinks,votes,debates about etc in a funny yet informational way so our members will not get overwhelmed by the number of threads and Rp sessions.

    Office of Quaestor
    (Elected position,Little power,Light workload)
    The Quaestor job will be to keep an eye on the treasury,post the end turn financial reports on the senate etc.His job is in a sense auxiliary to the Censor,so that the Censor can devote to the more important aspects of his job.
    ______________________________________________________________________
    V.
    Offices of the Imperium Romani
    This section deals with a possible switch to an imperial system of government. It outlines offices and details procedures for the transfer of power.
    Imperator Romanum

    (elected position,Very influential Position,Post-Marian office,Monthly term,Final Office achievable)

    Once the Imperial reforms in the military have occurred,the Emperor office will be available;Every elections after the 100BC,the Senate will be presented with a chance to change the Republic into the Roman Empire. If the vote is passed(no vetoes allowed),then the senators will vote on anyone they please on being Emperor.

    The Emperor will have to ratify the will of the Senate or present the senate will alternative motions and\or counter proposals.The Emperor has the power of Imperial veto, or the ability to veto any legislation for any reason whatsoever. He has the power to remove anyone from office and either appoint a successor or start an election. He can take control of the save at any time (pending senate confirmation), and may start any war or alliance he wishes.

    The emperor may ask the senate for any title (eg Lucius Aurelius Lepidus Augustus) pending their approval.

    The only real check on the power of an emperor is the ability of the senate to assassinate or depose him, whichever they wish.

    The Emperor names his heir before the end of his term. He leaves his term by retiring from public life or with his death.

    Imperial Heir

    The imperial heir is one of three people. He can be the emperor's choice of an heir to the throne, a senate sponsored replacement, or an individual that claims himself the true heir.

    Only in cases of assassination or deposition may non-imperial chosen heirs ascend to the throne.

    Heirs can be chosen in one of two ways. Through a senatorial election, or an online battle for which both the winner and the loser writes an AAR post. The winner shall decide if the loser's character should live or die.

    Office of Consul

    Same as the Republican counter part; The Consuls won't have to trouble anymore with Proconsuls but with the Emperor himself,when he asks to be given the save(only after confirmation of the Senate).

    Master of Treasury

    Same as Censor;

    Praefectus Praetorianum

    New office;The Prefect of the Praetorian Guard will be responsible for the Emperor's safety. He decides if an emperor lives or dies in an assassination attempt (Senator Romani) plus they can be appointed by the Emperor to lead a battle;requires Senate's vote. Appointed by the Imperator, usually one of his most trusted servants.

    Princeps Senatus,Praetor,Tribune of Plebes offices

    Same as the Republican counter parts; except that any motion introduced by the emperor and vetoed by the tribunes may be brought up again, as many times as the emperor wishes.

    Senator Romanus

    After the Empire is established the Senators will have to put their motions under the discretion of the Emperor.If though the Senators of Rome feel that they have an irrational Emperor or want the Emperor eliminated in any case they must firstly gather all possible support(all the enlisted Senators be in favor of the assassination) plus having the favor of the Praetorian Guard - in a sense,the Emperor isn't God;He can die for defying the Senate...

    ________________________________________________________________________
    VI.
    On the differences of Laws and Amendments
    Laws
    Laws are any motion passed in the senate with an enforceable goal. ie. the measure passed in your are the senate one
    Quote:
    All bills should be relevant to a single topic. Senseless sections and clauses tacked on disrupt the purpose of a bill. Senators who agree with a certain section of bill but disagree with another are forced to make choices as to which side they favor more. Instead of a bill as a whole package it should be broken into its respective sections and each one voted on individually.

    1. All bill should strive to be simple and to the point.

    2. Irrelevant clauses (not pertaining directly to the main bill) should be removed

    3. Any bill consisting of multiple pieces, and any removed materials should be voted on separate and treated as new bills.


    is a law, and shall not be incorporated into the constitution. Instead, all important laws will be outlined in a new thread called THE TWELVE TABLES


    Ammendments
    Amendments may be proposed in the senate by any member of the senate. They shall require 80% of the non abstaining vote, and shall be put into a separate section of the constitution.

    Tribunes may veto any amendment on any grounds, as may the Imperator.
    ________________________________________________________________________
    VII.
    The technical subtleties of the AAR.


    A. From now on, the Role Play threads are:


    1) Curia Iulia-->The official announcements and motions for anything that goes on in the Republic.
    2) Comitatia Curiata--->The assembly of the social classes, here can we can discuss the laws and how to update the constitution.
    3) Comitatia Legata--->The assembly of the Legates, here we can discuss all matters of war and tactics against the foes of Rome.
    4) Comitatia Popula--->The assembly of the Populi, here we can discuss all things that affect the populace of Rome (taxes, army recruitment, colonization of foreign provinces etc.)


    B. When does a vote considered been carried?


    A vote can be considered carried if the 60% of non-abstaining votes are in favour of said motion. A motion may not be closed if there are less than eight votes total. A motion may not be kept open longer than 3 days.
    Last edited by Winter; January 01, 2008 at 08:51 PM.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  2. #2
    Kritias's Avatar Petite bourgeois
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    2,344

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    How wonderful! When do we start????
    Under the valued patronage of Abdόlmecid I

  3. #3
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    As soon as the elections end, but lets keep this thread on topic. Shouldn't have to tell you Gaius

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  4. #4
    Kritias's Avatar Petite bourgeois
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    2,344

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    It was a trick question,one that a vulgar Plebeian mind would hardly understand...No offense to you,Lepidus!

    Actually very nice work on the con,friend Lepidus...I would like to propose though,that due to shortage of members for the time being we skip the Cursus Honorum,at least the veteran players,in order to have more candidates running these elections.
    Also,we should consider what Caesar Rex proposed;To have someone forward the campaign a little - the CS that is - up to 250-240BC and then start the official AAR...It could save us from days of clamor and time to better organize things.However the SC would have to drive ONLY Pyrrhus away and recruit a legion or two to begin at an interesting but safe for the republic time line!
    Lastly,I would like to propose something about the parties;Lets have our own like Temporantia was or like the extremist party of snoopy this time;Let us not get stuck in historical political coalitions like the Populares and the Optimates which will limit down the possibilities to both party members...
    Under the valued patronage of Abdόlmecid I

  5. #5
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Yes, I didn't even mention the cursus in the entry thread, as we aren't really in the position yet to implement it.

    And certainly we can go with new parties, but there's nothing wrong with re-using the pops and optimates. I was just thinking of restarting the Populares.

    As to playing ahead, the Pyrrhic wars are one of the biggest events in the early Roman RS game, so I don't think it would be wise to skip them. After all, we need something to debate

    And no offense taken, you extravagant, elitist, Patrician.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  6. #6
    sanada's Avatar Decanus
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Anlaby Common
    Posts
    516

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    I believe a new party should be founded, on the Ideals of Democracy and moving power away from the elitist Patricians, and towards the modest Plebians whilst keeping intact the Republic, it would be called "Validus Plebians Romanus Foedus (Powerful Plebians of Rome Alliance)" what do you say?
    Last edited by sanada; December 18, 2007 at 03:56 PM.
    Senator Decime, speaking of the Gauls;
    "...they shall be treated as scum. Scum that needs elimination."
    You Are The Senate an interactive AAR

    Decius Loreius Ancus - Plebeian Senator and Censor.

  7. #7
    Kritias's Avatar Petite bourgeois
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    2,344

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    I wanted to suggest a change in the constitution;I propose we change this
    Quote Originally Posted by Winter View Post

    _____________________________________________________________
    I.
    Elections of the Res Publica
    This section shall deal with the Republican electoral process

    II.
    Censor term:
    The active Censor will be voted each 1 month and cannot be Censor candidate again for one week after the end of his term.
    to :
    Quote Originally Posted by Winter View Post

    _____________________________________________________________
    I.
    Elections of the Res Publica
    This section shall deal with the Republican electoral process

    II.
    Censor term:
    The active Censor will be voted each two weeks and cannot be Censor candidate again for one week after the end of his term.
    The change is in order to avoid having any member tied with one electable office for too long;The republic was about the constant change in leadership and all officers and agents of the republic and this monthly term isn't in good lines with that principle.What do you say?
    Under the valued patronage of Abdόlmecid I

  8. #8
    68 Powers's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts
    1,562

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    i agreee. i do say this optimate dominance is a little boring
    Populares come and fight back jeez
    ‡Peace on earth - Death to the Enemy!‡

  9. #9
    Caesar Rex's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Cape Town, South Africa
    Posts
    1,509

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    The censors usually held office for 18 months. So shortening it to two weeks should equal out to 2 years. You have my vote.
    Co-Founder and Leader at Clan Dream (Multi-National Online Gaming Community)

    Voice Chat @ Discord

  10. #10
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Yes I should say thats enough of a term. And Cato I think people will start coming back once the holidays are over.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  11. #11
    68 Powers's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts
    1,562

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    i do hope so
    ‡Peace on earth - Death to the Enemy!‡

  12. #12
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Question, does the Consular veto power extend over the will of the senate? For example, if the senate ordered a consul to attack a settlement, and the co-consul veto's the other consul's actions, does that make it void? Or does the co-consul have to lead the attack?

    The way I read it, it is the latter.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  13. #13
    68 Powers's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts
    1,562

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    well seince your the Co Consul your under the Consul so i dont think it would or should.
    ‡Peace on earth - Death to the Enemy!‡

  14. #14

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Quote Originally Posted by Winter View Post
    Question, does the Consular veto power extend over the will of the senate? For example, if the senate ordered a consul to attack a settlement, and the co-consul veto's the other consul's actions, does that make it void? Or does the co-consul have to lead the attack?

    The way I read it, it is the latter.
    You probably mean, Consul, that the will of the Senate is the last will. I believe the majority is simply unquestionable, and can overthrow a veto if it wishes.
    "Romans not only easily conquered those who fought by cutting, but mocked them too. For the cut, even delivered with force, frequently does not kill, when the vital parts are protected by equipment and bone. On the contrary, a point brought to bear is fatal at two inches; for it is necessary that whatever vital parts it penetrates, it is immersed. Next, when a cut is delivered, the right arm and flank are exposed. However, the point is delivered with the cover of the body and wounds the enemy before he sees it."

    - Flavius Vegetius Renatus (in Epitoma Rei Militari, ca. 390)

  15. #15
    Caesar Rex's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Cape Town, South Africa
    Posts
    1,509

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    In history the veto could stop any action whether it be Consular or Tribunal. It was used in many occasion to stop the senate. It is what gave the consul power as well as the tribunes. If the co-consul wished to stop an action he could however it is then stopped and not passed over. Can always be brought up again and he would have to veto it again and again and again till out of office. It could bring a great divide in the senate should it be used.
    Co-Founder and Leader at Clan Dream (Multi-National Online Gaming Community)

    Voice Chat @ Discord

  16. #16
    68 Powers's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts
    1,562

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    then can i veto his veto?
    ‡Peace on earth - Death to the Enemy!‡

  17. #17
    Caesar Rex's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Cape Town, South Africa
    Posts
    1,509

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    That Cato is what make the Tribune so powerful. The fact that you can forbid anything.
    Co-Founder and Leader at Clan Dream (Multi-National Online Gaming Community)

    Voice Chat @ Discord

  18. #18
    68 Powers's Avatar Campidoctor
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts
    1,562

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Good..
    ‡Peace on earth - Death to the Enemy!‡

  19. #19
    Winter's Avatar Civitate
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Connecticut, USA
    Posts
    6,696

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Actually...

    Quote Originally Posted by constitution
    ...The right of Ius intercessionis, The Tribune's Veto. This power is used to counter act Motions, Bills, Acts, Votes etc that the Tribune member feels that it may take away power from the Senate or people....
    As you can see, tribunes only have the right to veto motions, bills, acts, and votes in the senate etc as I originally wrote it. If you want to be able to override consular vetoes, which I feel is far too much power for one man, you'll need to amend it.

    Cato, your a patrician anyway, what are you doing as tribune?

    Quote Originally Posted by Rebel Jeb View Post
    Hah, you're always so helpful to threads Winter. No wonder you got citizen!


  20. #20

    Default Re: Comitata Curiata (Law and Constitution discussion)

    Quote Originally Posted by the Constitution
    -Both Consul's have the right of Consular veto over each other.
    Hmmm, this surely means that Sabinus can counter-veto your veto, Junior Consul, if that will produce anything.
    Last edited by Marie Louise von Preussen; January 02, 2008 at 08:05 AM.
    "Romans not only easily conquered those who fought by cutting, but mocked them too. For the cut, even delivered with force, frequently does not kill, when the vital parts are protected by equipment and bone. On the contrary, a point brought to bear is fatal at two inches; for it is necessary that whatever vital parts it penetrates, it is immersed. Next, when a cut is delivered, the right arm and flank are exposed. However, the point is delivered with the cover of the body and wounds the enemy before he sees it."

    - Flavius Vegetius Renatus (in Epitoma Rei Militari, ca. 390)

Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •